1. Nagi Sanzenin - Hayate no Gotoku
2. Louise Francoise Le Blanc de la Valliere - Zero no Tsukaima
3. Huang Lingyin - Infinite Stratos
4. Mami Futami - Idolm@ster
5. Ai - Amagami SS
6. Ami Futami - Idolm@ster
7. Hibiki Ganeha - Idolm@ster
8. Kobato Hasegawa - Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai
9. Ookami Ryouko - Ookami-san to Shichinin no Nakamatachi
10. Yuuhi Katagiri - Akane-iro ni Somaru Saka
11. Merry Nightmare - Yumekui Merry
12. Maya Takahashi - Amagami SS
I stayed away from voting the characters that I felt had a high chance of getting in, e.g: Sena, since they are likely to get in anyway without my vote. Though in my haste, I completely forgot Aria Kanzaki....
Edit: Minami from Moshidora as well.