Rate That Signature!

[The Chaos]

M!rage..The Design don't look bad just what that about ?..8/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Evil Rick: Wooooooah lovely Roen Maiden sig. I am jealous. 9/10
M!rage: I dunno .... this signature could be the background for a real sig. The persons you insert there cannot be seen very well and effects are middle-rate. 6.5/10

[Kelisidina]

Thanks Evil Rick: <3

His vi Germania; 6/10 I like the coloring on his eye but the sketchy lines are hard to the eyes. Not much was done with it, it seems

[Emerald Emblem]

kelisidina: 8.1/10

[Chaho-Chi]

Kelisidina: 8.4/10 You've made good inprovements with color contrast beetween the render and background, but try putting some text.

[ganbaru]

Originally Posted by Kelisidina

Guys, maybe you could give comments on rendering/colors/blending so that everyone knows where to improve... Comments like "Nice" or "I dont like it" doesn't help.

I usualy put at least a comment with my rating but for comment about who improuving a sig it's trickier for many reasons, the most obvious one could be the difference in taste betweem every individual ( when someone may see something boring, someone else may see something peacefull )
Kelisidina 8,7/10 as good as a background is, too much of it might create a impression of emptyness, a text could be the solution ( I am not talking about a text like I use ,a few words would be enough ) And BTW the limit on animesuki is 50000 bytes, not 104529
Emerald Emblem 8,6/10 the background is quite colorful
Ayu-smepai 8,4/10 I am not much interested in that kind of artwork

[Kelisidina]

Oh ok! I understand now guys <3

Mai Tokiha: 6/10 again

[grylsyjaeger]

Kelisidina: Interesting design. I quite like how the overlay affect has been applied to the clothing too. 8/10

[Kelisidina]

@fallshcirmjager; actually it's a triple soft light and a multiply followed by a screen

Fallshcirmjager; 7/10 again

[The Chaos]

Kelisidina..look better than the old version ..8/10

[Bolton]

Sig: 8/10 Well designed, love the blue shading.

[The Chaos]

Bolton..too much effects in The Sig but Lovely Rukia-Chan..8/10

[ganbaru]

Kelisidina 8,8/10 only problem than I can see; 49549 bytes over the limit
Bolton 8,5/10 the backgroung could be said '' too chaotic'' ( at least for my taste ).

[KimmyChan]

Emerald Emblem - 10/10
Bolton - 9/10

[Emerald Emblem]

Kimmy chan - 8.3/10 Could do more with it I feel.
ganabru - 7.7/10 Same as before, maybe a brush or 2 for the background to give it more impact.

[Katocchi]

Originally Posted by Kelisidina

Guys, maybe you could give comments on rendering/colors/blending so that everyone knows where to improve... Comments like "Nice" or "I dont like it" doesn't help.

Okay Kelisidina-san .. maybe you in wrong thread .. if you want someone give Comments or Critics in your Sig, better you go to this Thread --> Here (go to last page to show your sig)
The Profesionals will give you CnC .. b

This thread is only for rate someone Signature .. "Just Rate" or maybe give simple statement .. like "Look Nice" or "Not Bad"

Emerald Emblem - 7.5/10

[Yotsuba]

@Emerald - I love this! It's super happy, bright and simple. 9.5/10

@Katochi - I feel torn, because I love Soul Eater. But I think it's too busy for my tastes. 8/10

Oh, and before someone tells me again that I should put my name on my signature?

よつば is "Yotsuba."

人形姫　is "Doll/Puppet Princess."

[Hs Vi Germania]

Yotsuba: What a couple 9/10
Emerald Emblem: Nice colours. 8.5/10
Bolton: 9/10
Katocchi: I don't like the effects and the design as well, however it is not simply made. I can see your effort. 8.5/10

[The Chaos]

Emerald Emblem..I Like Bright Sig..8.5/10
Yotsuba...kawaii~ ..9/10

[Chaho-Chi]

The Chaos: 9/10
Hs Vi Germania: 9/10