Episode 22: Created Human [Spoilers]

[dreamless]

I think Winry looks like Ed in the previews... *_*

[Bindibadgi]

Right im getting well confused with all these sins flying around!

Envy = cross-dressing-person-changer-dude?
Glutony = fat guy that eats Al?
Lust = foxy chick with nails you wouldnt like scratching your back in bed
Greed = ? I forgot

Spoiler:

Pride = we speculate is Elerics father?

Now im lost on the rest, is it cause ive not read the manga? Or should i just rewatch the series?

[BigFire]

Originally Posted by Bindibadgi

Right im getting well confused with all these sins flying around!

Envy = cross-dressing-person-changer-dude?
Glutony = fat guy that eats Al?
Lust = foxy chick with nails you wouldnt like scratching your back in bed
Greed = ? I forgot

Spoiler:

Pride = we speculate is Elerics father?

Now im lost on the rest, is it cause ive not read the manga? Or should i just rewatch the series?

Greed is the guy wearing fur coat. In the anime, he's the one locked up inside the 5th Central Research lab for 130 years.

Spoiler:

Sloth has not appear yet, and Wrath is someone you've already seen.

[ShadowLady]

Originally Posted by Shenlong

Winry looks very mature and hot with her hair down in the previews..
*blushes*

Yeah I kinda noticed that too.
I actually paused the video because i was like "huh is that winry 0.o?"

[DarkNtity]

Man, Greed and three other unknown people I assumed were the other sins, since at least one of them sports a red tattoo. Sweet episode, until I read this bloody thread so full of manga spoilers it could choke someone to death. Why are manga readers making predictions in the anime thread? Even if the anime breaks away from the manga storyline from time to time, some facts will never change.

I mean it doesn't say manga spoilers ahead. So what at least I presumed was that the spoiler tags are there for those who haven't seen the episode yet.
For whining out loud, one post pratically says "Some questions that can be raised for speculation here..." so I go in thinking "Gosh speculation regarding this ep, this should be fun" and I come out feeling violated by blades dipped in manga spoilers. Why???

[sarcasteak]

Originally Posted by DarkNtity

Why are manga readers making predictions in the anime thread?

Hmm, I do it because 1.) I don't discuss anywhere else other than Chinese forums, 2.) some people want those spoilers, and 3.) I use spoiler tag.

Originally Posted by DarkNtity

So what at least I presumed was that the spoiler tags are there for those who haven't seen the episode yet.

Any speculations based on this episode shouldn't even have spoiler tags to begin with, though! ^_^;;

Originally Posted by DarkNtity

or whining out loud, one post pratically says "Some questions that can be raised for speculation here..." so I go in thinking "Gosh speculation regarding this ep, this should be fun" and I come out feeling violated by blades dipped in manga spoilers. Why???

Ummm, Yebyosh made those speculations based mainly on this episode; yes, he did incorporate "Father" and "Wrath," but for the most part it was based on the anime alone. Don't bash indiscriminately...

[Dark_Sun]

so is ed like MEGA POWERFUL!?

[Mikesmaf]

i think the jolt of power was a temporary thing...but this is just a guess.

[BigFire]

Originally Posted by sarcasteak

Any speculations based on this episode shouldn't even have spoiler tags to begin with, though! ^_^;;




Ummm, Yebyosh made those speculations based mainly on this episode; yes, he did incorporate "Father" and "Wrath," but for the most part it was based on the anime alone. Don't bash indiscriminately...

How 'bout this. In the future, if we bring anything that's manga-sourced spoiler, we'd marked accordingly.

[SketchyMcChips]

Originally Posted by Mikesmaf

i think the jolt of power was a temporary thing...but this is just a guess.

I'm in the habit of putting everything in these threads in spoilers so my apoligies if you don't think it classes as one.

Spoiler:

I'd imagine so - but it's be interesting if it wasn't...considering he managed to scare the crap out of 3 homunculi when he had the power surge...just imagine what he could do with the philosophers stone???? How on earth did they homunculi get out of there??? Greed does look way too obvious, even if Envy and Lust managed to pull it off, Greed doesn't look human enough.

and looking ahead to ep 23...

Spoiler:

Well looks like we have a nice quiet one coming up whilst Ed recovers. Seems as well like Al is going to take the opportunity to confront the possibility that he isn't the soul he thinks he is. It'll be a nice turn of pace to give us a break from all the action.

