W Wish

[crumja]

So now that the first ep is out, what do you guys think?

It's definitely a lot more serious than Final Approach, its sister show, and focuses on drama in relationships rather than the wacky side of it.

[Lord Raiden]

It's on my download list but I haven't seen it yet. But from what I read it sounds interesting. I'm at least going to give it a look.

[Timeless Enigma]

More serious than Final Approach eh? I'm getting it right now, I'll let you know what I think.

[mangatron]

Final Approach is whacked up funny, W Wish is drama-like beauty. Ah, so elegant, I got ep 01 raw but haven't seen it yet....I'm a bad person

[Dejital]

I just saw it. That was pretty cute, and yes, it seems to be very dramatic. I'm not too sure how it's going to be a whole anime show, as there's not much to the story right now... I'm looking forward to the next episode anyway! ^_^

I just noticed I started every sentence with ' I ' ..... I'm so cocky... >_<;;

[DekaMaster]

I hated Final Approach so am I very hesitant to watch this one untill i hear more about it.

[Dejital]

Originally Posted by DekaMaster

I hated Final Approach so am I very hesitant to watch this one untill i hear more about it.

Let's see.... u__u;;;

Spoiler for for episode 1:

Boy is main character, a bad student. His parents died in an accident, leaving him only his sister as his family. The kids live together, on their own, which seems quite unrealistic. The boy also has amnesia for everything that happened before his parents' accident. Now for the ep. spoiler: They are called into the Principal's Office (?) and are suggested to live in the school's dorm. The boy expresses his love to his sister by refusing. There is some kind of school event to go on, which his sister wishes to go to, but her brother is reluctant. His sister thinks this would be a great way to make new memories for her brother.

Hope I didn't spoil it .... too much. o__O

[Mr. Shabaz]

Looks like I'm gonna be the first one to bash the show.

While there's nothing wrong with being a serious show, I just couldn't find the drama enjoyable.

Spoiler:

While the brother/sister relationship doesn't appear to be a 'incest' one, it still seems odd to me. It's like the shut everyone else out of their lives and only have each other as friends. Maybe future episodes will change this... but until then.

I'd rate the 1st ep of this show 3/10. It's slow pace just made it feel boring to me, and the drama just had me like... whatever.

[wraith985]

Not a lot happened in the first episode, and I'm not really sure what's going on either, so I feel you, Shabaz. At the same time, I always give new anime a few episodes to show me something, so I guess we'll see. I'm hoping the plot picks up soon. Still, as an introductory episode, I didn't think that it was so bad.

[Tiamat's Disciple]

Originally Posted by Mr. Shabaz

Looks like I'm gonna be the first one to bash the show.

While there's nothing wrong with being a serious show, I just couldn't find the drama enjoyable.

Spoiler:

While the brother/sister relationship doesn't appear to be a 'incest' one, it still seems odd to me. It's like the shut everyone else out of their lives and only have each other as friends. Maybe future episodes will change this... but until then.

I'd rate the 1st ep of this show 3/10. It's slow pace just made it feel boring to me, and the drama just had me like... whatever.

You need to bear in mind your actually only getting about 9 to 91/2 minutes of actual show, so it's going to appear slow, with shows like this you need to give it atleast 4 epsidoes to get a decent feel.

Spoiler:

As for the brother sister relationship, this episode went into the trauma he had been through. Taking all of that into account then its only natural for him to latch onto her. She is after all his only link to his past, as well as being the support thats kept him going, and him doing the same for her.

All that, its not suprising they're very dependant and protective of each other, and wanting to stay as a family.

All in all i liked the episode, it set a good foundation for future episodes. One thin i noticed though, in a way this is wind all over again. Wind being the deep story and Hani Hani being the lighter side, here we have Wish as the deep story (potentialy at least) and Final Aproach as the lighter side.

It's a good combination i feel, and hopefully they wont screw it up this time

[Mr. Shabaz]

Originally Posted by Taliesin

You need to bear in mind your actually only getting about 9 to 91/2 minutes of actual show, so it's going to appear slow, with shows like this you need to give it atleast 4 epsidoes to get a decent feel.

Spoiler:

As for the brother sister relationship, this episode went into the trauma he had been through. Taking all of that into account then its only natural for him to latch onto her. She is after all his only link to his past, as well as being the support thats kept him going, and him doing the same for her.

All that, its not suprising they're very dependant and protective of each other, and wanting to stay as a family.

All in all i liked the episode, it set a good foundation for future episodes. One thin i noticed though, in a way this is wind all over again. Wind being the deep story and Hani Hani being the lighter side, here we have Wish as the deep story (potentialy at least) and Final Aproach as the lighter side.

It's a good combination i feel, and hopefully they wont screw it up this time

I'm still gonna watch the next few episodes of the show and I do hope it turns out better. The more good stuff the better, right?

Spoiler:

I can understand them being dependant on each other and the family stuff. The only thing that got me was they seem to only want each other and not let in other people. Like when Senna seemed to get jealous over Junna's friend playfully grabbing his hand. Of course I could be wrong... it's just the way I interpreted it. Probably need to see more to get a better idea.

[Tima]

Spoiler:

As for the brother sister relationship, this episode went into the trauma he had been through. Taking all of that into account then its only natural for him to latch onto her. She is after all his only link to his past, as well as being the support thats kept him going, and him doing the same for her.

All that, its not suprising they're very dependant and protective of each other, and wanting to stay as a family.

Spoiler:

I can understand them being dependant on each other and the family stuff. The only thing that got me was they seem to only want each other and not let in other people. Like when Senna seemed to get jealous over Junna's friend playfully grabbing his hand. Of course I could be wrong... it's just the way I interpreted it. Probably need to see more to get a better idea.

