Rate That Signature!

[Silvance]

ganbaru - 9.2/10. I like the flowers and the character's design. Might wanna add some text since I think it would look better than having an empty space of white background.

[ganbaru]

Detective-san 8,8/10 did I rated this one before

@ Silvance, it's because it's the textless version

[Akito Kinomoto]

@ ganbaru: I think I'll concur with Silvance on this one. 8.39/10
@ Silvance: A little more weight on the left maybe? Nice border though. 8.41/10
@ Detective-san: 8/10
@ tolido17: I liek Carnage moar. But yeah, it needs a border. 7.9/10
@ ahelo: It needs a border. 7.9/10
@ Rennir: Yeah, I'm not repeating myself thrice. 7.9/10. Very delicious nice picture though.
@ Koominator: Nice border, nice balance, and good contrast especially for blonde hair against a white background. 8.44/10
@ grylsyjaeger: Lol. 8.38/10
@ Kaihan: Mhm. 8.45/10

[Kaihan]

Akito_Kinomoto: Awesome signature. 8.9/10
ganbaru: Already seen the Text version which I thought is better. Out of the last 3 Sig, I like this one the most. 9.0/10
tolido17: Changed signature? But I do like this one better, great effects. 8.9/10
ahelo: Nice mix of Background effects. 8.8/10
Koominator: Great Signature but feels like you had to drop some colors? 8.6/10

[Rennir]

tolido17-8.4/10 Purple doesn't fit in the tag. Brush over his shoulder with another color and set it to soft light or hue to fix it. Either that or make a purple light source

[Krytonis]

Kaihan: 8/10 good effects!

[Silvance]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

@ Silvance, it's because it's the textless version

Ah, that explains it. I was wondering why there's no text since it's always present in your works. I forgot that you also have textless versions of your sigs.



Akito Kinomoto - 9/10. Great work. I love how everything blends well together.
Kaihan - 10/10. You even included Hymnos in it. I like the background too. Last but not least, that's a wonderful close up shot of Mir -- sticking her cute small tongue out.
Rennir - I think I've rated this one before... Still don't get tired looking at it though. D=
Koominator - 8.5/10. I think there's too much glow effect on the text. The rest looks good nonetheless.

[ganbaru]

Akito_Kinomoto 8,8/10 looking great

[Krytonis]

ganbaru: 9/10 Very nice! Good colour blending and harmony! All-in-one! ^^

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,8/10 Actually, mine didn't require much blending...

[Godlike1889]

Silvance: 9.0/10...Ohhh looks very nice! Very well done

[Cold~as~Ice]

Godlike1889 9.2/10 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SASEEuL1xXM
ganbaru 9.0/10 how lovely
koominator 8.9/10 really good quality
silvance- 9.0/10 I'm loving it
kaihan 9.4/10 I like the color

[ganbaru]

tolido17 8,8/10 good effects

[Eragon]

@Godlike 1889 - ........Ahem, nice loop And great depth as well - 8.8

@Ganbaru - Wow its quite different from the your previous sigs I have seen. Very nice - 8.9

@Koominator - You like that C4D quite a lot - 8.5

@Silvance - Very cool - 8.6

@Rennir - She's quite beautiful But her hand is...... distracting (not from an signature point of view)

[Krytonis]

tolido17: 8/10 agreeing with ganbaru but I think you might want to work on the text a bit!

@Eragon I don't use any C4Ds! I rarely use them! This one doesn't have them ^^

[Eragon]

^ Really?................Hmm, seems like I have still a ways to go

A really quick one I came up with. Not too much detail but still your thoughts...

[ganbaru]

Eragon 8,7/10 I like it.
Koominator 8,7/10 no C4d but the usual kind of brush.

[Clarami]

Here are some of my Persona 4 signatures I've collected recently.




What do you all think?

[Silvance]

Kaihan - 8.3/10. Looks really nice except for the lower part, and the text that doesn't blend. Love the art though.
Koominator - 8.5/10. Cool sig. Makes me want to pick up the anime. At any rate, it'd look better without the light effects near the guy, but that's just my two cents. :3
ganbaru - 9.5/10. Simply beautiful. <3
Godlike1889 - 9/10. Amusing loop. It will catch anyones attention, that's for sure. XD
tolido17 - - 9.5/10. I love it! I really love the desing of his suit.
Eragon - 8.5/10. Nice effects.
Deikan - 10/10 for P4 Protagonist. So cool and the effects used emphasizes that even more.
9/10 for Chie, and 9.5/10 for Yukiko. All of them are very stylish.

[Kaihan]

Silvance: Nice Background, like how the text goes well with it. 8.9/10
Deikan: Great effect matching the charcters. MC 9.3/10, Yukiko 9.2/10, Chie 9.0/10.
ganbaru: Again Great work. 9.0/10
Eragon: Nice effect and that character pose. 8.9/10
Koominator: Nice Signature, glow effect works better here. 8.8/10
tolido17: Amazing work. 9.5/10

Originally Posted by Silvance

Eragon - 8.5/20. Nice effects.

20?