AnimeSuki Forums

D-KLAC · 2010-06-16, 06:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chupps

Uhm, your wording is weird, do you support the new project to hopefully spark a continuation of the series because you hate the thought of creating a 'happening' out of nowhere to start a new one?

really don't like this Abomination/CANCER/GARBAGE/DISEASE called geass from let see

1.the LIES really how much are there?

2.the "victims" really how many lives were lost include innocient such as euphie & shirley.

3.hiding the truth really how much more truth to hides?

4.too many WTFH twists etc really too confuse.

5.is "he" alive oh come i know that sword is a trick & othere knew about "it"

overall i got many more reasons but like i a said i HATE geass & only way i ok on it IF they RESTART/REBOOT it or yet new story with time travel to really "SAVE" it.

yea in terms i wanted next geass project be either time travel or a RESTART/REBOOT to prevent those "events" to happen & SAVE it.

Chupps · 2010-06-16, 07:40

Oh, i think then i gave you too much credit when i was confused.
Uhm, to put it short and sweetly i think the problems you have with CG stem from your inability to follow a 'complex' plot. Which isn't a bad thing, not everyone can (or the movie industry would put more focus into those and not action sequels with half baked stories & mediocre directing/acting).

I laughed at the suggestion of time travel introduced into CG

, that really would be diabolical. Time travel in anything to me seems pretty self destructive.

Now i feel like i've wasted a few lines & my time, the perfect answer/solution for you is: "Read/Watch something else if you don't like it"

**monir** · 2010-06-16, 12:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chupps

Oh, i think then i gave you too much credit when i was confused.
Uhm, to put it short and sweetly i think the problems you have with CG stem from your inability to follow a 'complex' plot. Which isn't a bad thing, not everyone can (or the movie industry would put more focus into those and not action sequels with half baked stories & mediocre directing/acting).

I'm sorry to interject, but when exactly did CG have a "complex" plot?

Your response above assumes so much. I also hope Code Geass isn't the only anime you've watched.

*flees before the hordes of CG-fans gets the wind of this outburst.*

bladeofdarkness · 2010-06-16, 12:15

*sniffs the air and gets wind of outburst*

while i do agree that the plot isn't all that complex, what it IS, is badly paced and under developed at times.
especially in the LAST two arcs

Chupps · 2010-06-16, 12:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by monir

I'm sorry to interject, but when exactly did CG have a "complex" plot?

Your response above assumes so much. I also hope Code Geass isn't the only anime you've watched.

*flees before the hordes of CG-fans gets the wind of this outburst.*

Note the apostrophes and what i was hinting towards

Xander · 2010-06-16, 13:58

Complexity is relative...and it's not always an inherently good thing either. In other words, simplicity can also be a virtue.

I would say most of Code Geass is just about as complex (and, looking at the other side of the same coin, convoluted) as your average Gundam series, give or take a couple of exceptions, and leave it at that. There's really no need to make a bigger deal about it. Execution or presentation flaws are an entirely different matter.

To bring this back on topic, at least slightly...one of the reasons why I'm assuming -and hoping- Code Geass Gaiden won't deal with Geass itself or any significant related issues is that there would probably be a potential benefit from focusing on less subjects at any given time, in terms of both plot and production concerns.

D-KLAC · 2010-06-17, 07:25

oh come on do you any regrets or 2nd thought of really NOT like what they did really is just so NOT RIGHT in any ways.

really it's like a total DISASTER really so many "victims" & "events" that should NOT happen.

is is truely a reason why i'm asking this to be RESTART/REBOOT or even yet do a time travel?

for yet to prevent those "happening" & SAVE it.

Cephei Mordred · 2010-06-17, 07:39

This is what I see happening in the new series:

A cameo by Charles and Marianne.

Not expys either, but the actual characters, because it'll probably be revealed that C's World transcends linear time or some bullshit like that.

Xander · 2010-06-17, 09:14

Considering Charles should be alive and in perfect health during the time of the new anime project, I don't think that will be much of a concern.

Once again, I would expect to find more Geass-related or supernatural trickery in the manga, which seems likely given what little we've seen of it so far.

