2006-11-03, 08:14 | Link #21 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
Quote:
Yondaime wasn't even going to be Yondaime had Orochimaru (who fears Itachi) not had a black heart and experimented on his own villagers. |
|
2006-11-03, 09:05 | Link #22 | |
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2006
|
Quote:
That said it appears quite obvious Itachi wouldnt stand the slightest chance versus Yondaime if he were still alive, if it wasnt for MS perhaps. Since according to him, it's a thing no one but another Uchiha can overcome. |
|
2006-11-03, 09:21 | Link #24 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2006-11-03, 09:31 | Link #25 | ||
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2006
|
Quote:
Pretty much as people including me were saying, these skills you just mentioned were countered by Kakashi without huge effort. No, I was not saying Sharingan is the cause of all Itachi's regualr ninja skills. Hence, I wasn't even talking about those skills, as mentioned multiple times in my previous post. Pay attention =D Pretty much, apparently MS is what makes the difference. Itachi says he's the strongest guy because he is at the moment the only guy with MS, therefore undefeatable, according to himself. Apparently he's right since Oro admits it. Yet, Oro thinks he's able to stand a chance versus Itachi once he takes over Sasuke. But wtf why then? Not because his actual skills will change any after tranferring to Sasuke, hell no, nothing will change. More like his new ability as in Sharingan. Sharingan counters Sharingan. No matter how much stronger than Itachi he is (jutsu wise, skill wise), he can't overcome MS. Yet according to himself he can once he takes over Sasuke. Therefore, MS appears to be unrivalled, not Itachi's battle skills. Quote:
|
||
2006-11-03, 10:21 | Link #26 | |
Golden
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: 9th Temple
Age: 45
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2006-11-03, 12:16 | Link #27 |
Hokage
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: USA, NewJersey
|
Itachi is strong because he graduated at the top of his Academy class at age 7, had mastered the Sharingan by age 8, became a Chunin at 10 and was previously an ANBU squad leader at the age of 13. He is one of those one in a million ninja genius freaks born with loads of natural talent from the beginning and yes also because he has teh magekyou.
|
2006-11-03, 14:45 | Link #28 | |
Akatsuki Bart is Tobi
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
Quote:
Wow. I very much disagree. Personally I don't think any of the Akatsuki members is kage level. Well I take that back, some of the kage's have been shown to be good but not great. None of the Akatsuki members would match up to Yondaime or Sandaime (if here were just a little younger). Here's where I disagree with you concerning itachi 1)he's able to counter kurenai's genjutsu and is probably good at countering genjutsu in general, but can he counter any genjutsu? I don't know. I'd say the same of kakashi. So far he's only fallen prey to the tsukyomi genjutsu, but it lasts only a second in real time (72 hours in your head). Who's to say if Itachi experienced it at the hands of someone else, he'd be able to counter it? 2)his taijutsu is good, but how can we be sure its on the same level as say Gai? Kicking kurenai and sending her flying doesn't mean a thing. I bet lee could do the same, or a 1 tailed naruto. Kurenai if you don't know is rather weak physically (or at least seems that way to me) 3)Fast hand seal speed is nice. But who's to say his jutsus have long hand seals? they could be 3 or 4 seal sequences. Then again they could be 25 seal sequences. And I don't recall someone saying they were so fast they couldn't be seen. 4)actually i thought it was an exploding water clone jutsu. In fact I'm pretty sure of it. I always thought it'd be nice if naruto realized what itachi was doing with water and decided to try it with his kage bunshins. but still its a sweet jutsu. however is it kage level? it doesn't really help the argument or hurt it. 5)he countered sasuke's chidori with one hand. sasukes. I'm sure gai could have done it, or even kakashi. doesn't really prove much. sasuke didn't have his best stuff and he wasn't very good. he'd recently lost in a showdown with naruto (almost anyway). 