LOL! Hi Demi., how's it going? I saw Last Sinner's post and was gonna comment on it but had to look up my new elite-moe character, Shinobu. I *think* she's elite; she really hasn't done much of anything yet. But so cute!
You'd think that if they got Aya Hirano for the role that she'd be saying SOMETHING!
Anyway, I haven't finalized my list of nominees yet. I hate typing, editing, and changing stuff. But LS, I was happy to see Lucy and Pino (of all girls!) on yours. I thought I was the only one around here who thought she was extremely moe~
Pino + melodica = OMG
I'm also gonna go with Sawako
and possibly two girls from Bakemonogatari besides Shinobu.
But Yurie... I don't remember if you were here last year for the extended torture/mutilation that poor Yurie went through... it was
awful 
I couldn't go through that again. Eater and I almost committed ritual suicide over it
And seeing Sakaki mentioned reminds me: Doesn't Sumika Murasame (Sasameki Koto) remind you of Yomi from AzuDaioh? Must be the glasses
Still thinkin'...