I base everything purely on my enjoyment alone. So this is definitely a 10/10. The dialogues are the best. I enjoy every interaction between characters in the series especially from Senjougahara. I can listen to Senjougahara teasing Araragi all days even if it's the same scene in the entire episode.
Episode 12 is one of the best I've ever seen. Senjougahara is my most favorite character of all time. This series can't be this awesome without Senjougahara. Oh yeah, Senjougahara fascination!
Seriously, I really don't care about all of those over the top fanservices from Nadeko.
On other note, I actually wish that all characters in this series don't go too far in Saimoe tournament. It will prove that this series doesn't sell well because of fanservices/moe (it's tore!) character.
I hope Kizu will air in next year. I prefer Shinobu in her adult form more than loli form.