6)well accuracy is great, but it seems like everyone in the naruto universe is pretty good with shuriken anyway, even those little kids at the academny. Tenten has near perfect accuracy, but she's lousy. I see it like this. whats the difference if I hit 90 out of a hundred and you hit 100 out of a 100. Once you get past a certain point in accuracy, each increase in accuracy becomes less and less beneficial. whats the difference between 500 million dollars and 600 million dollars? once you get past a certain point, each additional million becomes less and less valuable. Personally speaking, the only 2 jutsus that make Itachi exceptionally fearsome are the 2 related to his MS. However just how powerful are these jutsus? The tsukyomi jutsu I admit is fearsome. It forces the victim to fight after sustaining 72 hours of severe mental strain, yet only lasts a second in real time. However it doesn't do any physical harm. That is when itachi stabbed kakashi in critical locations during the jutsu, kakashi didn't physically have the wounds. For outside of shikamaru or Naruto, I'm not sure how anyone could plan for it. Yet kakashi did. He tells the itachi clone that he's ready for him (referring to the MS) the second time they meet. So who knows. Anyway, this point is a concession. The amaterasu jutsu however is probably overrated. Here's why I think so. He uses the jutsu to escape from the summoned frog stomach. He burns a hole in the wall about the size of a double door way, burning through the frog stomach and through the wall. Yet people are so impressed. Yes it was a fire breathing frog, but so what? It burned through the frog stomach, and through the wall, and then that its. Its not like it burned through the house next door, and the house after that, and the house after that. Even more just to do that probably cost more than 30% of his chakra. I say this because when the itachi clone fought kakashi it was limited to 30% chakra. However he didn't use either of his MS techniques. The torture technique might not have been used because it cost too much chakra, but actually I think it was avoided because kakashi said he was ready for it. However he didn't use amaterasu. That fight between kakashi and itachi took place after sakura and chiyo left. If itachi had defeated kakashi, he could have easily scooped up his prize naruto. I say this to illustrate that defeating kakashi was extremely to itachi's advantage. Yet he didn't use amaterasu which if it connected would have ended the match. Why? My theory is that it used more than 30% chakra. So back to my first point, it probably costs Itachi 30% of his chakra just to use amaterasu to burn a hole the size of 2 doorways. Wow! What a small range. Consider the range of other jutsus we know. Gaara can fill entire fields with sand, kimimaro's ultimate technique covered about the same area, and so on. So amaterasu using 30% only covers about 2 doorways. I suppose he coul d use 50% and cover a wider area, but still... So far, I've shown amaterasu uses a lot of chakra and covers a relatively small area. How about its targeting. How good is the targeting, because if the targeting is 100% accurate, then more than likely it doesn't matter if it covers a small area. Well there we can't be sure. All we saw was a flash of light, and then the 2 akatsuki villains are shown escaping. We don't know if amaterasu is slow or fast. We know it burns through stuff extremely quickly, but how fast it is we don't know. It could move as fast as a shuriken or instantly. If itachi can miss with amaterasu, then all of a sudden its not such a great jutsu. Or if he can be fooled (ie, lots of kagebunshins around-- that'd also be a good plan for the genjutsu, as he has to look at you for jutsu to work) then its not so great. Anyway, I have to go now. Those are just some thoughts. I'll finish this earlier, because I have one or 2 more good points to make. Last edited by Suna no tate; 2006-11-03 at 15:55. |
|
2006-11-03, 16:14 | Link #29 | ||||||||
The Ironman
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||||
2006-11-03, 17:15 | Link #30 | |
Conspiracy Theorist
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
We know Amaterasu is instant as described in the books. The targetting is probably difficult but this is Itachi we are talking about; the person with the best accuracy in the entire series (other people can be as good as him, but never better than him). It only did a small area of damage because Itachi wanted it to be a small area of damage. Since it destroys what is in Itachi's eyesight, he purposively went close enough to the object to make sure that the wall is destroyed. Granted, the jutsu has a ton of weaknesses but as far as one on one go; practically nothing can get around that. All Itachi has to do is look at you and that is it. In short, it isn't overrated but actually very underrated.
