AnimeSuki Forums

Blablabla · 2006-08-07, 07:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by hizashi

Oh, and why do people not like Shinku? She's my favourite by FAR! I love the way she carries herself and love her soft side which doesn't come out all that often. 2nd favourite would be Suseiseki (gotta love that hair).

Because every Gin-fanboys are jealous to see Shinku spending her time kicking their yakult godess' ass.

NezoR · 2006-08-07, 07:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flo

Well this just in, even the Japanese ppl in 2channel hates Stinku.

What's with all the Shinku hate?

^^ Kanaria is a far more annoying character than Shinku ever was.

^^ I also feel like doing this to her everytime she opens her mouth.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mincemaker

Well, then again....she is blonde....and high-and-mighty...

What does her being blonde have to do with anything?

Flo · 2006-08-07, 08:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mincemaker

It is well known that despite having a sum of her good points, the Japanese hates Shinku and worships either Suiseiseki or Her Royal Highness Gin-sama.

That is correct, many Japanese RM fans worship Desu and Junk the most. (Thus having the most fan-art of them)

Quote:

Originally Posted by NezoR

What's with all the Shinku hate?

^^ Kanaria is a far more annoying character than Shinku ever was.

Kana is much cuter than Stinku by far

Quote:

Originally Posted by NezoR

What does her being blonde have to do with anything?

Something about arrogant westerner I guess. *coughJPNHAETUScough*

Mincemaker · 2006-08-07, 08:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by NezoR

What does her being blonde have to do with anything?

Japan hates blonde, or so I was told.

Blablabla · 2006-08-07, 08:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by NezoR

What's with all the Shinku hate?

^^ Kanaria is a far more annoying character than Shinku ever was.

I agree... and Hina, too...

Quote:

That is correct, many Japanese RM fans worship Desu and Junk the most. (Thus having the most fan-art of them)

It seems that in previous Anime Saimoe tournament, Shinku won against Gin (and finished 3rd behind Sousei Seki and Nanoha). They don't seem to dislike her that much.

Quote:

Something about arrogant westerner I guess. *coughJPNHAETUScough*

Shinku ? Arrogant ? I don't remember hearing her sayinge "I'm the best, I will junk your ass bwa ha ha ha... ha". She is pride and has her "lady like cute and funny" attitude, nothing more.

hizashi · 2006-08-07, 09:14

Oh well, each to his own I guess. I like Shinku heaps though

Anyway, what about the other question? Are there any plans afoot for Season 3? I can't get enough of it! Don't exactly know why though......anime never had any appeal for me for some reason...till now....

the.Merines · 2006-08-07, 09:49

... kashira.

I think they intentionally made Shinku a bit more reserved and adult than the rest of the dolls for a reason. There has to be some kind of "voice of wisdom" so everyone doesn't fly off the handle everytime a strawberry goes missing ~desu.

As for Season 3... in time, I think. There have been a couple rumors about there being a "special" or OVA being shown at TBS's Anime Festa on this upcoming Aug. 19th, but personally I believe it's just a special showing of Träumend. Looking back, S1 aired from October to December '04, with news of a sequel coming in March '05. S2 aired from October '05 to January '06.

If news of a S3/OVA doesn't come during the TBS Anime Festa, I suspect we will have to wait for one or maybe even two more volumes of the manga to be released, which means at least another year... If Peach-Pit works with the show's creative writers and whatnot, exchanging of ideas... Maybe we could see something next spring. Like S2, where some manga plotpoints were introduced but the season really revolved around Barasuishou, who was created by the animation team and not Peach-Pit...

Arg, it's too much to wait! I want one 45 minute OVA every three months, starting Oct. '06!

Lost · 2006-08-07, 10:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flo

Well this just in, even the Japanese ppl in 2channel hates Stinku.

LOL.. but but.. that was Suiseiseki's handiwork. No doubt, Suiseiseki hates Shinku because she's jealous.

I dont hate Shinku, and I agree that she isnt arrogant, just proud of her pedigree as the most dignified of Rozen Maidens.

Couldn't find a better word. And yes, personally, Kanaria is much more irritating than her. No! Hina is not annoying!

