Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

Rennir 8,9/10 I can't remember if I rated this one before.

[CMHerrera]

Koominator - 8.3/10 Nice transparency on top

[ganbaru]

CMHerrera 8,6/10 simple but nice

[Rennir]

CMHerrera- I think you overdid the glow effect around the render a bit and it looks kind of LQ as a result. Try sharpening the focal a bit and lessening the opacity of that layer (I'm guessing you did gaussian blur + overlay?). Or instead of sharpen (cause PS's default sharpen function is kinda meh...) you can try: New layer>Apply Image>Filter>Other>High Pass and set it to ~10px and the mode to soft light @ 50% opacity.

[Hasumi]

CMHerrera: Nice effect. - 8/10
ganbaru: Like the artwork. - 9/10

[Vena]

Since I've not done this before and it looks like a good-fun time waster, and who doesn't enjoy looking at art?

Detective-san: I really enjoy the show of expressions (the color (and the angle to a lesser degree) changes help to keep the flow from being repetitive and give it a lot of life) and it compliments the avatar you have perfectly. The fact that its a simple colorless with a simple smile is a perfect foil to the more expressive emotions and the richer colors that come with them. (Though that's probably just me looking a little too deeply into things.)

I give the whole set a 9.5/10, can't give a ten on my first go and it could be longer.

[ganbaru]

Vena 8,8/10 good artwork but JPEG would give better quality than .gif

[Krytonis]

ganbaru 9/10 lovely artwork!
CMHerrera 8/10 simple yet so good
Vena 7/10 not bad but quality could be better

[CMHerrera]

Thanks for the tip Rennir I am a little rusty, I haven't really made a signature in a while.

Rennir - 9/10 Did I rate before? Looking good.

How does this look? I am experimenting.

[delorean2200]

Koominator: 9/10 has a few low quality artifacts here and there, but the overall design is nice, its in season and its the season to be merry :P.
ganbaru: 9.5/10 one of your best.
Vena: 8.4/10 agreeing with ganbaru.
CMHerrera: 8.8/10 like your current one more the blue goes better with the render though the hair has a few artifacts/extraction left overs.

[ganbaru]

CMHerrera (posted one) 8,7/10 it do hide some of the rendering error.
delorean2200 8,5/10 nice. BTW it isn't my creation but a gift from Patchy

[Hasumi]

delorean2200: Great picture. - 9/10
ganbaru: I'd expect no less. - 9/10

[Krytonis]

Merry Christmas Everyone!!

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,5/10 the border could be thinner

[Hasumi]

Koominator: Seconding the border. - 8/10

[Krytonis]

ganbaru 9/10 dont remember rating this one

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,6/10 good popping-out signature

[Rennir]

Koominator-8/10 Needs more effects but nice job otherwise

[Krytonis]

ganbaru 9/10 cute

[CMHerrera]

Koominator - 8.5/10 Nice transparency on top and on the side looks good.