I don't see why everyone's being so hard on Yumeria. Sure it isn't that great, but it is funny and may possibly have some potential later on...though ep 3 pretty much killed that chance...
Anyway for winners this season, Naruto, Full Metal Alchemist and any other series carried over from a previous season. The mediocre selection of new anime means these series will get more attention. (as if Naruto needed more attention
)
For losers, all the new anime. None of them stand out. Even the best seem only average. Maybe it's just because there were so many good series last season...