Thread
:
To Aru Majutsu no Index - Episode 9 Discussion / Poll
View Single Post
2008-12-01, 01:39
Link
#
55
tshengchao
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
I can't help find faults with this anime so.. sue me.
Spoiler
for
Episode
:
Then Izzard gets pissed and tries to kill the duo because they trampled on his emotions!? WTF is wrong with Izzard? Touma saved Index for you and so you should thank him, not try to kill him? Though Styil was always the one to persistently spoke in a demeaning manner...
Next, did Izzard really forget that he can use Ars Magna to save Index? The alchemist magic supposedly allows the user's thoughts to become reality. So if Izzard sets his mind to say that Index is free of her problem, the same result should occur in reality. Following my logic, the argument of Ars Magna's effect being temporary (as in it could only have 'freed Index of her problems' in this particular moment only and afterwards her condition will revert) should not hold. This is so as Izzard was actively using Ars Magna to change the reality around him(remember the shattered building?)
and his reality did not fall apart by time or even the *user's ability to use magic*<-if the creators are even planning of using logic to tie up loose ends/explain the story after introducing difficult plot devices like the concept of Ars Magna(note even at the end of the episode the building was there).
This sums up on the more irritating problems that bothered me in the episode. In all what this anime seeks are flashy effects/phenomena which upon further inquisition breaks itself up like kamikaze planes. If I wanna add, the main character had a pretty screwed up mentailty as well.
tshengchao
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by tshengchao