|
After reading through the whole thread, it all comes down to the labelling of what 'HD' is. Mentar argues HD is based on perception; while others argue it's based on original intent of broadcast; i.e. resolution.
I find the same situation arises when you try and define what a 'person' is. Is a foetus a 'person'? Is the conceptus a 'person'? Is it only a 'person' when it is born? How about when logical thought processes are in place - i.e. is a 4 year old a 'person', whereas a newborn is not?
My suggestion: Remove the label of HD altogether from releases, unless it really is a HD-mastered, HD-broadcasted, HD-ripped encode. Then all is happy and prosperous in the world.
My opinion: I don't care if it's been re-upscaled as long as it looks damn good and it does. I'm happy.
|