AnimeSuki Forums

Apterous · 2004-09-12, 13:19

CLAMP animated their manga "Wish" not into a full anime series, but a 2 1/2 minute music video. It is original CLAMP animation though, and I thought you might like to list this. Song translated by Sailor Spork Productions.

http://a.scarywater.net/spork/

Apterous · 2004-09-13, 01:33

Not planning on posting it? In its defence, its not an "anime music video," its a few minutes of original CLAMP animation displaying the characters, set to theme music. CLAMP did other videos like this, like "CLAMP in Wonderland." Just wondering what your stand is on it.

JustAnotherFan · 2004-09-13, 02:04

It's yet undecided.

We noticed that it's not a (fanmade) AMV. But even if it's original CLAMP it looks more like a trailer or an omake than an anime.

AnimeSuki does list trailers or omake if they are related to an actual anime, which doesn't seem to be the case here.

Apterous · 2004-09-13, 02:31

I can see where there might be room for debate. ANN Encyclopedia lists it as a stand alone "Special." http://animenewsnetwork.com/encyclop...me.php?id=1175

Anidb lists it as "Music Other," but seems to group it as an episode of the "Clamp in Wonderland" music video specials.
http://anidb.ath.cx/perl-bin/animedb...anime&aid=2534

Out of curiosity, by your definition, would you list the "Clamp in Wonderland" specials since they include cameos of characters from other known anime shows (like RayEarth)?

I need to find more of these "Clamp in Wonderland" videos and find out how their all related to each other.

Ialdaboth · 2004-09-13, 11:47

I think there was a "Clover" special too, doesn't it ?

That is a special I would like to see...

The Clamp in Wondreland was quite funny.

Apterous · 2004-09-13, 14:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ialdaboth

I think there was a "Clover" special too, doesn't it ?

That is a special I would like to see...

The Clamp in Wondreland was quite funny.

That would be cool... I didn't see anything about a Clover special, but I did find something about a really long X MV special with 4 X-Japan songs (called Double X or X^2). If anyone can hook me up with the X or Clover specials (in any quality), let me know so our group can sub it... I've had a lot of trouble tracking down any sort of raws for these (they're obscure and over a decade old). We prolly won't do CLAMP in Wonderland since HnK did that already and did a good job.

Ialdaboth · 2004-09-13, 16:29

Clover clip data. If I remember well it was shown in Japan before a Sakura movie and don't know if it has had a DVD or VHS release. T_T

The final X² clip is splendid ^^ . Wasn't it the same team than the movie ?

Apterous · 2004-09-13, 23:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ialdaboth

Clover clip data. If I remember well it was shown in Japan before a Sakura movie and don't know if it has had a DVD or VHS release. T_T

The final X² clip is splendid ^^ . Wasn't it the same team than the movie ?

I think so. That clip was made as a preview/prequil to the X movie. I'm thinking of subbing it too, if I can get my hands on a copy.

Oh, who can read chinese and has a shipping address in Taiwan?

I found an eBay posting of the Wish video/CD set.
http://cgi.tw.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI....sPageName=WDVW

StarCreator · 2004-09-13, 23:31

If this gets added, I would ask for our copy of CLAMP in Wonderland to be retroactively added, as that would by logic reverse the decision. =p

(The Wish clip is -old-, and is the only animated Wish to exist. There are drama CDs and even a "soundtrack", but no anime is planned to my knowledge.)

Apterous · 2004-09-13, 23:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by StarCreator

If this gets added, I would ask for our copy of CLAMP in Wonderland to be retroactively added, as that would by logic reverse the decision. =p

(The Wish clip is -old-, and is the only animated Wish to exist. There are drama CDs and even a "soundtrack", but no anime is planned to my knowledge.)

I've been talking to them about listing Wish, there's been heavy internal debate. I brought "Clamp in Wonderland" up too. Can of worms, all this.

edit: By the way, I loved Clamp in Wonderland.

Was there a 2nd, or was "Wish" CiW2?

2004-09-12, 13:19	Link #1
Apterous Cutie Honey Fansubber Fansubber Join Date: Jun 2004 Age: 32	Clamp's WISH CLAMP animated their manga "Wish" not into a full anime series, but a 2 1/2 minute music video. It is original CLAMP animation though, and I thought you might like to list this. Song translated by Sailor Spork Productions. http://a.scarywater.net/spork/

2004-09-13, 02:04	Link #3
JustAnotherFan /(bb\|[^b]{2})/ Join Date: Nov 2003	It's yet undecided. We noticed that it's not a (fanmade) AMV. But even if it's original CLAMP it looks more like a trailer or an omake than an anime. AnimeSuki does list trailers or omake if they are related to an actual anime, which doesn't seem to be the case here. __________________ #AnimeSuki IRC channel: #AnimeSuki@irc.synirc.net

2004-09-13, 23:31	Link #9
StarCreator HnK founding lunatic Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Maryland, USA Age: 30	If this gets added, I would ask for our copy of CLAMP in Wonderland to be retroactively added, as that would by logic reverse the decision. =p (The Wish clip is -old-, and is the only animated Wish to exist. There are drama CDs and even a "soundtrack", but no anime is planned to my knowledge.) __________________ * StarCreator * Hikari no Kiseki

2004-09-13, 01:33	Link #2
Apterous Cutie Honey Fansubber Fansubber Join Date: Jun 2004 Age: 32	Not planning on posting it? In its defence, its not an "anime music video," its a few minutes of original CLAMP animation displaying the characters, set to theme music. CLAMP did other videos like this, like "CLAMP in Wonderland." Just wondering what your stand is on it.

2004-09-13, 02:31	Link #4
Apterous Cutie Honey Fansubber Fansubber Join Date: Jun 2004 Age: 32	I can see where there might be room for debate. ANN Encyclopedia lists it as a stand alone "Special." http://animenewsnetwork.com/encyclop...me.php?id=1175 Anidb lists it as "Music Other," but seems to group it as an episode of the "Clamp in Wonderland" music video specials. http://anidb.ath.cx/perl-bin/animedb...anime&aid=2534 Out of curiosity, by your definition, would you list the "Clamp in Wonderland" specials since they include cameos of characters from other known anime shows (like RayEarth)? I need to find more of these "Clamp in Wonderland" videos and find out how their all related to each other.

2004-09-13, 11:47	Link #5
Ialdaboth Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2004	I think there was a "Clover" special too, doesn't it ? That is a special I would like to see... The Clamp in Wondreland was quite funny.

2004-09-13, 16:29	Link #7
Ialdaboth Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2004	Clover clip data. If I remember well it was shown in Japan before a Sakura movie and don't know if it has had a DVD or VHS release. T_T The final X² clip is splendid ^^ . Wasn't it the same team than the movie ?