__________________
|
|
2006-11-03, 17:33 | Link #31 |
✖ ǝʇ ɯıqnɾl ☆
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Mortuary : D
|
Itachi by far the strongest chracter in Naruto . Yondi was supposed to be a genius but nothing much is known about him so it would be wrong to speculate .
And using his graduation age as coefficient for being the strongest is not a valid point . That makes Itachi a child prodigy nothing more nothing less . Itachi has this thing which no one posses ' lust for power ' , Itachi was willing to sacrfice his own family and best freind in order to become stronger, to gain power that makes him stand out . Oro also has that , but Oro does not have a distuinguished blood-line . So purely in terms of Genius you call Oro a genius . Coz Itachi was born with a gift ( ie Sharingam ) . But when it comes to the strongest Shinobi it has to be hands down Itachi . We dont know how Itachi will fair against Jiraiya or Tsunade so its to early to say anything .
__________________
|
2006-11-03, 17:46 | Link #32 | ||
Golden
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: 9th Temple
Age: 45
|
Given Im already retired when it comes to Debates regarding Itachi’s power, I will let the New Generation of poster have some fun
Quote:
I Just quoted this part to Clear the confussion of both you and Suan no Tate, Itachi Clone that exploded was a Kage Bushin. (it was said like 2 times in that chapter.) And The exploding part of the Kage Bushin seems to be a tottaly different Jutsu, and it’s A-Ranked, its name in Japanese is “Bunshin Daibakuha” Quote:
Spoiler:
Just a friendly reminder to all, use spoiler tags..Have fun!!!!!!!!
__________________
|
||
2006-11-03, 18:54 | Link #33 |
Akatsuki Bart is Tobi
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
I will conceed that amaterasu burns through stuff instantly, but how fast it travels is questionable, and even if it travels near instantly, maybe he can still miss. Forgive the X-Men allusion, but cyclops shoots laser beams at the speed of light, and he seems to miss an awful lot. You could say he restricted himself to a small area, but even then that hurts the case as to the usefulness of the technique. If such a small area requires so much chakra (seeing as Itachi was really tuckered), that would worsen its usefulness. then you're really saying, a limited amaterasu really tired him. How about a normal amaterasu? Well then, if everything is consistent, a normal amaterasu that obliterates everything in the field of vision, would kill him because it costs so much chakra. Its better to assume, that that distance and that damage area is the normal amount. And also keep in mind that it burned through just the frog stomach, and the wall, and that was it. It didn't like burn through the next 4 houses or anything. Can it burn through 3 bishamon gates? Can it burn through naruto's chakra shield in a high tailed form? Who knows...Its interesting though that if these flames are so hot, how come there were residual flames that didn't keep on burning through stuff? (Its also interesting to note that , in the anime at the end of the tunnel that Itachi and kisame escaped from, there was a huge window that covered most of the end of that tunnel. What?! A window?! That completely blew my mind!)
If that was a kage bunshin, then the anime was wrong, because I so distinctly remember the bunshin forming from water. But who knows, I'll take a look tonight and see. I do believe you though rurik when you say what the manga says. Oh about the hand seal speed, its been thought that perhaps the reason for the large akatsuki cloaks is that it hides hand seal motions, making the user seem faster at techniques than normal. Then it'd have a purpose besides just being cool looking (because I definitely want one). Still it could be possible that we're just not shown the hand seal. After all, when kakashi was fighting zabuza, nobody saw him copy zabuza's hand seals and form a clone either. but I will concede that fast hand seals itachi probably has and that makes him very cool. I do have one question though and I think its a valid one. It does seem that itachi mastered an exploding shadow clone jutsu. It was a shadow clone in the mange. However, how can he afford to do that considering our understanding of how shadow clone jutsu works? He only made like 1 or 2 clones and then blew them up. Each clone possesses an equal amount of chakra... it doesn't make sense...lets say he makes 2 clones, then each would have 33% of total chakra, and then he just blows them up? that'd make the jutsu more costly than amaterasu. either our understanding is wrong, or something else is going on. anyway, I still have to go and wil edit and add my true discussion later. I have to go again and don't have time for my real discussion. So later. I'll edit this later. (1st edit. The water bunshin I remember was kakashis. Kakashi as he was diving away said something watch out for the exploding kage bunshin. So yeah, if you trust kakashi's judgement in that situation, itachi exploded a kagebunshin) Last edited by Suna no tate; 2006-11-03 at 23:03. |
