[iKumdo]

Originally Posted by xris

Since this can only be speculation, isn't that what the Theories & future Speculation thread is for?

Originally Posted by BlackNhite

I think he means he wants a thread where he can post an in depth breakdown of the story so far, like a book analysis.
Not sure how that would hold up.

Exactly.
There isn't any "speculation" to it, but it can be considered "theory." The type of theory it is, however, does not match the overall theme of the thread you're talking about Xris. It's a plot analysis that argues the importance of every arc in the manga. It would be nice to open up a new thread and discuss this in depth, but currently, it's collecting dust in the "Theories" thread.