AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - Hayate no Gotoku manga (raw discussion only)

GDB · 2013-12-21, 22:56

For the second hand, I don't think Hina's logic works. Assuming the game is two of each number is transparent, then:

Miki shows transparent Q9, three unknowns.
Hina had a transparent 9 and discarded a solid 9. Meaning if Miki had a full house, one of the unknowns would have to be a solid 9.
This leaves two unknowns, which would have to be queens. But... nothing in Hina's logic states why one of those queens would have to be transparent. Logically, there are two solid queens still in the deck.

Also, whooo naked Izumi.

2013-12-21, 22:56	Link #9841
GDB Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2008 Age: 38	For the second hand, I don't think Hina's logic works. Assuming the game is two of each number is transparent, then: Miki shows transparent Q9, three unknowns. Hina had a transparent 9 and discarded a solid 9. Meaning if Miki had a full house, one of the unknowns would have to be a solid 9. This leaves two unknowns, which would have to be queens. But... nothing in Hina's logic states why one of those queens would have to be transparent. Logically, there are two solid queens still in the deck. Also, whooo naked Izumi.