Welcome hizashi, Suiseiseki is my personal favourite.

Quote:

Originally Posted by the.Merines

I think they intentionally made Shinku a bit more reserved and adult than the rest of the dolls for a reason. There has to be some kind of "voice of wisdom" so everyone doesn't fly off the handle everytime a strawberry goes missing ~desu.

And whose gonna lead a KunKun cosplay search with Souseiseki gone?

Skane · 2006-08-07, 11:08

I don't dislike Shinku, and I did find some endearing moments involving her. Not my favourite by far though.

1) Suiseiseki
2) Sugintou
3) Tie between Souseiseki and Shinku
4) Kira
5) Hina( season 2 saved her, otherwise...)

Kanaria can go jump into a trash compactor for all I care.

RM-FAN · 2006-08-07, 14:31

First welcome to this forum and second i dont know why Shinku got much detractors, that is a pitty

my order of my favs RM dolls are:

1.SUIGINTOU
2.SHINKU
3.KIRAKISHOU
4.SUISEISEKI
5.HINAICHIGO
6.KANARIA
7.SOUSEISEKI
8.BARASUISHOU

And about third season, we can only wait for the TBS expo in this August 19, please, GOD heard us.

Calca · 2006-08-07, 14:49

I agree, the Shinku hate has to stop.

Sometimes the board confuses me with the amount of love they give the evil dolls who wish to kill the other dolls and yet hate the main protagonist doll.

the.Merines · 2006-08-07, 15:01

Because dolls aren't necessarily evil. Except Kira, but we barely know her. I've said it before, but part of the show's appeal is the universal acceptance of all the dolls. It sounds wishy-washy to say, "Oh, I love all the Rozen Maiden." People mainly bash on Shinku or Kanaria. Shinku is the central doll of the series; no one can change that.

Kanaria-chan... With every time I watch through season 2, I appreciate her a little more, though I felt cheated that she got more screen time than Souseiseki.

RM-FAN · 2006-08-07, 16:27

Now that mention to Kirakishou, you dont think that the "real" number of Rozen Maidens only be SIX and Kira can be an "intruder" like Bara?

All us know that Bara was an impostore but, if Kira is the real doll number seven ¿how Father can be create her if she dont got phisycal body, dont got Rosa Mistyca and ONLY exist in the N-Field,? and more importan, why Father when "rebirth" to Shinku and the others never make mention of Kirakishou to Shinku?

the.Merines · 2006-08-07, 18:16

Rozen works in mysterious ways. Perhaps he planned to create Kirakishou, but something happened and he halted before creating her physical body. However, maybe a part of him wished for her to be completed and created her in an "n-Field form" only.

Or maybe he realized that Enju was copying his design and stopped before making her. It's just a possibility... Tokyopop really needs to get the manga out more quickly! I demand all volumes up to and including 7 be released by the end of the year!

blitz1/2 · 2006-08-07, 18:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by the.Merines

Rozen works in mysterious ways. Perhaps he planned to create Kirakishou, but something happened and he halted before creating her physical body. However, maybe a part of him wished for her to be completed and created her in an "n-Field form" only.

Or maybe he realized that Enju was copying his design and stopped before making her. It's just a possibility... Tokyopop really needs to get the manga out more quickly! I demand all volumes up to and including 7 be released by the end of the year!

I'm guessing it's 1 manga for every 3 months so you got a long time to wait.

Perhaps, when Kirakishou was completed, Barasuishou may have destroyed Kira's body and therefore Kira has no body.

But I still agree with your explanations/ideas.

Blablabla · 2006-08-07, 19:31

But Barasuishou doesn't exist in the manga... she she could not have destroyed Kira's body.
And in the anime... well we don't know how they may introduce Kira... if an other season is planed, of course.

Mincemaker · 2006-08-07, 20:20

Kirakishou is going to possess someone's body (I think Hina in the manga), so she can stalk Gin-sama.

My number one will always be Gin-sama. Here is the list of my favorite dolls from favorite to least favorite:

1. Gin-sama
2. Souseiseki (for being the know-it-all she is)
3. Suiseiseki
4. Shinku
5. Hinaichigo
6. Kanaria

Still can't rate Kirakishou, seeing that we don't know much about Her Psychoness.

blitz1/2 · 2006-08-07, 20:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mincemaker

Kirakishou is going to possess someone's body (I think Hina in the manga), so she can stalk Gin-sama.

