Quote:
|
I choose number one, personally. But I don't really like the idea of arbitrarily decide that the hints that don't fit well my theory are unimportant or must be interpreted. It's easy to fall victim of personal bias if you act that way. If you do that there are very little chances for you to realize when your theory is wrong.
|
I understand your feelings however most of the meta that's not red truth can't be taken litterally. Think at the scene in which Beato tells Battler her mother's story.
She talks about homunculus and her soul being transferred and such.
Even with red we've to be carefully about her exact wording and how it can be applied to the situation.
So I'm not sure I can discount the idea we've to interpret that sentence... -_-
Guessing the truth in Umineko is rather difficult...