Quote:
Originally Posted by FlavorOfLife
No, involved as in become a mahou shoujo. Homura's words on her being too caring is a likely foreshadow. As for dying, that is unknown. Madoka was seperated into pieces when drawn into the witch dimension. Yet she survived fine. Her stretching did not show she was going to die yet. Add to this Homura arrived 1 minute after Sayaka.
|
Maybe, maybe not. Her previous separation could be seen as just her being drawn into the witch world. Once the witch took notice of her, it began to devour her. At any rate, it was quite dangerous, and Sayaka still saved her. And the point being, Madoka is still continuing to get herself involved, even if she isn't an MG.
And in actuality, by Sayaka becoming an MG, Madoka doesn't have to. Now there is someone who can take of the witches. So Sayaka is helping to keep Madoka uninvolved in the MG business.
Quote:
|
Then there is the problem of can she even die inside there? Has any normals been killed inside a witch dimension?
|
Of course normals can die. Take anotehr look at ep 3; when Mami gets her head bitten off, she reverts to her normal clothes, implying that she turned normal. You think normals are 100% safe in a witch dimension? Kyube obviously believed there was some amount of danger (related to how active the witch had become).
Also, since witches deliberately feed on normal people, I would assume it could draw them in.
Quote:
|
Cut off your left hand. There's no wishes in RL. What happens? The vet whose hand gets amputated. He can't shoot anymore. Does he die?
|
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Kamijou was alive, true, but there was no medical technology that would have allowed his hand to return to normal enough to play the violin. He even said he couldn't feel anything with it, implying the death of nerves.
Your original comment was that his hand could be "solved" without wishes. That is blatantly untrue. It's a point of fact: Kamijou would never have been able to play the violin again without a wish (or some other magic or miracle). Heh, it's one of the few facts we have.