Rate That Signature!

[Risa chan]

Senbon Zakura: 8.4/10
shinkou_chou: 8.6/10 looks nice
evil_rick: 9/10 great
lord_iriuu:8.2/10 I think the background doesn't fit the text and the picture, but well done
ichy : I think it needs some text 8.5/10
emerald: 8.4/10 nice, even if i find the bg empty

[ganbaru]

Ichi 8,5/10 who is her ?
ShinkuChou 8,3/10 good focus
Senbob Zakura 8,4/10 look good

( BTW, Evil Rick, exept the use of 2 renders, did you see others problem with my sig? )

[Kelisidina]

Ganbaru 5/10. The background lacks a lot of brushes, the stocks are a bit out of focus. Text is too much and isn't very attractive. Lighting is a bit dull, and it's a bit boring. Perhaps a glare? Still, the composition is nice.

[Emerald Emblem]

Someone sure knows how to use layers, possibly a bit bright though, the render is nice and clear but a bit less brightness on that too.

So overall I'll give you a 9/10

[Chaho-Chi]

Kelisidina: 9/10
Emerald Emblem: 9.5/10 Nice use of effects with the render.

[Kelisidina]

^ 7/10. The stock is too big; I think there needs to be more effects and I cannot see very well cause it's so dark; text is pure love though

[Hs Vi Germania]

Back to business.


Kelisidina: I like these colour effects very well. 9/10
ayu-smepai: like an artwork xD 9/10
Emerald Emblem: 8/10
ganbaru: 8/10
Risa chan: wheeeee 9/10 Comment: 118 kB are too much.... the maximum are 50 kB.
Ichy: I would suggest a border and probably a font. 8/10

[Kelisidina]

His Vi Germania: 7/10. Background is a bit plain, not too fond of the brushes used. Text is too busy, contradicts will the background and the stock blending wasn't very well done. Still, I like the composition

[Risa chan]

The text seems off and the render is too harsh compared to the background. Otherwise nice 8.7/10

[Kelisidina]

^ 7/10. Hmm... Something went wrong with the brushes. Some were blended nicely, but I think others put the stock off. The stock's white outline contradicts the background, and the text is a bit too much I think. And perhaps there's too much dark, perhaps take it down a scale of purple?

[ganbaru]

Kelisidina 8,2/10 I can't read the smaller tehx and BTW your sig is 80693 bytes
Emerald Emblem 8,7/10 a improuvement over the previous version

Originally Posted by Kelisidina

Ganbaru 5/10. The background lacks a lot of brushes, the stocks are a bit out of focus. Text is too much and isn't very attractive. Lighting is a bit dull, and it's a bit boring. Perhaps a glare? Still, the composition is nice.

I didn't use brush, for the render , I should had put the render closer. For the text, I could say than long text are a habit for me ( and this one is far from being the longest ) . And for the lightning , I wanted it to be ''dull'' and beside there is nothing with the renders than could had justified a glare.

[Kelisidina]

^ 5/10 again

Originally Posted by ganbaru

there is nothing with the renders than could had justified a glare.

Actually, I've seen a lot of good banners that placed the glare at the tie of the sailor uniform.

[Chaho-Chi]

Kelisidina: 7.9/10 The effects are good work, but the text nor the render fit each other at all.

[Kelisidina]

^ 7/10 again

[ganbaru]

kelisidina8,3/10 interesting, the text could be reworked

[KimmyChan]

Ichy - 9.5/10
Emerald Emblem - 10/10
Risa chan - 9.5/10
ganbaru - 10/10
Kelisidina - 9.5/10
Hs Vi Germania - 10/10
ayu-smepai - 9.5/10

[Emerald Emblem]

I can always rely on a high rating from you KimmyChan, well most people can but yeah...lol

Kelisidina: 8.1/10 It could use some blending of the render with the background, Text is kinda plain too.

[KimmyChan]

Emerald Emblem - 10/10 (That you can indeed)

[Moonie]

ganbaru - the glow on the edges is somehow distracting. overall, it's okay. 8/10
Emerald Emblem - Azunyan~ 8.5/10
KimmyChan - same comment as your avatar. 9/10

[KimmyChan]

Moonie - 10/10