[David Johnston]

Originally Posted by aliensporebomb

Weird, but generally has potential.

Spoiler:

I found it ridiculous they couldn't tell the protagonist was a girl.

I think the girl who tossed her luggage in the fountain DID know,
girl bullies usually don't beat up on boys unless they know the
person is weaky weaky, s/he would have been an unknown
quantity.

Oh well.

Spoiler:

No if she'd known, she would have had a much better weapon to use against Haruhi. She wasn't really a bully in general. Just jealous enough to try to provoke Haruhi into getting violent enough to be expelled so Tamaki would be "saved" from his weird fascination with the little "commoner".