Quote:
Originally Posted by Inanis
ah yeah your right.
the wiki just states: "Madoka apparently manages to defeat the witch, but at the expense of her own life"
|
The color of the sky is IMO not as relevant as Kyubey's explanation about the magical potential a girl posses. This potential, Kyubey states, is equivalent to the suffering/burden the girl shoulders.
Now, the Madoka from the first timeline has a normal life, loving family, good friends. As per Kyubey's explanation, her potential in this timeline should be fairly low, at least lower than Mami, who had lost her family before becoming a magical girl, and also lower than Homura, whose health was poor, has no friends, and probably has no family either (as hinted in the drama CD).
So there. There's really no way, IMO, that Madoka from this timeline could possibly beat Walpurgis, even at the cost of her own life.