|
View Poll Results: Shakugan no Shana II - Episode 15 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 57 | 54.29% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 28 | 26.67% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 12 | 11.43% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 7 | 6.67% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 0 | 0% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 1 | 0.95% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 0 | 0% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 0 | 0% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 0 | 0% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 0 | 0% | |
Voters: 105. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2008-01-29, 03:31 | Link #122 | |
Nick of Time~
|
Quote:
Shana-tan was meant purely for fun, so don't take that too seriously. |
|
2008-01-29, 09:32 | Link #123 | |
I'm the Showstopper!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: A place where you can't find me.
|
Quote:
|
|
2008-01-29, 11:58 | Link #124 | ||
Nick of Time~
|
Quote:
Quote:
Aside from that, what kind of tactics or maneuvers would have been preferable? A suggestion would be nice to back up your statement that Shana could have done something better other than charge straight in and try to slice Master Throne into a million pieces. And for starters, trying to chop off Hecate's fingers isn't viable. She isn't a darn practice dummy for beginners. |
||
2008-01-29, 12:42 | Link #125 | |
I'm the Showstopper!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: A place where you can't find me.
|
Quote:
Adrenaline can cause people to think faster in relation to time. They become more alert in thinking things milliseconds off the bat. Aside from training in combat, Shana did have an education at the Tendou-Kyuu so the knowledge of applying quick-second tactics was greatly stressed. When Hecate brought the Trigon to block, the fingers of both hands were around the grip of the staff. Try holding a pipe and you'll see that your fingers tend to envelop around it. So Shana could've aim a slash at Hecate's fingers when the Supreme Throne brought her weapon to block, not at the staff space between Hecate's hands as depicted above. |
|
2008-01-29, 16:30 | Link #126 |
Urusai~Urusai~Urusai~
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Location
Age: 31
|
^Actually, rather than Shana makes a mistake at where to strike, isn't it Hecate who is able to predict where to block? That's what I have been thinking, although looking back, the scene doesn't give much detail...
Also, I'm not really sure what adrenaline is, but when you are scare or desperate, don't you react fast to the situation at hand but gets dumb down on everything else? Shana can't think logically is one thing, but at the same time it seems like she is too desperate so her neglect on fighting a good fight just seems natural to me.
__________________
|
2008-01-29, 17:16 | Link #127 | |||
Snape: "I hate Potter!"
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Australia
|
Quote:
Quote:
Take for example, why do people become pale when they get scared? Well that's one of the effects of adrenaline, it causes blood to rush to the muscles in preparation to runaway or to fight hence technically less blood would be at the brains for logical thinking. In fact adrenaline does the opposite effect to what you've stated DX in that it actually causes a person to be more rash in their actions. I hope i've explained it. Anyone can tell you that it's hard to think when they are in panic and when they are in panic and that's because when they are in panic they produce adrenaline. In other words Shana, who looks to be pumped full with adrenaline and chose to fight out of the "fight or flight" response could not possibly thinking logically. I'm a bit confused but does that mean you agree with me in that she wasn't thinking logically? Quote:
We have seen throughout the series that despite what Flame Hazes are, their reactions and emotions still mimick that of a human. We've seen Shana, display love, jealousy, sadness ect. We've also seen Margery lose control in ep 13, it's proof that despite the power Flame Hazes possess, they still have a sense of humanity in that they are still influenced by emotions and aren't just logical cold killers of Tomogura.
__________________
|
|||
2008-01-29, 19:48 | Link #128 |
Senior Member
Author
|
I have to agree with holyman282.
Shana struck me as coming just short of losing it in this episode - she almost snapped like Margery did in Episode 13. I think that Shana just wanted to blitz Hecate into defeat - even cut her in half if that was necessary. It is possible that she wanted to wipe out Hecate's staff , though, perhaps seeing it as a major source, or channeller, of Hecate's power. Either way, she was simply charging in with her emotions going full blast. Episode 15 was a great, intense, thrill-ride. Episodes 13 through 15 have all been excellent, and they make up for a couple too many "slice of life" episodes in the first half of the season. All around, Shana Season 2 is looking pretty good right now, and shaping up nicely. I love how complex, and intertwined, Yuji's situation has become. It'll be great to see how it's all resolved. I also think that Johan, for whatever reason, probably cares a bit about Yuji's fate (perhaps he could even see into Yuji's life and actions a bit from his position within him)?). I think he basically talked Pheles down into accepting the current situation for Yuji's sake until more could be done to rectify everything. I think that Johan is still continuing to exist within Yuji - I don't think that he was absorbed by Pheles, or just faded away. Last edited by Triple_R; 2008-01-30 at 04:28. |
2008-01-29, 20:40 | Link #129 | |
I'm the Showstopper!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: A place where you can't find me.