[Yebyosh]

Originally Posted by dreamless

I think Winry looks like Ed in the previews... *_*

Haven't you heard of the sayings that fated devoted couples tend to grow to look alike? I think that pretty much settles who the anime crew would like to pair Ed with

To SketchyMcChips: I believe you are referring to Gluttony, not Greed.

[DarkNtity]

Originally Posted by sarcasteak

Hmm, I do it because 1.) I don't discuss anywhere else other than Chinese forums, 2.) some people want those spoilers, and 3.) I use spoiler tag.

1) That has no relevance bringing the discussion here. 2) I don't see anyone asking for spoilers. But I do see spoilers confusing someone. 3) Good for you. But since you were responding to Yebyosh, there was no need to read whatever you tagged.

Any speculations based on this episode shouldn't even have spoiler tags to begin with, though! ^_^;;

Really? So are my eyes decieving me? Aren't you the very one who has an overview with added speculation regarding this episode + a drop of a manga spoiler all hidden in spoiler tags?

So please, don't give me that crap.

Ummm, Yebyosh made those speculations based mainly on this episode; yes, he did incorporate "Father" and "Wrath," but for the most part it was based on the anime alone. Don't bash indiscriminately...

I watch the anime. And I can perfectly asess by myself when too much info is given. There was more going on in there than "Father" and "Wrath". And even that alone is valid in this case.
It's not like I'm the only one who feels this way.

Originally Posted by cf18

Sigh... Can we have anime discussion without complete manga spoilers? I already read up to vol6 of the manga and there are still tons of spoilers here.

And who is bashing, indiscriminately for that matter?
This is a critique.

[Kira]

this thread is amazing!!! i learned so much thing i didn't know. Hey it seems that the manga is more detailed.

[YuuOminae]

I'm going to have to agree with Darkntity. A lot of people just watch the anime and hence would prefer not to have to be constantly spoiled about what's happening in the manga, which will mostly likely be what will happen in the anime.

It'd be better to make a separate thread just for the manga.

[sarcasteak]

Originally Posted by DarkNtity

1) That has no relevance bringing the discussion here. 2) I don't see anyone asking for spoilers. But I do see spoilers confusing someone. 3) Good for you. But since you were responding to Yebyosh, there was no need to read whatever you tagged.

Yes, I was having a little discussion with Yebyosh, and I truly apologize for not using the PM option!!

Really? So are my eyes decieving me? Aren't you the very one who has an overview with added speculation regarding this episode + a drop of a manga spoiler all hidden in spoiler tags?

So please, don't give me that crap.

Read what I said again; why do people need spoiler tags if their speculations are based on the current episode? I wasn't referring to myself.

I watch the anime. And I can perfectly asess by myself when too much info is given. There was more going on in there than "Father" and "Wrath". And even that alone is valid in this case.

I felt those were just minor details in that particular discussion, but obviously you disagree. Note taken.

It's not like I'm the only one who feels this way.

Your complaint has been heard. We'll have our own little discussions with our new [mangaspoiler] tags.

And who is bashing, indiscriminately for that matter?
This is a critique.

I felt the speculation you were "criticizing" did not involve many manga spoilers (or anything that hasn't been repeatedly spoiled already) and thus the comment.

[Bindibadgi]

Originally Posted by SketchyMcChips

and looking ahead to ep 23...

Spoiler:

Well looks like we have a nice quiet one coming up whilst Ed recovers. Seems as well like Al is going to take the opportunity to confront the possibility that he isn't the soul he thinks he is. It'll be a nice turn of pace to give us a break from all the action.

Spoiler:

Are you nuts? Al's gone dark by the looks of the preview. Shouldnt have as much physical action but it aint gonna be quiet imo

[That Other Ninja]

Any comments made about who r Sloth n Wrath? Or if Sloth is someone we've already seen...

Spoiler:

...is it Scar?

[BigFire]

Originally Posted by That Other Ninja

Spoiler:

Any comments made about who r Sloth n Wrath? Or if Sloth is someone we've already seen...

...is it Scar?

Possilbe Manga Spoiler

Spoiler:

Sloth isn't anyone that the anime've shown. Wrath is someone who's been on the anime for quite a while. And it's not Scar.

[ItsuJin]

but one thing for sure.. FMA is getting more n more interesting.. man, its a really good anime.. i like winry ^O^, even though she forgot one screw...
for me FMA is the best anime so far, beside one piece..

[That Other Ninja]

Er... I meant Wrath for Scar, not Sloth.