2013-08-25, 11:54 | Link #32901 | |
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2013-08-25, 12:08 | Link #32902 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
In Japan, starting with the backwards approval of the three (or four) great strange books, a strong trend towards questioning the genre while writing it (especially instigated by a strong split between genre-critical mysteries and socio-critical mysteries) began, which continues until today. The points these three "strange books" are also cited as THE anti-mystery in Japan.
All things that can be found in Umineko? Yes, and Ryukishi didn't need to be an exceptionally intellectual person to tackle these points, since by now they have become common tropes in a post-mortum stage of the author as the sole creator of one simple creation. Is Ryukishi well read in the mystery genre? He's at least something that could be considered an avid reader, maybe even mania by Japanese standards, but that much was already clear with Higurashi. Does he make any new points? Not necessarily, but these points were technically already "old" when they were put together, considering that at least the first 3 pieces mentioned above were written in 1935, '34 and '64 respectively (even preceding Barthe's big proclamation). What he did do is create them in a different kind of medium and create a different kind of author-reader relationship that is missing from a large number of mystery publications today. |
|
2013-08-25, 14:57 | Link #32903 | ||
Member
Join Date: Dec 2012
|
Quote:
The fact that Ryu explained in OC that "the noise is not so loud" is pretty much the finishing point for this discussion, as the sound is now explained not to be an important factor towards the story, and Yasu has some kind of magic gun. Pretty much the same explanation why people don't get wet in the rain. Quote:
Last edited by Dormin; 2013-08-25 at 15:21. |
||
2013-08-25, 19:03 | Link #32905 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
Quote:
- in Ep 5 to be witnessed by Erika as Shannon and Kanon she would have to change in the time Erika basically moved her gaze to look around if she even looked around the room and made sure everyone was there like the witches said (my solution to that point is that Erika never looked around so she took the 'everyone's here' for a fact and never checked if the guys were all in the room in the moment it was said, too busy let's say, chatting with the cousins) - For 2/3 years Yasu had to constantly change at the most random moments as she could end up in a situation in which she was supposed to serve tea to Natsuhi while she's looking out of the window to see if Kanon is cleaning the garden... considering Yasu would have to work as Shannon and Kanon and that their working schedule might overlap and Natsuhi check if people work, things will be pretty troublesome often. |
||
2013-08-25, 19:21 | Link #32906 | |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
In the first two stories there isn't a whole lot of changing going on though, there's just certain points where it gets questionable later. It's one of those "possible, but increasingly less plausible and more obsessive the more you think about the necessary logistics" things, rather than "doesn't actually happen" like instantaneous travel between buildings or not getting wet outside in a typhoon or inaudible rifles.
__________________
|
|
2013-08-25, 19:33 | Link #32907 | |
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2013-08-25, 20:43 | Link #32908 | |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
I'm not sure we actually know, as "Did anyone ever look up Kanon's info at the orphanage or contact others who went there after the fact and realize there isn't any such person?" is one of those sticky questions that never seems to get answered.
__________________
|
|
2013-08-25, 20:59 | Link #32909 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
Also it's troublesome as Natsuhi also surely check working schedule and might want to have a say on them and because Shannon also went to school, which means when she's at school Kanon can't be on the island... which leave an even smaller amount of time to orchestrate things. Of course I've my own theory on all this but still... it seems an overcomplicate thing that makes sense only if Yasu knew she would end up needing Kanon for closed room tricks. |
|
2013-08-25, 21:27 | Link #32910 |
Blick Winkel
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Gobbled up by Promathia
|
I think the easiest way to explain it is "Kanon is just a metaphor and is not entity in R-Prime and Yasu just didn't care enough about details about dress-switching to as much as MENTION them in her stories". Of course, that's just me covering for R07
I'm suddenly trying to imagine what would result if Yasu actually completely sucked at writing and resorted to writing shitty fanfiction to let her feelings out ("My Immortal" tier shit). Think about it: self-insert characters, tormented by love, writes multiple stories about her feelings (granted in this case her angst is probably justified but still). "and thn battler leaned to shannn face nd wispered 'i'll love you 5ever' and they kissed passintley nd then had bbies named beato and kanon" Because in the grand scheme of things, she wrote emo fanfiction about real life. What if she failed on every level? |
2013-08-25, 21:45 | Link #32911 |
Eaten by goats
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Rokkenjima
|
I think it's possible that he was created as an imaginary friend then but Yasu only acted him out later on, when she was already the head of the family. He may also only have been "real" at Jessica's school festival.
|
2013-08-25, 22:36 | Link #32912 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
The major issue with guns not being heard, is while it was never indicated that rain payed a part in telling when people went outside, in episode 1 it was certainly noted that people could hear Natsuhi's gun.