|
Quote:
The rashness comes more from the dark animalistic nature of the human being itself and that's when their emotions boil over their sentient mentality. Adrenaline might feed into that irrationality but it isn't the primary cause. Shana could think logically in situations like that, even with the adrenaline going through her blood. Why the portrayal lacking that in the episode is a mystery. You ASKED me the question on WHETHER she could be thinking logically when she charged into the fray. The only simple reaction I saw that held sound judgment/logic would be directly assaulting the threat Hecate posed, compared to just flying to and getting Yuji out of the fire. When I said "I didn't SAY she was thinking logically at the moment", that meant that I never answered your question in regards to MY view on whether Shana was acting on logic or judgment at all until now. Overall, Shana did have a bit of logic but there could've been more in that small time gap between clearing the Aster and engaging Hecate: the point I stressed in my last post about slashing the fingers rather than just think: "slash to kill" repeatedly but failing to utilize the attacks to an effective level. Besides, those few seconds after clearing the Aster Unrestricted Spell to engaging the enemy was more than enough sufficient time for her to set her first goal which was to strike Hecate down, but it raises the question within a millisecond later: How do I do that? Half a second later: She's holding a staff that nearly blasted me out of the sky. Another half second as she screams in bringing her sword up: She's about to block my attack so I'll disarm her by targeting her fingers surrounding parts of the staff. alternative scenario that results: Shana brings the Nietono no Shana down right on Hecate's fingers that enveloped the staff and SLASH! four of Hecate's fingers are sliced off and she's momentarily disarmed from the pain, leaving an opening for about two or three seconds. Obviously, Flame Hazes are still human so I have neither an objection nor the energy to type anything about it |
|
2008-01-29, 21:20 | Link #130 |
Nick of Time~
|
The way it is, DX, you're going to find fault with every single battle scene not only in SnS, but also in any fighting scenes from other shows. I'm suggesting you just drop this, or we can all just carry out with this pointless argument.
Just for one last shot at this: You know, I'ver rewatched the scene, and it isn't as though Shana was aiming at the staff. I mean, you don't fight to aim for the weapon first, right? The way she was fighting was to attack Hecate in the quickest and most direct way possible as dictated probably by her instinct, emotion and perhaps even a different train of thought from what you suggested. No offense, but your suggestion is flawed (but interesting) at the very beginning because the scene doesn't show us if Hecate has already taken up her staff to parry before Shana tried to strike her. I'd like to see even the most seasoned warrior determine WHERE Hecate's fingers were accurately before she raised up her staff. There are so many possibilities for her; Hecate could dodge, parry the blow in the centre, step back and fire an Aster at her with the right timing. What makes you think Shana is the only one capable of thinking in this exchange of blows? Besides, it's the same old argument: You could see her heart wasn't in it to fight Hecate, but she was actually more concerned with Yuuji. The moment he went into a freefall, she turned from the fight as though it never happened. The division of her attention might be a reason why she was unable to 'think logically' in that sense. Re-watching the scene where Johan and Pheles finally met up was touching, but it gave me the chills too; Just exactly how insanely powerful is this Sabrac? Spoiler:
|
2008-01-29, 21:53 | Link #131 | ||||||
Snape: "I hate Potter!"
