Quote:
Originally Posted by Akashin
Why do I keep seeing this get tossed around? Am I missing some part of that timeline that indicates a loss? Unless I am, I fail to see why people keep assuming she lost that fight.
|
ah yeah your right.
the wiki just states: "Madoka
apparently manages to defeat the witch, but at the expense of her own life"
was reading
http://wiki.puella-magi.net/Episode_10
PS:
In TL1 the only hint we get is the color of the sky.. is a yellow/grey .. so likely she actually won that one (even tho the camare just shows a small portion of the sky, i had not noticed the sky color change before)
In TL2 the sky is once again yellow and the only distorcion you can see if the one cause by Madoka's witch form, so yeah they defeated the witch in TL2 too
in TL3 Madoka and Homura are talking after their sould gems became tained , the camera pans around and the witch is no where to be seen , also the sky is on a more normal color , no blue , but yellow.. like a setting sun..the fight likely lasted a lot more)