If Ryu hadn't tried to convince me that it was as loud as a champagne bottle, I would have said that it was just super loud inside the rooms, but through a shut door down a hallway and down some stairs in a thunderstorm was not that immediately recognizable. On the other hand, for an author who researches like Ryu, it is an odd oversight (but not unprecedented, if he can retcon a door...) As for the whole "X didn't have motive to murder everyone" arguments, I think they sort of miss the mark a little bit. A lot of the episodes go to pointing out that no-one really had a solid motive to personally go up to each person on the island and murder them face to face (which is quite a statement), but that it was the right setting for something bad to go wrong, and then have everyone die by the bomb. Ep 7 even shows how the bomb can be switched on or off accidentally by someone who doesn't believe Yasu. My opinion is that the message is that no-one has a motive to kill everyone, but they all died anyway. So even though something bad happened, likely a fight between siblings and even probably a direct death or two, there is almost certainly just an element of tragedy involved. Maybe that is why Eva always felt so guilty, maybe she threw the switch herself. Also, while I am not saying that it didn't happen, I am not sure "Kinzo used a business deal to get his son a wife and then never trusted her (after she "killed" a baby that was important to him)" is evidence that he raped his own daughter... |
2013-08-25, 22:46 | Link #32913 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
Also, I am quite sure that Ryu pointed out it was a little unfair, but that Kanon and Shannon didn't have to wear their own clothes to act as themselves.
Also also: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=257Hw7TsykI apparently the bolt actions are quieter, and it is ammo dependent. Listening to this (model winchester, real ammunition, skip the long start bit) they aren't THAT loud at all. Then again, that one has a barrel, which helps. |
2013-08-25, 23:54 | Link #32914 | |||||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
I do hope the manga goes a little bit more indepth concerning what lead the goats to believe that (evidence post-tragedy etc.). Quote:
This is sadly one of these elements that we just have to swallow, but, on the other hand, even big writers like Queen, Carr, Van Dine, Sayers, Christie and others made fairly stupid mistakes or bend the laws of nature to fit their stories. My favorite remains the man shot in the chest who still manages to climb up a building, leap over roofs, run into his house and prepare a locked room situation. Quote:
Heck, in An Offering to Nothingness both the culprit and the detective figure (both from a group of avid mystery readers) basically break the fourth wall and tell the author that it was not only them but the reader as well who wished for a horrible, complicated and yet beautiful murder-case scenario to occur, while actually it all leads to "Nothingness". Quote:
Sure, Kinzo was a misogynist, but probably a good 80-90% of all men during those days were misogynistic from today's point of view. Just like Anti-Semitism was en vogue in the 19th and early 20th century, Black jokes were celebrated well past the mid of the 20th century and LGBTQ people are still treated more of as stereotype then actual living beings, of course these are questionable if not horrible things from today's point of view, but people also have to be seen in the context of their environment. Kinzo was raised as a puppet and got a wife added to him like an accessory, his children being more an obligation he had to fulfill. The only actual friends he seemed to have close to him were a rambunctious noble from Taiwan, with whom he apparently didn't shy away from committing stuff that bordered on criminal, and a money-grabbing doctor with questionable work-ethics. I think Kinzo's psychological profile would turn out to be quite messed up from today's perspective...though maybe not if we look at celebrity news.. |
|||||
2013-08-26, 06:02 | Link #32915 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
And she might have excused her poor writing saying she was trying to make the games look as if Maria wrote them. Quote:
Also Jessica wouldn't harbour feelings for Kanon if she were to know he's Shannon or she wouldn't try to pair Shannon and George together. My best theory is that Shannon began to play the role of Kanon after Kinzo's death and with Natsuhi and Krauss' agreement so as to use Kanon as an extra servant who has viewed Kinzo was around when the siblings were around. Also it's possible due to Krauss poor business they couldn't hire more Fukuin children but didn't want to openly show this to the siblings so used 'Kanon' to make it look like they have enough servants. Note how the servants on Rokkenjima during the siblings' visits are all in with Kinzo's death apart from Gohda who can't be replaced because they need someone to prepare food and how Gohda was hired after Kinzo's death so he can't notice anything different in his behaviour. I like to think though that Natsuhi left Jessica out of this, so as not to force her to lie or be involved in the crime of hiding Kinzo's death. Jessica though might have her suspicions but since she seems to be pretty protective of her parents she might have not investigated too deep in this. It'll be interesting if Jessica's feelings for Kanon are all Yasu's fantasy and more than crushing after Kanon she was trying to be his friend and live better. Quote:
After all we can't prove the baby existed. His birth wasn't recordered, Natsuhi's confession to the grave of the husband of the maid supposedly wasn't witnessed, Genji, Kumasawa and Nanjo are dead and likely didn't let medical records that could prove that Kinzo's illegittimate child existed (though there can be documents of Nanjo taking care of a baby), for the Fukuin house the baby would be nothing more than another orphan so... it can very well be all in Yasu's mind as someone theorized in the past. So it can entirely be Kinzo never touched his daughter in Prime and never had a child from her. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||||||
2013-08-26, 06:55 | Link #32916 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
|
I think Kanon works similarly to Beatrice. He's just an imaginary friend at first, but then Yasu decides to rewrite the world so that she can be him, not just talk to him, at which point he is able to manifest to others. And presumably that change is triggered by her learning that she was born male, motivating her to try experimenting with a male persona - and, funnily enough, that's the exact point at which she becomes the head, so she can easily get Genji to pull some strings so that 'Kanon' can start working at the mansion. The motivation to make Kanon manifest in the human world and the access to the "magic" that could make that happen occurred at exactly the same time.