2006-11-03, 19:08 | Link #34 | |||||||||
Tesseract Enigma
Graphic Designer
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
What I'm agreeing with is the fact that Kurenai IS indeed physically weak. Her specialty is genjutsu that is what she fights with, she came to the village when she was little with a natural talent for genjutsu so she excelled and trained in that. Hence, her taijutsu is average or just "enough" is more what I'm saying. To be honest with you although Itachi doesn’t seem like the hand to hand combat type there is two obvious reason behind this. One is because so far there is no one who can rival his Mangekyo Sharingan. When some one that can comes along, we are going to see some real fireworks then we will truly know how good Itachi's taijutsu is. The other one is, Kisame holds him back, by that I mean Kisame is the one who gets down and dirty and Itachi supports. When Kisame has issues or there's too many then Itachi gets his hand dirty. In other words Itachi just does not like getting his hand dirty, he probably believes his Mangekyo Sharingan is good enough to take care of anything. Quote:
Quote:
I half agree with you on this one, its not exploding Kage Bunshin's but water clone's this is indeed amazing, the crazy thing about this is only Water clones create such an impact, can you imagine how big of an impact a kage bunshin which is a real body in almost every way possible would do? By the way only Naruto can afford to waste Kage Bunshins like that, that’s why Itach and NEARLY every other Ninja who makes clones stays away from Kage Bunshins and use some sort of Medium like Water, Wood, Ink to make their clones. Any way your right this is no where near kage level, BUT once again the topic is if Itachi is a genius without the Mangekyo Sharingan or not, it has really nothing to do with Kage level Jutsu's or if he is Kage level. But NO DOUBT this Jutsu is genius level, so this definitely favor's Itachi, in term's of is he a genius without the Mangekyo Shringan. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
What I’m saying is, I believe some one with a average / weak mind I bet you the Tsukuyomi would do physical harm to them, in the way that their minds think what they are seeing is really what’s happening to them which causes the body to do harm to it self because the eye's see, the mind believes. Quote:
I disagree 100%, do you really know what the Amaterasu is? Before I get to that I want to explain one thing, Amaterasu is not the only thing that takes 30% or more of Itachi's chakra, the Tsukuyomi does as well, that’s why he couldn’t use the Tsukuyomi during the 2nd fight with Kakashi. He even clearly says it "Its more like I CANT use it" so he starts using his finger Jutsu. So don’t diss on the Amaterasu because it consumes mass Chakra, if I had to guess I would say the Amaterasu uses 30% and so does the Tsukuyomi. The first time Itachi was shown he used the Tsukuyomi twice, and the Amaterasu once 90% of his chakra was gone leaving him with only 10%, hence him being in a state where he must retreat and rest. Now then, Amaterasu named after the Shinto sun goddess, this legendary jutsu is unique to the Uchiha clan. The jet-black flames are said to be as hot as the sun, and will burn for seven days and seven nights. Since the Mangekyo Sharingan is necessary to activate this jutsu, not many have learned it. Think about this for a moment, short range or long range IF you get hit with this jutsu, hell you wouldn’t even have to get hit, even if a bit of your cloths is caught by the Amaterasu, your done for. Burns for seven days and seven nights, Jiraiya had to SEAL the flames to get rid of it, in other words you can roll all you want it wont go out, you can throw water on it nothing will happen, you cant pat it down you will only be spreading the flame to the hand you patted with, the only thing you can do is seal it. Even if you were to try that your screwed by the time your ready. Don’t take the Amaterasu lightly we haven’t seen it in real action yet just got a taste of it. We have not even seen how it look's, for all you know it could be a flame ball that swallows a good amount of the radius around itachi body making it impossible for any one near him to escape, because it IS indeed short range, so most like it its one of those large sphere around the body type jutsu. A flame that’s as hot as the sun and burns for 7 days and 7 nights that can not be put out in any way other then a sealing jutsu, if that’s not impressive I don’t know what is. As far as it goes, the answer is Itachi is a genius without the Mangekyo Sharingan, YES he has the capacity and intelligence to become hokage ONE DAY. Just like Naruto, or Sasuke, but neither of them are Hokage level (if your talking about Yondaime or Sandaime that is.) None the less, we shouldn’t even be discussing Amaterasu and Tsukuyomi because this is suppose to be a topic that involves Itachi's genius without the Mangekyo Sharingan, and the Amaterasu and Tsukuyomi is impossible without it.