Eternal Dreamer · 2010-06-17, 18:56

Umm, I know this is very sudden, but...I've managed to get a hold of the RAWs for the first chapter of "Shikkoku no Renya". (I was tired of waiting for the bloody thing, so I ordered the magazine over the Internet and finally got it today.) Unfortunately, because of the crack-down on RAWs of manga that's been happening over the Internet recently (mangahelpers. com is a good example of that), I don't really have anywhere to send these, and I'm not able to translate it myself. (I don't know why, but my translations of text in manga always turn out very...iffy, to say the least.) So I've decided to just post this first and ask if anyone of you guys know any good translator/scanlators out there who would be able to put these RAW scans to good use. Otherwise, I'll just try and look for someone myself.

konart · 2010-06-17, 23:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eternal Dreamer

Umm, I know this is very sudden, but...I've managed to get a hold of the RAWs for the first chapter of "Shikkoku no Renya". (I was tired of waiting for the bloody thing, so I ordered the magazine over the Internet and finally got it today.) Unfortunately, because of the crack-down on RAWs of manga that's been happening over the Internet recently (mangahelpers. com is a good example of that), I don't really have anywhere to send these, and I'm not able to translate it myself. (I don't know why, but my translations of text in manga always turn out very...iffy, to say the least.) So I've decided to just post this first and ask if anyone of you guys know any good translator/scanlators out there who would be able to put these RAW scans to good use. Otherwise, I'll just try and look for someone myself.

CXC Scans maybe? They were scanlating about half of chapters of NoN

Eternal Dreamer · 2010-06-18, 12:39

Thanks for the advice, Konart, but I've already been contacted by someone interested in scanlating it, so it's all good now. Considering there's 52 pages in the first chapter, it shouldn't be TOO long before it comes out. (At least we know that it's definitely going to get done now.)

Chupps · 2010-06-18, 13:55

Sweet news, let us know when it's done. I'm eager to read it.

levithian · 2010-06-18, 23:59

Thanks in advance Eternal Dreamer, I am waiting for the chapter.

by the way is this scan new or old ?
I think it is new, please if you can find any new information in it.

http://basementotaku.com/wp-content/...aunch-Scan.jpg

konart · 2010-06-19, 01:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by levithian

Thanks in advance Eternal Dreamer, I am waiting for the chapter.

by the way is this scan new or old ?
I think it is new, please if you can find any new information in it.

http://basementotaku.com/wp-content/...aunch-Scan.jpg

Old one. One of the first of scans dedicated to new manga

Cephei Mordred · 2010-06-21, 13:04

Thing is, will the manga be considered canon? I was under the impression that the manga for Code Geass wasn't canon compared to the anime.

Rising Dragon · 2010-06-21, 13:11

The official stance of Sunrise is that anything that is animated is canon, anything that isn't is not. Ultimately, no one gives a shit about Sunrise's stance on things except Sunrise.

Taniguchi, however, says that the Renya manga is canon to the LotR anime universe.

Eternal Dreamer · 2010-06-21, 13:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cephei Mordred

Thing is, will the manga be considered canon? I was under the impression that the manga for Code Geass wasn't canon compared to the anime.

That was true for the previous manga, like Nightmare of Nunnally and Suzaku of the Counterattack. However, this new one, Shikkoku no Renya or Jet-Black Renya, has been clearly stated by Taniguchi and Takuma to be within Code Geass' official history, so it will be canon.

konart · 2010-06-24, 12:06

http://mangahelpers.com/t/shadowskill/releases/23163

Renya's 1st chapter translation

Kurosu · 2010-06-25, 19:35

I don't think I'm allowed to post links to scanlation sites, so I'll just announced that chapter 1 has been released by CXC Scans, thanks to Eternal Dreamer to providing me the raws.

2010-06-16, 12:15	Link #1704
bladeofdarkness Um-Shmum Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: at GNR, bringing you the truth, no matter how bad it hurts Age: 39	sniffs the air and gets wind of outburst while i do agree that the plot isn't all that complex, what it IS, is badly paced and under developed at times. especially in the LAST two arcs __________________

2010-06-17, 07:25	Link #1707
D-KLAC KLAC OF THE ANIME WORLD Join Date: May 2007 Location: gs series Age: 34	oh come on do you any regrets or 2nd thought of really NOT like what they did really is just so NOT RIGHT in any ways. really it's like a total DISASTER really so many "victims" & "events" that should NOT happen. is is truely a reason why i'm asking this to be RESTART/REBOOT or even yet do a time travel? for yet to prevent those "happening" & SAVE it. __________________ ONCE A GS ALWAYS A GS A KLAC IS JUST TOO COMMIT, HONOR, LOYALTY, PRIDE, ETC TO WORLD OF ANIME WALKING THE PATH OF KLAC ON THE JOURNEY THORUGH THE KLAC-ERA YOU EITHER ANIME NEXUS http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=24159 OR AGAINST THE ANIME http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6WFM...eature=related KLAC OF PERSONALITY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqyG8w0iMPw

2010-06-18, 23:59	Link #1714
levithian Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2010	Thanks in advance Eternal Dreamer, I am waiting for the chapter. by the way is this scan new or old ? I think it is new, please if you can find any new information in it. http://basementotaku.com/wp-content/...aunch-Scan.jpg Last edited by CrowKenobi; 2010-11-26 at 17:32.

