Quote:
Originally Posted by AuraTwilight
Things aren't true just because they aren't denied. One of the cousins might have left the room before 24:00, but how the hell did they get back into the room? She was keeping watch THE WHOLE TIME, and all of the cousins were in the room later, murdered around Battler.
Infact, Battler was the only person Erika saw enter all night.
The knock and the letter never existed. There is nothing supporting their existence, and there's no way to withdraw the cousins from the guesthouse because of Erika.
|
No she wasn't there the whole time actually. Did you forgot that Erika started to seal every window after she left the mansion?.
now consider this fact, they never said in Red that the knocked happened on 24:00 and it was only implied by rudolf and erika. This lead me to believe that the Clock in the dining hall was Altered to fool all those inside the dining hall and to fool us.
Sorry,i don't believe that the knock and the letter never existed though. Everything that happened in umineko have an explanation other than they all lied about it.