AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - Umineko no Naku Koro ni

tcaz2 · 2009-10-28, 13:45

Despite some annoying cuts, I honestly think this is the best episode so far. Lots of emotion, lots of intensity.

Some things that disappointed me:

Spoiler for MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THIS EPISODE:

I'm going to give this episode a 10/10 despite those faults, as it entertained me. Something that the anime on a whole has kind of struggled to do at times because of lacking intensity and emotion.

Honestly, if Episode 3 would have been one more episode so they didn't have to rush the things they rush, I'd consider it a good adaption. As it is, however, it was just "decent". Still a hell of a lot better than Episode's 1 and 2.

2009-10-28, 13:45	Link #9
tcaz2 Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2009	Despite some annoying cuts, I honestly think this is the best episode so far. Lots of emotion, lots of intensity. Some things that disappointed me: Spoiler for MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THIS EPISODE: The red web was kind of... underwhelming. The LOL I TROLL U was a bit too sudden, not enough build up. They skipped Lambda threatening Beatrice. And of course the music complaints, but I forgive them because they used Happiness of Marionette, Core, and Dread of the Grave. Still would have liked Tsubasa and Miragecoordinator... I'm going to give this episode a 10/10 despite those faults, as it entertained me. Something that the anime on a whole has kind of struggled to do at times because of lacking intensity and emotion. Honestly, if Episode 3 would have been one more episode so they didn't have to rush the things they rush, I'd consider it a good adaption. As it is, however, it was just "decent". Still a hell of a lot better than Episode's 1 and 2.