2011-03-12, 06:25 | Link #762 | |
SIBYL salesman
Join Date: Feb 2011
|
Quote:
And as revealed in ep 9: What he is: alien collecting energy What he's planning: Turn Madoka into a Mahou Shoujo to collect her energy. I'm not sure why people want to suggest Kyubei has ulterior motives over ulterior motives that was just revealed. |
|
2011-03-12, 08:11 | Link #763 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
|
Quote:
Walpurgis Night , as some other theories in other threads , and perhaps before this , might not be the Witch of a Single fallen Puella Magi , but rather , a collection of Grief Seeds merged together into a Single powerful entity called Walpurgis Night. A gathering of Witches manifested as a Single Super-witch . Walpurgis Night , I believe , is fully controlled by Kyubey . It probably can only be executed once a certain number of Grief Seeds are collected, and perhaps some other conditions , and when it's triggered , produces immense amounts of Material used to defy Entropy. In other words , Kyubey could be Walpurgis - or more accurately, Walpurgis is a mere drone "Witch"; made out of multiple Witches controlled directly by Kyubey . Killing it of course , does not kill Kyubey - any more than shooting down a UAV kills the pilot controlling it from hundereds of kilometers away. Given that some Magical Girls may take a very long time to become Witches , Walpurgis Night might also play a role in encouraging the formation of new Witches , in addition to becoming a Madoka Esque power source . In fact , what makes Madoka unique might be the fact that her full potential is equal to that of dozens of Magical Girls - multiple Walpurgis Nights combined. |
|
2011-03-29, 10:55 | Link #766 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Houston
Age: 36
|
I just thought of something that I wonder about now. We now know that Homura's weapons are normal guns/explosives but in the scene where Homura makes Swiss cheese out of QB. Why is it the background bench does not suffer any damage despite the bullets clearly have gone through QB.
I wonder if the disintegrate upon contact with his insides, like in Alien. I also have a big question about QB. How did he start this whole system? I how did he get this first MG to become a Witch? I can easily see how you can find some poor girl who has a wish and granting it. But I wonder how the conversation went. QB: Hey, form a contract with me and become a MG. Girl: What do I do as a MG? QB: ... Soul Gems must be capable of taint beyond just fighting Witches, otherwise how could the first Witch have been born? Unless QB also brought some alien Witches at first to get the ball rolling.
__________________
Last edited by Sekirei07; 2011-03-29 at 11:08. |
2011-03-30, 03:13 | Link #768 | |
SIBYL salesman
Join Date: Feb 2011
|
Quote:
If you're dying it'd be easy to get them to wish to live and skip the whole explanation the cost. And despair accelerates the rate of the taint - case in point: Sayaka. |
|
2011-04-20, 03:18 | Link #769 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Tennessee
Age: 36
|
I'm rewatching the whole series to refresh my memory for the last two episodes/just for something fun to do (I marathoned 1-5 tonight, will do the same for 6-10 tomorrow). A certain line from Kyubey in the second episode really jumped out at me. This is going by the Nutbladder version, around 11:45 into the episode.
Sayaka: There's plenty of things I want and things I'd like to do. But I can't get over the 'risking my life' part. I don't want anything that bad. Kyubey: Wow, I'm surprised. Most girls go right for it. wait, what Surprise is an emotion, Kyubey. That (loveable) little lying bastard... now I'm wondering whether he was telling the truth or not when he claimed that his species doesn't have emotions. Well, just 33 hours until the last two episodes, so maybe the whole issue will be answered then. Kyubey never fails to surprise, amaze, and amuse, so I'm curious to see what role he'll play in the finale. Should add a few feathers to his troll hat. |
2011-04-20, 06:52 | Link #770 |
Twilight lander
|
Coming from him, that might be a figure of speech. Otherwise, he's capable of specifically reacting to unexpected things and "surprise" is the closest word to describe it in conversation, but he doesn't consider it a real emotion. If we go by the subs, he seems to use this word freely - in ep 9 he tells Kyouko he wouldn't be surprised if she managed to convert Octavia back to Sayaka.