And I do think that people overstate how difficult it would be to pull off. It should be fairly easy for Genji to fix it so that Shannon and Kanon are almost never stationed at the mansion at the same time. I actually wouldn't be surprised if the 1986 family conference is one of if not the only time they're ever stationed together. |
2013-08-26, 08:22 | Link #32918 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
If a new servant boy was hired, and what's worse a new servant boy who's supposed to be in with the secret of Kinzo being dead as he's made Kinzo's special servant, I think she would like to have a say in all this. That's why I think Natsuhi (and Krauss) likely knew Shannon was playing a double role otherwise they wouldn't have trusted a stranger to be in with their secret, probably not even if Genji recommended him. Hiding Kinzo's death is serious business so I think they would be really wary about who can know and who can't (Gohda, for example, likely had no idea Kinzo was dead). |
|
2013-08-26, 08:24 | Link #32919 | |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
That said, it's supported, at least: Kinzo's entire motivation for the epitaph seems to be to find his missing heir who he is quite sure is "Beatrice." He seems crazy enough to recognize anybody who does this as Beatrice whether it's a reliable association or not; granted, he thinks Yasu looks like her, but let's be honest, Yasu can't IRL look anything like Beatrice or everybody would notice including Battler. So more likely than not his thought process boils down to "solved epitaph and is the right age and isn't one of my other kids or grandkids == my long-lost kid." All Genji has to do is nudge somebody toward that, which he does with Yasu. There's nothing to suggest that Yasu had any inherent advantage solely because of blood or anything, since the epitaph is a strictly intellectual thing. In fact, she was at a distinct disadvantage compared to Kinzo's children, in that she didn't know about the Taiwan thing until Genji dropped the hint. Also if Yasu isn't Lion then that explains the ep7 thing where Shannon and Kanon can't be in the same place but Lion can be in the same place as either of them, though that's pretty weak as a claim given the nature of that board. So one could argue that there was no baby, or the original baby (Lion) died, and that Yasu is a random replacement who happened to be of the right disposition and such to be chosen by Genji to fill the role. It's a devil's proof, it's unfalsifiable based on the information that we know. On the other hand, she was always given special treatment from the start. Granted, Yasu could just be sort of retroactively trying to justify her own specialness by believing that the reason she had special treatment was because of who she is, and not that she simply got lucky to be about the same age as Jessica. It could also be handwaved away as Genji planning for the long-term to give Kinzo mounting "evidence" that his child has secretly come back. There's also the apparent "confession" from Nanjo and Genji, although again we don't know what was said specifically and whether it was true (not like Nanjo can't be paid to lie). Since we know so little about Genji and even less about his recent motivations, it's impossible to say for sure what he was even trying to do. As people have pointed out, if Yasu is the child, then Genji's actions are reckless and grossly irresponsible, and we have no clear understanding of why he did what he did outside of a vague sense that he was trying to do this for Kinzo's sake. Maybe. I guess the biggest issue is whether Shannon/Kanon look anything like Kinzo or Beatrice at all. If they looked like Beatrice, surely someone would point out the similarity at some point or Battler would find her face familiar. If they looked like Kinzo, well... seems like that would be hard to hide, given that the family thinks Battler looks like Kinzo did as a young man, so they must know what Kinzo looked like at a younger age. You'd think someone would've caught on. Orphan-Yasu would entirely escape notice because she in fact does not resemble any of the others. But it also isn't impossible for a child not to resemble either of his or her parents.
__________________
|
|
Thread Tools | |
|
|