Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

Deikan ( used one ) 8,5/10 gif. should be used only for animation, it screw up quality
(posted one) 8,8/10 I do prefer the Chie one but both have great effects.
Silvance 8,7/10 great background
Kaiban 8,6/10 the effect on the background seem to have some issue

[Krytonis]

Silvance: 9/10 very catchy and cool effects!
Kaihan: 8.5/10 I like the idea of the no border, but the bottom bit is different due to the AS sig setup! But it is very creative!
Eragon: 8.5/10 Nice glow effects and good focus! You are getting better!

[Silvance]

Originally Posted by Kaihan

20?

Oops. Thanks for the heads up

Koominator - Great looking signature of Miku. Switching the glow effect to something blue-ish might make it look even better. D=

[delorean2200]

Silvance: 9/10 the Hayase feels a bit blurred but otherwise nice sig XD, she was a great character in Alternative, i liked her personality .
Kaihan: 8.5/10 nice fade effect rather then borders but to bad it gets cut out at the end.
ganbaru: 9/10 simply love the colors.
Koominator:9.5/10 nice effects and nice render of Miku used, great work.

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,8/10 good choice of colors
delorean2200 8,4/10 aren't thoses ''strap'' thing a bit too ridiculous ?

[Clarami]

As some of you may know, I'm a huge ClariS fan because their music is great, plus I fell in love with their anime portrayal designs!

These are sigs of them I've collected not to long ago.




So what do you think? Cool right?

[ganbaru]

Kirito first one 8,4/10
second one 8,7/10 good background

[delorean2200]

Kirito: first one 8.2/10 dunno the elements don't seem to go that well together imho.
second one: 8.5/10 as its been said the background is good but i'm not so sure about the border.

@ganbaru: actually there's a reason for them, she keeps her left hand bound to her back since she is quite strong those straps are for keeping it in place.

[kaitok]

Delorean2200: 8/10 nice cropping, but the troll is trolling loooool.
Ganbaru: 9/10 love the colours! clean and neat.

[Krytonis]

kaitok: 8.6/10 good effects you used there!

[Coldlight]

Kirito- 8.1/10 Not really a fan of smudge effects.
- 8.5/10 Good background, the lines help focus attention on the girls.
ganbaru - 8.9/10 Very artistic, quite like a painting.
delorean2200 - 8.4/10 Nice border effects, but the height causes the text below to get cut off.
kaitok - 8.7/10 The black "screen" effect works, and the glowing particles are a nice touch.
Koominator - 8.9/10 Nice work, though I also agree with Silvance on glow color.

[Kaihan]

Coldlight: Simple but nevertheless looks good. I do like the head tilting the same way as your avatar(almost missed this). 8.7/10
Koominator: Nice background and border shape. maybe change glow angle or color. 8.7/10
kaitok: Like the effect of the background, matches with Insane 8.8/10
delorean2200: good image shot and border matching your avatar 8.5/10
ganbaru: Great signature. like how the character blends with the background. But I see that some of your text is conflicting with the background. 9/10
Kirito: Not too sure about the first one, the smudge effect doesnt seem to go well with the character. 7.5/10
I like the second one, Nice background effect and great text. 8.6/10

[Cold~as~Ice]

Silvance 8.9/10 what does that text say?

koominator 9.1/10 very professional

[ganbaru]

kaitok 8,7/10 interesting effects
kaihan 8,6/10 problem with the form ?
tolido17 8,8/10 great artwork

[Krytonis]

Kaihan: 7.6/10 something wrong with the shape?
tolido17 8/10 good artwork but is it me or does it have low quality?

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,8/10 I said what I had to say on your thread.

[grylsyjaeger]

Koominator: Love Inori but the image just has a very low quality feel to it. And not quite sure if the effects around her suit the background. 7/10

ganbaru: Really like the artwork of this one, mate! Got a larger version of it? 9.5/10

[Cold~as~Ice]

grylsyjaeger 10000/10 I love onani master kurosawa

[Hasumi]

grylsyjaeger: DO YOU EVEN HAVE TO ASK!!!??? - 98347/10

[Godlike1889]

grylsyjaeger: 9.8/10...Simple yet touching, I love it!