Emotions are basically reactions. Maybe in Kyuubey's POV not all reactions can be called emotions... as not all reactions yield sufficient energy? If his classification is downright practical, then from human perspective, his race MIGHT have a basic set of emotions, only heavily subdued in comparison - thus not really counting by his criteria. /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ |
2011-04-20, 19:08 | Link #771 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
|
Surprise is hardly an emotion. It happens when something does not result the way an individual expects it to.
And emotions are not "basically reactions". Quote:
Quote:
|
||
2011-04-21, 20:41 | Link #775 |
Banned
|
Well, from one point of view... he gave mankind civilization and is a big reason why we are at this technologically developed. It cost us some girls here and there, but also helped forestall entropy.
From a strictly logical, emotionless point of view, it would seem to be more than a fair trade. |
2011-04-21, 21:49 | Link #776 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2010
|
Score! So I assume from the comments that the QB != Evil Team won? In Yo Face, QB = Evil Team! I haven't actually watched the last two eps (They're downloading now) but I never got the impression QB was evil. He would have been a better manipulator if he were since many times the information he offered up freely was the very thing which would hurt his cause the most and make the girls freak out. In the entire series there was only 1 problematic statement where I questioned his intentions and that was the whole, WitchMadoka blow up the world in 10 days but I don't care, I've met my quota and it's miller time. That made no sense to me since it would seem Entropy was an ongoing problem. Having someone blow up your source of Entropy repellent and not caring seemed to make no sense and suggested that fighting off Entropy might not have been his real goal. I still don't know if that was just a poor translation or if there's something in the last two eps that fixes it.
|
2011-04-21, 21:53 | Link #777 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2008
|
Quote:
QB after the reset is slightly more benevolent because magical girls no longer become witches. They fight something else and they can get rid of the darkness in the soul gems easier it seems. Of course they can still die or disappear but that seems to just be the hazard they take for a wish, it doesn't seem like a guaranteed situation like it was before.
__________________
|
|
2011-04-21, 22:05 | Link #778 |
Banned
|
I wouldn't say it was a matter of Kyube being evil or not (and thus one side or the other "winning"). Kyube wasn't evil in the "Mwahahaha! I'm a villain!" sense. He lacked emotions, being purely logical, doing what he was doing for what he felt was for the greater good of all. At best, one could call him antagonistic, and he certainly came across quite dickish; but then again, McCoy also had things to say about Spock, heh.
The whole "Kyube defender" thing was partially a joke, mainly to introduce new lines of thought, since the prevailing one was "Kyube is evil!" and no one seemed to be considering otherwise. In that light, I'd say we succeeded, since many people changed their viewpoint, and at least began considering alternate explanations. What people like Triple R and myself were coming from, was that Kyube felt so downright evil and creepy from nearly day 1 that the evil explanation felt too... simplistic and obvious. We felt there was a more complex explanation. And of course, the whole defense attorney thing was to have fun with the concept, heh. But yeah, now Kyube seems to at least be no longer antagonistic, working with the girls. Time will tell how things change, with any spinoffs and sequels. |
2011-04-21, 22:20 | Link #779 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2010
|
I don't frequent anime message boards much and only tossed off a few QB != Evil comments here so I wasn't aware that the overwhelming consensus was that he was evil among anime fans. Thus my opinion wasn't a backlash against the general consensus, I just never really got that impression from him watching the series. He just never did the 'right' things if his goal was really malicious and completely self-centered. I think people just have a tendency to jump to conclusions in cases like this. If the girls are good then anyone who makes the girls sad must be evil. It's a ridiculously simplistic (and often wrong) way of looking at things.
|
2011-04-21, 22:25 | Link #780 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2007
Age: 38
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
Tags |
characters |
|
|