My number one will always be Gin-sama. Here is the list of my favorite dolls from favorite to least favorite:

1. Gin-sama
2. Souseiseki (for being the know-it-all she is)
3. Suiseiseki
4. Shinku
5. Hinaichigo
6. Kanaria

Still can't rate Kirakishou, seeing that we don't know much about Her Psychoness.

You forgot Bara (even though she isn't a real RM)

hizashi · 2006-08-07, 21:34

Hrm..since everyone is listing their favourite dolls, I'll do the same

Didn't read the manga so no Kirasuishou for me.

1) Shinku
2) Shinku
3) Shinku
4) Suiseiseki
5) Sugintou (feel sorry for her I think)
6) Hinaichigo (cute butt

)
7) Souseiseki (I think her character wasn't sufficiently developed)
8) Barasuishou
9) Kanaria (she gets a little annoying)

Shadow Miko · 2006-08-07, 22:02

Same here might as well make a list <3.

1.Kirakishou
2.Kanaria (technically Jun would go next but I'm just listing the dolls)
3.Souseiseki
4.Shinku
5.Barasuishou
6.Suigintou
7.Hina-Ichigo
8.Suiseiseki (<-HATE!)

2006-08-07, 09:49	Link #5027
the.Merines Seeker of Power Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: ΔHidden Forbidden Holy Ground Age: 39	... kashira. I think they intentionally made Shinku a bit more reserved and adult than the rest of the dolls for a reason. There has to be some kind of "voice of wisdom" so everyone doesn't fly off the handle everytime a strawberry goes missing ~desu. As for Season 3... in time, I think. There have been a couple rumors about there being a "special" or OVA being shown at TBS's Anime Festa on this upcoming Aug. 19th, but personally I believe it's just a special showing of Träumend. Looking back, S1 aired from October to December '04, with news of a sequel coming in March '05. S2 aired from October '05 to January '06. If news of a S3/OVA doesn't come during the TBS Anime Festa, I suspect we will have to wait for one or maybe even two more volumes of the manga to be released, which means at least another year... If Peach-Pit works with the show's creative writers and whatnot, exchanging of ideas... Maybe we could see something next spring. Like S2, where some manga plotpoints were introduced but the season really revolved around Barasuishou, who was created by the animation team and not Peach-Pit... Arg, it's too much to wait! I want one 45 minute OVA every three months, starting Oct. '06! __________________ I am bound to pay the debt I owe.

2006-08-07, 11:08	Link #5029
Skane Anime Snark Join Date: May 2006 Location: Singapore Age: 41	I don't dislike Shinku, and I did find some endearing moments involving her. Not my favourite by far though. 1) Suiseiseki 2) Sugintou 3) Tie between Souseiseki and Shinku 4) Kira 5) Hina( season 2 saved her, otherwise...) Kanaria can go jump into a trash compactor for all I care. __________________ Hearthstone Battletag: Skane#1425 [Can't GIF This], [Jail's House of Rock], [Kanon In The Snow], [She Ain't Dead Yet... She's In Quantum], [She Stabs] Founder of "The Cult of Psycho-Moe", Member of "ARIA the Social Group" & the "Belkan Saint Church".

2006-08-07, 15:01	Link #5032
the.Merines Seeker of Power Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: ΔHidden Forbidden Holy Ground Age: 39	Because dolls aren't necessarily evil. Except Kira, but we barely know her. I've said it before, but part of the show's appeal is the universal acceptance of all the dolls. It sounds wishy-washy to say, "Oh, I love all the Rozen Maiden." People mainly bash on Shinku or Kanaria. Shinku is the central doll of the series; no one can change that. Kanaria-chan... With every time I watch through season 2, I appreciate her a little more, though I felt cheated that she got more screen time than Souseiseki. __________________ I am bound to pay the debt I owe.

