Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mentar
Blah blah blah. I'll turn this around: If you're too tender to stomach the shoujo-ai implications, what are you doing here?
|
If Strawberry Panic will be the yardstick by which you shall measure shoujo-ai, then I am laughing at your lack of scope.
It makes no difference to me whether a show is shoujo-ai or not, the only measures by which I judge a show is whether it is interesting or not, by whether it is beautiful or not, by whether it is innovative or not, by whether it is well-detailed and well-animated or not.
You might be thinking differently, and I am not taking away your right to love this show to death, but consider one thing. I am stating
MY opinion here that Strawberry Panic is none of those things and by
MY own yardstick it is highly mediocre in the areas where it isn't laughingly terrible.
I understand the urge to put down opinions you disagree with, but please, restrain yourself, I am not going to frequent this thread. 8)
Quote:
|
Reducing SP to a yuri-fanservice show after this episode 1 is fairly ridiculous to me. Except for the near-kisses, the fanservice aspect was zero, even though there would have been enough opportunities.
|
Yeah? And what else is there? Please do enlighten me, what the hell else is there in this show besides the yuri fanservice and the multitude of egg-headed clones who differ only by hair color, level of genki-ness and breast size? I am assuming this is what you called "broader in layout".
Do you by any chance consider Negima to be the epitome of anime?