View Single Post
Old 2009-07-05, 07:45   Link #17
ZephyrLeanne
On a sabbatical
 
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Wellington, NZ
Age: 43
Animation Quality: 8.
Kyoani slipped a little. Compared to CLANNAD. Still, one up fom Haruhi.

Voice Actors: 7
So-so. But they're rookies. So.

Script/Editing: 4
I'm sorry to say this, but: THERE WAS ONE!? Ok the problem: There was. This isn't Minami-ke so it does have a general plot. But after a few eps, I think it was thrown out in favor of "weekly randomning".

Hey, you know what? Even "fail script" anime like Myself; Yourself at least looked like they had one.

Soundtrack: 8
Compared to Haruhi, this isn't very spectacular. But it's about the standard of Myself; Yourself, Minami-ke and Maria-sama. So it's still good.

Enjoyment: 7
It was a moe-blob, and I came expecting that. So?

Emotional Involvement: 4
I think even Minami-ke had more of it. I mean. I'm not a girl. Although I do play bass. But this is like "hahahahahhahahahahahahhahah all the way."

OH COME ON. I mean, music isn't meant to be this easy! I'll drag in a Nanaka Yatsushiro, a Kotomi Ichinose and a Shinji Ikari to show the pains of music.

Total avg: 6.4-6.5
This is really, the most dismal showing from Kyoani so far. Ok actually it's problem was THE DAMN SAME AS MYSELF; YOURSELF. Not long enough to actually have a real plot. So there.
__________________
ZephyrLeanne is offline