2006-08-07, 18:16	Link #5034
the.Merines Seeker of Power Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: ΔHidden Forbidden Holy Ground Age: 39	Rozen works in mysterious ways. Perhaps he planned to create Kirakishou, but something happened and he halted before creating her physical body. However, maybe a part of him wished for her to be completed and created her in an "n-Field form" only. Or maybe he realized that Enju was copying his design and stopped before making her. It's just a possibility... Tokyopop really needs to get the manga out more quickly! I demand all volumes up to and including 7 be released by the end of the year! __________________ I am bound to pay the debt I owe.

2006-08-07, 22:02	Link #5040
Shadow Miko ASuki's #1 Virgillia fan~ Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Moriya Shrine, Gensokyo Age: 31	Same here might as well make a list <3. 1.Kirakishou 2.Kanaria (technically Jun would go next but I'm just listing the dolls) 3.Souseiseki 4.Shinku 5.Barasuishou 6.Suigintou 7.Hina-Ichigo 8.Suiseiseki (<-HATE!) __________________ WAS Hanyuu's biggest fangirl, my heart belongs to Virgillia now. <3 Loli Salad - A blog of epic-proportions!

2006-08-07, 09:14	Link #5026
hizashi Shinku's Devout Medium Join Date: Aug 2006	Oh well, each to his own I guess. I like Shinku heaps though Anyway, what about the other question? Are there any plans afoot for Season 3? I can't get enough of it! Don't exactly know why though......anime never had any appeal for me for some reason...till now....

2006-08-07, 14:31	Link #5030
RM-FAN Anti-Nina Einstein Join Date: May 2006 Location: In a N-Field named "Mexico" Age: 44	First welcome to this forum and second i dont know why Shinku got much detractors, that is a pitty my order of my favs RM dolls are: 1.SUIGINTOU 2.SHINKU 3.KIRAKISHOU 4.SUISEISEKI 5.HINAICHIGO 6.KANARIA 7.SOUSEISEKI 8.BARASUISHOU And about third season, we can only wait for the TBS expo in this August 19, please, GOD heard us.

2006-08-07, 14:49	Link #5031
Calca Expressionless Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Walking on the path known as life	I agree, the Shinku hate has to stop. Sometimes the board confuses me with the amount of love they give the evil dolls who wish to kill the other dolls and yet hate the main protagonist doll.

2006-08-07, 16:27	Link #5033
RM-FAN Anti-Nina Einstein Join Date: May 2006 Location: In a N-Field named "Mexico" Age: 44	Now that mention to Kirakishou, you dont think that the "real" number of Rozen Maidens only be SIX and Kira can be an "intruder" like Bara? All us know that Bara was an impostore but, if Kira is the real doll number seven ¿how Father can be create her if she dont got phisycal body, dont got Rosa Mistyca and ONLY exist in the N-Field,? and more importan, why Father when "rebirth" to Shinku and the others never make mention of Kirakishou to Shinku?

2006-08-07, 19:31	Link #5036
Blablabla Zetsubo-sensei daaaaaa !! Join Date: Dec 2005	But Barasuishou doesn't exist in the manga... she she could not have destroyed Kira's body. And in the anime... well we don't know how they may introduce Kira... if an other season is planed, of course.

2006-08-07, 20:20	Link #5037
Mincemaker Hmmm? Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Brill, Tirisfal Glade	Kirakishou is going to possess someone's body (I think Hina in the manga), so she can stalk Gin-sama. My number one will always be Gin-sama. Here is the list of my favorite dolls from favorite to least favorite: 1. Gin-sama 2. Souseiseki (for being the know-it-all she is) 3. Suiseiseki 4. Shinku 5. Hinaichigo 6. Kanaria Still can't rate Kirakishou, seeing that we don't know much about Her Psychoness.

2006-08-07, 21:34	Link #5039
hizashi Shinku's Devout Medium Join Date: Aug 2006	Hrm..since everyone is listing their favourite dolls, I'll do the same Didn't read the manga so no Kirasuishou for me. 1) Shinku 2) Shinku 3) Shinku 4) Suiseiseki 5) Sugintou (feel sorry for her I think) 6) Hinaichigo (cute butt ) 7) Souseiseki (I think her character wasn't sufficiently developed) 8) Barasuishou 9) Kanaria (she gets a little annoying)