2010-06-21, 13:11	Link #1717
Rising Dragon Goat Herder Author Join Date: Jun 2008 Age: 36	The official stance of Sunrise is that anything that is animated is canon, anything that isn't is not. Ultimately, no one gives a shit about Sunrise's stance on things except Sunrise. Taniguchi, however, says that the Renya manga is canon to the LotR anime universe. __________________

2010-06-24, 12:06	Link #1719
konart Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Moscow, RU Age: 35	http://mangahelpers.com/t/shadowskill/releases/23163 Renya's 1st chapter translation __________________

2010-06-16, 07:40	Link #1702
Chupps Member Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: UK Age: 32	Oh, i think then i gave you too much credit when i was confused. Uhm, to put it short and sweetly i think the problems you have with CG stem from your inability to follow a 'complex' plot. Which isn't a bad thing, not everyone can (or the movie industry would put more focus into those and not action sequels with half baked stories & mediocre directing/acting). I laughed at the suggestion of time travel introduced into CG , that really would be diabolical. Time travel in anything to me seems pretty self destructive. Now i feel like i've wasted a few lines & my time, the perfect answer/solution for you is: "Read/Watch something else if you don't like it"

2010-06-16, 13:58	Link #1706
Xander Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2008	Complexity is relative...and it's not always an inherently good thing either. In other words, simplicity can also be a virtue. I would say most of Code Geass is just about as complex (and, looking at the other side of the same coin, convoluted) as your average Gundam series, give or take a couple of exceptions, and leave it at that. There's really no need to make a bigger deal about it. Execution or presentation flaws are an entirely different matter. To bring this back on topic, at least slightly...one of the reasons why I'm assuming -and hoping- Code Geass Gaiden won't deal with Geass itself or any significant related issues is that there would probably be a potential benefit from focusing on less subjects at any given time, in terms of both plot and production concerns.

2010-06-17, 07:39	Link #1708
Cephei Mordred Lord Knight of SYTOM Join Date: Feb 2010	This is what I see happening in the new series: A cameo by Charles and Marianne. Not expys either, but the actual characters, because it'll probably be revealed that C's World transcends linear time or some bullshit like that.

2010-06-17, 09:14	Link #1709
Xander Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2008	Considering Charles should be alive and in perfect health during the time of the new anime project, I don't think that will be much of a concern. Once again, I would expect to find more Geass-related or supernatural trickery in the manga, which seems likely given what little we've seen of it so far.

2010-06-17, 18:56	Link #1710
Eternal Dreamer Seeker of Truth and Lies Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: In your Dreams. And Nightmares	Umm, I know this is very sudden, but...I've managed to get a hold of the RAWs for the first chapter of "Shikkoku no Renya". (I was tired of waiting for the bloody thing, so I ordered the magazine over the Internet and finally got it today.) Unfortunately, because of the crack-down on RAWs of manga that's been happening over the Internet recently (mangahelpers. com is a good example of that), I don't really have anywhere to send these, and I'm not able to translate it myself. (I don't know why, but my translations of text in manga always turn out very...iffy, to say the least.) So I've decided to just post this first and ask if anyone of you guys know any good translator/scanlators out there who would be able to put these RAW scans to good use. Otherwise, I'll just try and look for someone myself.

2010-06-18, 12:39	Link #1712
Eternal Dreamer Seeker of Truth and Lies Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: In your Dreams. And Nightmares	Thanks for the advice, Konart, but I've already been contacted by someone interested in scanlating it, so it's all good now. Considering there's 52 pages in the first chapter, it shouldn't be TOO long before it comes out. (At least we know that it's definitely going to get done now.)

2010-06-18, 13:55	Link #1713
Chupps Member Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: UK Age: 32	Sweet news, let us know when it's done. I'm eager to read it.

2010-06-21, 13:04	Link #1716
Cephei Mordred Lord Knight of SYTOM Join Date: Feb 2010	Thing is, will the manga be considered canon? I was under the impression that the manga for Code Geass wasn't canon compared to the anime.

2010-06-25, 19:35	Link #1720
Kurosu KORA!! Scanlator Join Date: May 2009 Age: 32	I don't think I'm allowed to post links to scanlation sites, so I'll just announced that chapter 1 has been released by CXC Scans, thanks to Eternal Dreamer to providing me the raws.