AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko

Drifloon · 2012-10-09, 13:05

The part with Shannon and Beatrice still seems weird to me. The main episodes all portray Shannon and Kanon as rebelling against Beatrice, which suggested that there was still some part of Yasu that didn't want to follow Beato's plan. But the way this is written suggests that all the personalities were okay with it, implying that all parts of Yasu were completely resolved to carry out the ceremony. It's a strange inconsistency.

Edit: Actually...come to think of it, Shannon and Kanon are only shown rebelling when Beato tries to kill George and/or Jessica, right? Maybe if Beatrice never tries to kill either of those two, then she never experiences that internal struggle between her personalities.

Edit2: Actually, never mind, I forgot about the scene with Kanon in EP1. Which is particularly weird since he says that he resolved to rebel if Beatrice killed Shannon and left him alive. How strange.

2012-10-09, 13:05	Link #30793
Drifloon Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2011	The part with Shannon and Beatrice still seems weird to me. The main episodes all portray Shannon and Kanon as rebelling against Beatrice, which suggested that there was still some part of Yasu that didn't want to follow Beato's plan. But the way this is written suggests that all the personalities were okay with it, implying that all parts of Yasu were completely resolved to carry out the ceremony. It's a strange inconsistency. Edit: Actually...come to think of it, Shannon and Kanon are only shown rebelling when Beato tries to kill George and/or Jessica, right? Maybe if Beatrice never tries to kill either of those two, then she never experiences that internal struggle between her personalities. Edit2: Actually, never mind, I forgot about the scene with Kanon in EP1. Which is particularly weird since he says that he resolved to rebel if Beatrice killed Shannon and left him alive. How strange. Last edited by Drifloon; 2012-10-09 at 13:24.