__________________
Last edited by 0TaKu0; 2006-11-03 at 19:24. |
|||||||||
2006-11-03, 20:17 | Link #35 | |||
The Ironman
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2006-11-03, 20:49 | Link #36 | ||
Tesseract Enigma
Graphic Designer
|
Quote:
Quote:
That’s besides the point really, although I made that one of the reasons, my most important reason was the time frame, the fact that Itachi could combine his Sharingan with his throwing techniques was a big deal because of his age. I'm sure there was other Uchiha who could throw like him but they were probably jounin's or at least 10-15 years older then him.
__________________
|
||
2006-11-03, 21:01 | Link #37 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
If you take it for what weve been told about other Characters and jounin in general.
Jounin need to ge able to open gates to be able to even qualify, signifying a high degree of Taijitsu was learned (without the body conditioning, the body would not be able to handle the strait of opening any gates). Jounin need to be able to manipulate two kinds of elemental Chakra, enfasising a huge understanding of ninjitsu skills in and of itself. And to add to this, of the elite Jounin that we know of, most were gifted from an overly early age (Kakashi graduated from the academy at 5 and was a chunin by 6, and was a jounin by 13. Guy too graduated at only 7, and Chunin by 11 [refer to more of the elite jounin in the databook, youd be surprised how common it seems that they were far ahead of Naruto's generation]). With all this, we can say that disregarding his Sharingan, Itachi would almost surely be in the same league as them in skills. The sharingan just gives him enough of an added ability to be able to approach multiple ennemies of such high standing, knowing he could hold his own vs them (not whether he could kill them all). |
2006-11-03, 21:16 | Link #38 |
Akatsuki Bart is Tobi
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
Ok. To clarify a few things, I will attempt. I just watched the episode where Itachi/Kisame meets Kakashi/Kurenai/Asuma. How fun. First off, it was most likely a kagebunshin that itachi exploded, though its possible Kakashi made a mistake. After all, he already commented about having trouble with itachi's speed. However, I will also say that the episode shows how the Akatsuki members use their cloaks to their advantage, as the jutsu was performed with hands purposely hidden. Itachi performed it with his hands inside the cloak, then pulled out shurikens as a distraction. Very nice. Very nice indeed. We already know they Sharingan can't penetrate cloth so its all up in the air. But as to itachi's skill...very good and his speed is probably amplified by the use of distractions. However no reference was made to his hand speed, just to the speed at which he uses jutsus (one after the other after the other and such).
