[babbo3d]

Originally Posted by kagato3

Yes


Exactly.

He is still very capable of some emotional responses and it is shown he likes to trigger emotional responses in others.

But we aren't being shown much of the actual situation and even the point of views don't match. Lets take the situation with their father.

Tatsuya believes his father sees him only as a tool, merely used as a piece of recovery equipment for research samples and as as the manga put it not as a researcher used for his knowledge or skills.


Miyuki believes he is trying to use Tatsuya's talents and genius.

These 2 Points of view are pretty incompatible as if Miyuki is right then Tatsuya can't be seen as just a piece of recovery equipment for research samples, If Tatsuya is right then Miyuki is wrong about wanting to leach off his genius.

And what do we see when they meet? Does their father belittle Tatsuya? No. Does he demand he return to working for him? No Does he stick up for the financial manager of the Yotsoba House, who is basically in control of his company? Not really. He reprimands Tatsuya for speaking poorly of his mother and completely misreads him and seems more then a bit taken aback by his statement that he doesn't hate his mother.

True because even if we knew the story from everyone points of view the story wouldn't change much since Tatsuyas action can only come from his decisions which inevitably can from his point of view even if they had the best intentions in the end if he decided to fight them (either because he doesn't know or doesn't care" if they had reasons other than the ones he thinks us knowing everything will not change anything that will happened) .
Before i'm flooded by people telling me I'm wrong ,I'm not saying that if Tatsuya knew everything he would not change his mind. At the end of the day tatsuya is the main character so of course the world will see is influence from his point of view.
About what Miyuki

Spoiler for Miyuki's thoughts on this situation:

The man who by all rights would be the father of these two siblings crumpled before that terror. And in the face of that terror, he belittled and abused his own son. All this she was aware of.

Her elder brother believed that she remained ignorant.

Thus, she pretended not to know.

Father — that man to this day still sought to belittle her elder brother's talent, to give him a false sense of defeatism, seeking to pinion the wings of his spirit and ambition. All this she knows.

How comical.

He originally sought to imprison her elder brother, only to find himself crushed by the fact that his son's talent far exceeded his own.

That son obtained the "resources" he needed to barter for his freedom.

Their father could only watch that one last binding, and was forced to let go.

The only thing that man could do was adopt that phony title, and collect the hollow praises of the masses.

That person was not interested in this, she probably knew this as well.

......She was unable to control her own thoughts.

I got something different i think she only pretended to be trick. AT least on the father i think they are pretty similar views.