5. JRendell (that lighting just drew my attention in, very nice!)
6. Drake (totally loved it from the very beginning, simple but stunning!)
16. capture (very creative and it's animated!
)
Spoiler for honourable mentions:
17. escimo - hilarious and cute. Had to flip a coin between you and capture.
2. ganbaru - nice unique idea with the arrow
8. AtomicoX - very nice, love the lighting and overall quality of the sig
10. CMHerrera - totally love the use of colour in this one
11. Buttercup~ - made me laugh, cute and funny.
Dang it, wish I can vote for more than 3...o_o. It was hard deciding; despite the smaller number of entries, everyone's was so good.
Awesome theme! For me, it was the lack of time for not entering.