Originally Posted by Sorrow-K
And just to ram the point home, I just watched the latest episode of Hayate no Gotoku, and I laughed more in the first twenty seconds of that than I have in the last six episodes of Lucky Star. If they incite such completely different reactions from me, surely you can see why I'd say I think one is far better than the other.
And personally, I find Lucky Star to be more consistently funny than Hayate's hit or miss episodes. On average, I laugh even more at LS than at HnG.
But hey, if LS isn't for you, it's not for you. Unfortunate, but what can you do? And just because a show isn't universally pleasing (or, more to the point, not pleasing to you) doesn't mean they're bad