[chronotrig]

I'm not sure I understand what Beatrice's reason would be for all this though...
If we follow the Higurashi-logic that gets brought up in EP5, Rosa actually suffers the least of pretty much any character.

After all, she's usually killed before anything sad or terrifying even happens. In EP1 and 4, it's before any murders occur, and given how tired she always is on the first night, she might not even have been fully awake. In EP3, she's convinced that none of the murders are real, and then gets killed instantly (or so it would seem) and presumably before Maria dies.

Even in EP2, when she lives until the end, she actually ends up as the Ushiromiya head and with Maria still alive until the 9th Twilight. Not really a happy ending, but no worse than what anyone else suffered, I think.


We also need to get around that EP5 red: Her (Beatrice's) goal is not to make someone experience fear. And it isn't to have revenge on someone either.