Hello everyone, I'm another lurker who decided to post his thinking
I have another theory for the second game.
Spoiler for Umineko from game 2 to 4:
For the chapel, I will borrow what I saw from a video on youtube (from TahYllis), since there's nothing that can destroy the theory yet.
First of all, if you check closely everything said in red for the chapel, it was never stated WHEN the key was given to Maria. And just that breaks it open, since Maria could have received it after the murders and it would still respect all the red.
We can't trust everything we see after all... It's easy to suspect Rosa in that game, but it could be a trap.
As for the fake Kanon, something bugs me... Why were Nanjo and Kumasawa staked last if they died before Gohda, George and Shannon? Didn't Lambdadelta mention that Beatrice made a mistake in this game with the overkill? If this is it.... Then those two weren't dead when we believed it. And for me, that makes them highly suspicious.
And now for something from the third game... Nanjo was killed by someone who was supposed dead. Eva lived. Because the messages in the two bottles said everyone should have been dead, Ange thought that something went wrong in the third game.
So with this, I think Nanjo's killer received a fatal wound that ended him after killing the doctor.... If it is the culprit, nothing wrong. If it was a real victim, then I can think of only one reason for them to kill the doctor.
As for Eva... As a theory put on by TahYllis(youtueb account) said, paranoia and bordering on insanity after both her husband and George's death, she saw Battler as the culprit. Didn't Ange herself realized that Eva may not have been the culprit at the end of her journey?
And that's about it. Just one last thing I would like to confirm on fifth game: