Quote:
Originally Posted by ThereminVox
I tend to rank based on the "consumer review" scale, which is to say that I don't concern myself with "perfection". I've seen plenty of shows that I can't find a single thing wrong with, but I wouldn't give them a 10, because there are just better shows out there. I did give this show a 10, but it wasn't because I didn't have any issues with the story. I just don't score it like a test, where I ding the show a point for everything it does that I don't like.
Which is just my long-winded and self-important way of explaining that I gave it a 10 because i can recommend it without any reservation, even if there was stuff that I could gripe about.
|
That's a good argument, I have to admit.
I like to approach anime ranks from a "literary critique" perspective (only broadening it to account for the importance of visuals and audio, of course), but a "consumer review" is just as valid a way of approaching it, I have to admit.
And yeah, I will say that from a "consumer review" perspective, Madoka deserves whatever the top grade is.