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Australia
|
Quote:
I was hoping we wouldn't get to the different lobes of the cerebrum but i guess i'll have to.. You understand that the cerebrum is made up of different lobes. Logical thinking, in the sense you're mentioning are located in the frontal lobe. The frontal lobe works by controlling problem solving initiation, facial movement, planning abilities, coordinating, and motivation. In other words this is the part where one could our sentience derives from. One of the effects of Adrenaline is a heightened sense of awareness, which you may confuse as being more logical in your actions, but the instead it means that focus of nutrients and blood are diverted into the temporal lobe (auditory processing), parietal lobe (spatial sense and navigation) and occipital lobe (visual processing). All together increases in blood flows in those areas cause a heightened sense of awareness and not the frontal lobe which is what is involved in logical processing. Quote:
Also think of it this way, adrenaline is produced during periods of stress, in which your mind (hence your logical processing ability) is already not working at its optimum. Quote:
I don't mean any offence or wish to argue but don't you feel that what you are saying is a bit unreasonable? You expect someone to act and think logically in those situations.. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Consider why we have a reflex arc system built into our bodies. Because if you put your hands on a hot plate and it takes your brain to think "geeze it's hot i should remove it" then you remove it, let's just say there's would be alot of burnt hands. Certain processes if gone through the normal way i.e. sensory>nerve>spinal cord> brain would take too long then say the reflex arc which just bypasses the brain.
__________________
|
||||||
2008-01-29, 23:41 | Link #134 |
Yummy, sweet and unyuu!!!
Join Date: Dec 2004
|
I dunno about adrenaline and Shana, she has been trained from a wee baby to deal with combat situations. Panic due to loosing something that she isn't willing to loose is more likely in my mind. In the old days it was living up to the memory of the previous Flame Haze and Alastor, but now it is poor fragile but oh so dense Yuji.
I personally think that the FH's power levels are linked to their emotional states. When Shana lost to Margery she was all confused by Yuji. Margery was so powerful maybe due to her need for revenge. When Shana was confident in her feelings for Yuji she was doing well, but right now she is in a halfway house so that could be affecting her.
__________________
|
2008-01-30, 14:25 | Link #136 | ||
I'm the Showstopper!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: A place where you can't find me.
|
Quote:
I'm sure Hecate could also think in the exchange of blows. It could make a better melee exchange than just a simple slash being blocked. Shana was putting her heart into the fight while Yuji was floating. Just look at her face when fighting the threat closest to him. She pulled back quickly when Yuji began to fall. At that point of realization, the logic in her reason to save Yuji would dictate this: break away from fighting the enemy and go after Yuji. It boils down to priority in achieving a goal. Quote:
When a person is on an "adrenal rush", the senses are heightened to achieve greater awareness. The body begans to speed up processes to an emergency state. To that person, time relative to their surroundings seem to slow a bit which would allow them to relatively think and act faster. Unreasonable seems a bit heavy there but I doubt I'm demanding overboard, unlike those who ask for more fanservice. Figuring the cause to a series of steps isn't that difficult. You underestimate the true potential for humans to comprehend things in such short periods. That period of time was more than enough to figure out a simple plan or tactic. It was only 3 to 5 seconds anyways and Shana had that combat state of mind on full throttle so she could in that duration. The majority of the fight scenes in this season don't seem as intense as they used to be, despite the new things. I could go on with this, despite seeing others gnash their teeth at me. Other than ban me for eternity (something I ain't afraid of), what's the worse that could happen if I went on? |
||
2008-01-30, 17:24 | Link #137 | |||||
Snape: "I hate Potter!"
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Australia
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I don't mean to offend you, it's just that without any evidence, you'd have to expect people to believe what you are saying on your words alone. Quote:
Quote:
Compared to how much depth you had to go to, to justify why Shana should be able to think logically. It just means that your point is harder to argue because it's more unbelievable. There is a saying that the "simplest solution is usually the correct one" The simple solution is that Shana at that moment was too stressed and in a state of emotional turmoil to think logically. Evidence can be provided by the way she was acting in those events. See? Simple. A complicated response would be to try and justify why Shana could think logically and made you and me go into details about adrenaline and the brain lobes ect.
__________________
|
|||||
2008-01-30, 18:02 | Link #138 | |
I'm the Showstopper!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: A place where you can't find me.
|
Quote:
It's hard to think about the actual circumstances or imagine myself in Shana's place at that point in the first place. Let me ask you: Have you ever got into real fights in your life? Ones that were close to the "kill or be killed"? The process isn't that elaborate as you would imagine in Shana's case. You're thinking a bit too complex on a simple notion of where to strike your sword at. Why would I need a scientific journal to explain something that happens in a cartoon or a piece of fiction? Flame Haze are the epitome of what they are in comparison to normal humans, which means that they could achieve a number of things beyond the human range of possible understanding. That last comment just came out in response to others saying that I should cease the discussion about this. |
|
|
|