2010-08-31, 15:31 | Link #3323 |
Hei aka Li Xiansheng
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Kasumigaseki; where contractors dwell.
Age: 35
|
You know, I think it'd be a lot more interesting if it was just the Edolas Lisanna trying to fit in with a dead person's image. Of course it wouldn't be as emotional I guess.
and LOL @ Gazille!
__________________
|
2010-08-31, 18:27 | Link #3328 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: SC
|
I think that the Lisanna before them is earthland Lisanna. Because she must have internal magic or she wouldn't be there. Edo Lisanna would have been stripped of her magic and not be there. Another thing Edo team Natsu would be there with Earthland Team Natsu. I think the Lisanna that died was the Edo one. Say that after the prince arrived from Edo to Earthland, Edo Lisanna was sent by the king to spy on him. Say she bushwacks earthland Lisanna around the time Natsu finds Happy's Egg. Earthland Lisanna get sent to Edo and grows up there. The Lisanna you see in the picture with Mirajane and Elfman was actually Edo Lisanna. My thing is how Mirajane and Elfman going to react to Lisanna being alive.
I'm glad Gajeel finally got his cat partner. |
2010-08-31, 18:32 | Link #3330 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
|
the new chapter is a major hint. The mere fact she's in earthland means that she has inner magic, something Edolas people don't have. Then there's the fact that the full scope of what happened 2 years ago hasn't been mentioned. It's pretty much that Mashima didn't want to show it before now. Possibly for a reason since it could give it away. I'd say there equal evidence for both sides at this point.
|
2010-08-31, 18:45 | Link #3331 |
Eh?
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Canada
|
That chapter was bloody incredible. Bring on the next one.
Highlights for me: Everyone`s different expressions as they were falling in the beginning The Exceed family revelations Baby Wendy FT winning at waving (cookies for those who catch the reference) Panther Lily and Gazille LISANNA (I fear for my Lucy x Natsu flag, it may be replaced)
__________________
|
2010-08-31, 19:55 | Link #3333 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
This Lisanna can be from Earthland, but sorry, the theory that Mystogan sent her to Edoras sounds so wrong in many way.
Anyhow, I'm not positive that if this is indeed Earthland Lisanna, she's having an amnesia right now. It seems to me that she really tried to avoid Natsu and co, because she finds it hard to meet them somehow. But yes, the most likely possibility is that the dead Lisanna was Edo Lisanna. |
2010-08-31, 22:09 | Link #3335 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2007
|
There are too many things that don't make sense.
1. The lisanna that died was earthland lisanna, she could use magic and her grave appeared in past episodes. 2. Edoras people can cross the anima (mistgun was a proof of that) so just because earthland lisanna crossed the anime doesn't mean she has inner magic. 3. Edoras lisanna and earthland lisanna don't use the same kind of magic (like edoras natsu and earthland natsu use different magic). 4. I doubt lissana would stay in earthland, she would miss edoras mirajane and elfman. |
2010-09-01, 01:12 | Link #3337 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
|
Quote:
b. graves don't necessarily have bodies in them (check Rave Master) 2. Mystogan had access and means to study it and find a way. I doubt Lisanna would have a clue what to do even if she got to the anima machine. 3. Mystogan had to give EL-FT something to allow them to use their magic normally in Edolas. If Lisanna is the EL one then she likely didn't get it and had to conform to Edo magic weapons. 4. Same could be said if she was the EL ones and missed the EL Mira and Elfman. |
|
2010-09-01, 01:32 | Link #3338 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2009
|
People really need to apply Occam's Razor a bit more. The simplest explanation for this is that this is Edo-Lisanna was dragged here through some freak circumstance when everything else got pulled out. That everyone will indeed be unhappy with this Lisanna being in the wrong world, but the experts in dimensional travel being in the other world means she's stuck here. Leaving her to join this Fairy Tail in order to make a living while she figures out what to do.
The alternative that this is indeed the deceased EL-Lisanna requires multiple convoluted theories about her flawlessly replacing her Edoras self despite several obstacles to doing so. While still leaving her siblings convinced Elfman had killed her, and Natsu and the rest of the guild convinced she was dead without a body. |
2010-09-01, 01:43 | Link #3339 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
|
Quote:
|
|
Tags |
action, adventure, fantasy, shounen |
Thread Tools | |
|
|