[/QUOTE]

Spoiler:

Junna's friend came off to me to be gay he even blushed when he touched Senna's brothers hand. It seemed to me like she was just backing up what her brother said by telling him to stop cause it was embarassing her brother, or she didn't want anyone to get the wrong idea about her brother maybe.

I was questioning wether she was his sister or not at first becuase of the way some things were explianed, and because i didn't see why the counsler would want them to split up unless they weren't really related. Now I see that she really is his sister.

[/QUOTE]

[Tiamat's Disciple]

Originally Posted by Tima

Spoiler:

As for the brother sister relationship, this episode went into the trauma he had been through. Taking all of that into account then its only natural for him to latch onto her. She is after all his only link to his past, as well as being the support thats kept him going, and him doing the same for her.

All that, its not suprising they're very dependant and protective of each other, and wanting to stay as a family.

Spoiler:

I can understand them being dependant on each other and the family stuff. The only thing that got me was they seem to only want each other and not let in other people. Like when Senna seemed to get jealous over Junna's friend playfully grabbing his hand. Of course I could be wrong... it's just the way I interpreted it. Probably need to see more to get a better idea.

Spoiler:

Junna's friend came off to me to be gay he even blushed when he touched Senna's brothers hand. It seemed to me like she was just backing up what her brother said by telling him to stop cause it was embarassing her brother, or she didn't want anyone to get the wrong idea about her brother maybe.

I was questioning wether she was his sister or not at first becuase of the way some things were explianed, and because i didn't see why the counsler would want them to split up unless they weren't really related. Now I see that she really is his sister.

[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]


I happen to know a brother and sister just like this. At the hospital i go to there is a brother and sister like this there. They're totaly dependant on each other, wont let anyone else near them, and god help anyone that touches the brother without the sisters permission.

Theres nothing between them, they're just totaly dependant on each other. They've been in care together since they were born, so they've come to depend on each other as their only friends and such.

Spoiler:

Now, in the case of this show, the brother has been through hell. Lost all of his memories and found one of them, his sister. The sister is the only link left to reality. I think he's probably more clingy than she is, just look at how he reacted when they offered him the dorm, before his sis had even said a scentence he'd refused, and look at the words he uses, and again later just at the end of the show.

and oh my god i cant believe im analysing an anime show >.<

Note to Self: stop reading to much into anime :P

Time for a coffee

[Dejital]

Spoiler:

Juuna's friend is indeed gay, that's kind of obvious. I don't think Juuna appreciates this, but he doesn't want to hurt his friend... His sister defends her brother and that's a good thing. There is no romance or love affairs between the children, Juuna's sister is the only thing he remembers about his past life, so he defends and will continue defending her til the end of their days. You can see he loves her cause he silently agrees to go to the event.

I'm just stating the obvious. u__u

[cindialai]

It's better than Kanon ... i like the brownish drawings.. gives it an old effect.

[Tiamat's Disciple]

Originally Posted by cindialai

It's better than Kanon ... i like the brownish drawings.. gives it an old effect.

I dont think it's fair to compare this to Kanon, they're from two different genre's, and have different time spans. This is a good show so far, and one i'll be keeping, but you cant really compare it to Kanon, not yet anyway.

If it turns into a similar genre, ie: magic happens around him, then you can sort of compre them. But even then i dont think it would do wither shows justice to compre them, that would be like compareing a mini with a ferrari, both are excellent in their own right, but totaly different and from different driving styles.

[Kyolux]

Haven't watched it yet, will in a few, but it is comparable in the fact that they are both ero-games based anime.. Well I think W wish is, and Kanon is for sure.

[Tiamat's Disciple]

Originally Posted by Kyolux

Haven't watched it yet, will in a few, but it is comparable in the fact that they are both ero-games based anime.. Well I think W wish is, and Kanon is for sure.

They may be game based, but they're still completely different genre. It would be like comparing KotOR and NWN, both are games, both are RPG's but they're from 2 totaly different and seperate genre, you cant therefore compare them. You can say that one is a more faithful translation of the game, but thats about as far as you can go.

[LoveOfAnime]

Originally Posted by Mr. Shabaz

Looks like I'm gonna be the first one to bash the show.

While there's nothing wrong with being a serious show, I just couldn't find the drama enjoyable.

Spoiler:

While the brother/sister relationship doesn't appear to be a 'incest' one, it still seems odd to me. It's like the shut everyone else out of their lives and only have each other as friends. Maybe future episodes will change this... but until then.

I'd rate the 1st ep of this show 3/10. It's slow pace just made it feel boring to me, and the drama just had me like... whatever.

I agree completely. Question for you.

Spoiler:

It doesn't appear to be an incestual relationship but I was not the only one picking up on that feeling, did it not look like She was kissing him on that last scene when they were leaving the park?

Did anyone else notice the sound being terrible? Kind of like fading in and out and some hissing? To me it also seemed the characters were subpar. I might watch a couple more episodes, but I think I already like Final Approach more. The art seemed better and the storyline seemed like it had more options as to how the storyline will progress.

[Tiamat's Disciple]

Originally Posted by LoveOfAnime

I agree completely. Question for you.

Spoiler:

It doesn't appear to be an incestual relationship but I was not the only one picking up on that feeling, did it not look like She was kissing him on that last scene when they were leaving the park?

Did anyone else notice the sound being terrible? Kind of like fading in and out and some hissing? To me it also seemed the characters were subpar. I might watch a couple more episodes, but I think I already like Final Approach more. The art seemed better and the storyline seemed like it had more options as to how the storyline will progress.

Final Aproach = Rizlemine Wannabe

I had no trouble with the sound, you might need to update your codecs to the latest ones is all