Quote:
Originally Posted by taofd
The issue I have with deconstructor, is that there is NO evidence (and rather, evidence for quite the contrary) of QB having evil intent. However, he just wants to insist that QB is evil because of the acts he is doing. Claiming that QB has evil intent because his actions are evil is a logical fallacy and circular in argument. What I have issue with is not if someone's definition of evil doesn't correspond to my own, but rather the logic one uses to arrive to that conclusion is fundamentally flawed.
|
The logic most people use is as follows:
Kyubey wants Puella Magi to turn into witches.
The only way seen so far for Puella Magi to turn into a witch is to feel extreme despair.
Therefore, Kyubey wants Puella Magi to feel extreme despair.
Wanting people to feel extreme despair falls under my category of evil. The only thing that can qualify as "evidence" to you is Kyubey himself admitting that he is evil. Which will never happen, because Kyubey has no emotions.