Now lets discuss Gai. Gai shows up and the first thing Itachi says is "Don't underestimate him" and he repeats it later in the second major arc. Itachi seems to seriously respect Maito Gai. It also seems Gai knows 2 methods for fighting sharingan methods, aside from the first which is to look at their feet. I'm very curious as to the other method. I bet its the blindfold over the eyes method combined with some sort of drunken fist! haha! Your chakra flow would be all over the place! But I was immediately curious as to what it was. Still Itachi seems to really respect Gai and Gai himself said he's battled and trained against Sharingan users. So Gai is even stronger than I gave him credit for since he's smarter than I thought (he was my top jounin of those we've seen in konoha. Now the distance between him and kakashi has grown just a bit. A gai that breaks 7 gates.... watch out) Thirdly lets discuss the placement of itachi and Jiraiya. It seems the both underestimate each other so its really funny. Here are itachi's and kisame's words before they go to fight Jiraiya: K: he's an opponent that you may be able to face but I'm not sure about myself. He's of a different degree. I: Yeah. If we fight him, we put both our lives at risk. Where we fight him doesn't matter. Even if there were more of our kind... nothing would make a difference. K:Him being one of the legendary three...He'll be a hard opponent even for one of Konoha's Uchiha clan and one of the Mist's Seven Angles of Shinobi Katana I: Yeah... however...everyone has a weakness, no matter how strong they first appear to be Thats really funny, because after the fight, in a manga translation, Jiraiya seemed really afraid of them and was glad he was just able to scare them off. The anime gives a completely different impression. But its still funny. What really threw me for a loop was what Itachi meant whenhe said "even if there were more of our kind". What kind? Uchiha? S-Rank Ninja? More akatsuki members? Who knows. But the point is they seemed rather intimidated of this one member of the legendary three, yet everyone for some reason feels Orochimaru is absolutely terrified of itachi. This point I will pick up in little later. About catching sasuke's chidori, that really isn't that big of an accomplishment. Sasuke was rather deranged at the time and he hadn't mastered the entire sharingan either. After all the sharingan's weakness is taijutsu and all Itachi did was basically one quick motion. Personally speaking, it wasn't that great of an accomplishment and yes it makes Itachi look good, but not super good. My point about the accuracy was that after a certain point, increases in accuracy don't matter as much. If itachi throws 8 kunai at you, all 8 will hit. If Naruto throws 8 kunai at you, 6 may hit. Big difference. Back to the orochimaru statement. I think it is clear to everyone that orochimaru is a very narrow minded individual, that is once he sets his mind on something, everything else be damned. It doesn't matter to him how many babies are killed as long as the research is completed, or it doesn't matter how many ninja died as long as sasuke is delivered. From my record, orochimaru wanted itachi as his body host. The host apparently doesn't have to be willing, but must be in good physical condition. After all kimimaro got sick and all of sudden was a bad choice, despite the fact that Orochimaru has obvious healing and rejuvenation jutsus. I don't know if there are any direct statements of Orochimaru that indicate some sort of fear, but I do know he left because of itachi's growing power (Itachi probably found out about it). To me this means that, if itachi was an unwilling host, it would be extremely difficult for Orochimaru to gain his body, at least without damaging it. He may be able to fight itachi, but not with the ease needed to keep the body unharmed. He may have to kill itachi, or use techniques that would really rip him up and then itachi's body would be unuseable. After all, Itachi and Kisame already said that the legendary three are respectable opponents, and orochimaru is a legendary three member. Hehe... but then if there's one statement of Orochimaru that says he outright fears itachi, then this argument loses a lot of credibility. I would like to say though that Orochimaru wants konoha to rid some of the Akatsuki members for him and I think when he says that he's referring to the leader and the higher and more troublesom members of akatsuki like that zetsu. I doubt he's afraid of kisame (though in my mind Kisame is pretty strong, and in the right field, can tangle with anyone) or kukuzu or that hidan, but probably was of that Sasori who really wanted to kill him. |
2006-11-03, 21:18 | Link #39 | ||
The Ironman
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
2006-11-03, 21:50 | Link #40 | ||||
Tesseract Enigma
Graphic Designer
|
Quote:
Quote:
By the way, remember how kakashi stoped the Chidori and Rasengan? grabbed both hands.... LMAO like it was a cake walk, wtf was that? I mean even though it was not aimed at him, he basically grabbed a throwing knife, Itachi did the same shit. That proves how weak ass Sasuke was back then, so being able to stop his chidori by grabbing his hand doesn’t mean it was an amazing counter. Quote:
Quote:
By the way Suna No Tate Err, The whole bunshin thing and hand seals speed I was basing it on the Manga, actually I based everything on the Manga I try not to do anything from the anime because they add shit that's not there and change stuff. You said you watched the episode, I cant be bothered to watch the episode right now but yea, I’m pretty sure they changed stuff and added shit that wasn’t there. In the manga it didn’t look like he was doing the hand seals in his robe…
__________________
|
||||
|
|