Rate That Signature!

[JRendell]

bigdave: It's a nice concept, but I've got mixed views on the colours. The orange cloud seems really out of place, but I think it's supposed to be an explosion caused by her? 8/10
delirium: Lurvely work. I like the font. 8.8/10

[ganbaru]

JRendell 9,1/10 looking great.

[Haladflire65]

JR: Nice work! Who is it? 9/10

[ganbaru]

Haladflire65 8,8/10 interesting one

[Butter Fly]

ganbaru : 8.5/10 good colours.
Halad : 9.4/10 Awesome!

[delorean2200]

Halad: 10/10 love it!, btw didn't you had one with a similar main render before ?
JRendell: 9.5/10 interesting.

[Haladflire65]

@delorean: I think I might've, since this isn't my first guitar sig. I especially like this particular Les Paul, so... (next one might be a Flying V!)

ganbaru: Nice one, but the sig looks a bit low-q and the reflection not necessary. 8.6/10

[Rikimtasu]

Haladflire65 9/10 Da Guitar! It's a fresh one.
delorean2200 8/10 Haven't finshed SEED yet...
Butter Fly 7/10 Can be better.

[ganbaru]

Rikimtasu 8,3/10 not bad

[delorean2200]

Rikimatsu: 8/10 made me lol a bit.
Ganbaru: 8.6/10 agreeing with Halad.

[ganbaru]

delorean2200 8,6/10 nice

[delirium]

ganbaru: What's with the bottom of those illuminated buildings? It doesn't look right. 7/10
delorean: 6/10 would look so much better with a border.

[JRendell]

@delirium - maybe ganbaru's signature will make more sense if you view the stock.

delorean: Aria right? She was hilarious. 8.8/10
ganbaru: I like it, but I feel the mirror effect is unnecessary. 7/10
delirium: Very nicely done. The yellow suits her. 9/10

[Rikimtasu]

JRendell 9/10
delirium 9.2/10
ganbaru 9.1/10
When rating got lazy vol.2

[delirium]

Originally Posted by JRendell

@delirium - maybe ganbaru's signature will make more sense if you view the stock.

delorean: Aria right? She was hilarious. 8.8/10
ganbaru: I like it, but I feel the mirror effect is unnecessary. 7/10
delirium: Very nicely done. The yellow suits her. 9/10

JRendell: 9/10 cool.
Rikimtasu: 9/10 nice.



The stock image doesn't have that blackening satin effect near the middle of the bottom. That is what I'm talking about, why is it in ganbaru's signature?

[Haladflire65]

Riki: Cute 8.8/10
delirium: Not bad... 8.6/10

[ganbaru]

delirium 8,5/10 interesting

delirium/JRedell, strangely it happened to modified the whole picture's brightness and contrast.

[Rennir]

delorean-8/10 Couldn've done more with it
Halad-8.5/10 Nice to see you trying some new effects and text, but the effect could use a bit of cleaning up, esp around the thumb part

[UltimaWolf]

Rennir: Nice choice for a sig. 8/10

[Kagayaki]

UltimaWolf: Ooh, pretty! 9/10