AnimeSuki Forums

Pendevous · 2007-08-30, 07:57

1st one: *saves* I like it.

9.5/10

2nd one: Would be better with a border. 8/10

3rd one: Don't like the barcodes that much because the renders don't blend well with the background. 7.5/10

Here are mine:

Spoiler:

~Tsukuyomi · 2007-08-30, 08:44

@Pendevous
1st:
Random placement of paintbrushes, with horrid erasing job on the main focus... Render job is around the head is quite noticeable and the strong redish color over the right side is too strong... 5/10

2nd:
Basic background work with just basic brushing... Don't know what wrongs with the pattern going under Haruhi's boobs... 3/10

3rd:
Another basic paintbrush work... Placement makes thing look a tad bit attractive, there's nothing "SPECIAL" about it... 6/10

Final Thought:
Go study more on the basics of depth, colors, and lighting... Learning just those 3 all together can actually improve your sigs you have on now by maybe 10-20%... Also, learn a bit more on effect building, because seriously, paintbrushes are SOOOO boring...

Sephi · 2007-08-30, 12:40

~Tsukuyomi
Bit cluttered for my taste due to the bg full with ls characters. And not to found of the line myself. Other than that. Looks ok. 7.5/10

Pendevous: I like it. I just don't see the point of the height, since it's empty anyway

But i like the overall looks. And nice change from the usual anime signatures i see here. 8/10

CXC: Not to found of the black stroke myself. Other than that it looks ok. 7.5/10

Runa: Bg is nice. Render looks good to. Just the border which i'm not to found of, but that is just meh. 8/10

Azami: Very bright and soothing as usual

But as runa mentioned the brightness went a bit overkill on this one. 8.5/10 And i think it would be better if you save it as a jpeg with a white bg instead of the PNG-8. I can see some quality lose. Unless those miniscule white dots are on purpose and part of the render/sig, than ignore the pgn blabla of me.

matradley: Cute

but the font is a bit plain. 7.5/10

Wandy · 2007-08-30, 12:52

Sephi - 8.5/10 love what you've done with the sig XD..I was going to make that into a siggy because I have the render..but first I need to watch the anime

and yes there is a big loss of image quality when I downsized it >_> if I save it on jpeg the round border will become all white :x

Mystearika · 2007-08-30, 14:22

azamii> so pretty i really like the ligt colours and its so sweet 10/10

by the way my sig is my first so that is why it is not so great

i have drawn the drawing myself, becouse i didnt wantet to usew fanart ^^:

Rhyel · 2007-08-30, 14:54

@ Sephi 10/10 Kawaii Aria signature
@ Azami 9/10 Great, but a dark pink color font make it better.
@ Mystearika 8/10 I like it.

Humm I change my signature, based on episode 22 of Claymore. No much work on it.

TakutoKun · 2007-08-30, 17:14

@Azami: Kawaii!! Though I cannot really read the text. @.@ 9/10

@CXC: That's pretty cool! A bit of a rough cut though. 8.5/10

@Pendevous: Shiny... @.@ I want one! 8.5/10

@Mystearika: She's cute but the signature is a bit empty - 9/10

konstargirl · 2007-08-30, 17:49

@Rhyelys: Ooo. Looks so halloween like love the black thats fits in your siggy. 9/10

@Mystearika: I agree with matradley it looks a little plan but simle 7/10

@Azami: So pretty but its alot bright don't you think maybe it can be a little darker. 8.5/10

@~Tsukuyomi: Lucky star. Thats a really cute siggy. 9/10

New siggy. I'm not going to use it for here but I'm going to use it on other forums:

xxmimixx · 2007-08-30, 19:32

Nuriko: like I said in your thread, wow! Just wow (at the new signature)!! 100/10 because the squares look so creative lol.

Azami : Seems bright but it is pretty. 10/10

Rhyelys: Simple but I don't like the dark theme though. 8/10

Everyone else: between 8 and 9 out of 10 =).

Wandy · 2007-08-30, 23:22

Nuriko - 7/10 if you cut them up into small to medium puzzles pieces rather than big sized pieces they look better

konstargirl · 2007-08-31, 06:22

@Azami: This was my first time doing it though. I'll get better though. :P

@Pendevous: 9/10 for all of your siggys you post in. They are just too cool to me.

@Mr.Incest: 8/10 for all of your siggy. One they look simple. Two you couldn't work on t a little more. And three it looks like you were being cheap on yourself in the third especially

TakutoKun · 2007-08-31, 14:35

@nuriko_konstar_2006: I like it. Very nicely done! 9/10 Though, it appears to be of lower quality. Is that an effect?

Cyz · 2007-08-31, 21:57

@ Azami: The pic is cute though it's bright. The text is a little harder to read too. 7/10

Jechtsphere · 2007-08-31, 22:05

@ Cyz: Liking the soft blue colors in the background along with the cute girl although you can tell she was cut out of something else or maybe it's intentional what do I know lol, like it very much reguardless. 8.5/10

Thingle · 2007-09-01, 02:10

@Cyz
8. Nice model but simple BG.

konstargirl · 2007-09-01, 06:57

@Jechtsphere: Love the background but the man looks scary 8/10

@Mr.Incest:9/10 love the border.

@Matradley: i just brighten it up a little. Also I use a tutorial for the siggy and it said save it on Gif or PNG. So I save it on both PNG and Gif

Wandy · 2007-09-01, 21:07

Jecht 6/10 it's missing lighting, would love to see it have gradient maps, photo filters and gaussian blur...what's that butt naked angel there? o_o is that just some random thing you put in ?

TakutoKun · 2007-09-01, 21:26

@Jechtsphere: Though it is a bit rough, I like the work. However, I must agree with Azami, what is the angel for? 7.5/10

@Mr.Incest: I still love it! 10/10

@Azami: I know the intent is not Christmas, but I get a Christmas-feeling by looking at your signature. 9/10

Runa · 2007-09-02, 01:31

Azami = 7/10... it's quite good image for a crop sigs... but shouldn't you change the size ? max 160 px for the height i believe... also to make it alive you could put some text on it^^ and the last things is... where is your usual rounded edge go^^ ?

strung_out · 2007-09-02, 03:13

Azami: Really nice! It has a "magic" feel to it, a border would be nice but that's just me

8.5/10
Matradley:Cute! Seems just a bit gritty though. Nice font and colour, it goes well with the background 8/10
Runa: Wow, really nice sig! The black goes with the pink very well, the picture is sharp and clear and the border is awesome!!! 10/10

And about Jechtsphere's "Angel"... it's a fairy named Puck. He follows Guts (the man in Jecht's sig) around everywhere he goes.

2007-08-30, 07:57	Link #3821
Pendevous Yoroshiku Graphic Designer Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Philippines Age: 36	1st one: saves I like it. 9.5/10 2nd one: Would be better with a border. 8/10 3rd one: Don't like the barcodes that much because the renders don't blend well with the background. 7.5/10 Here are mine: Spoiler: A gift to someone: My enter in another forum's SOTW:

2007-08-30, 12:40	Link #3823
Sephi Thinking outside the box Graphic Designer Join Date: May 2007 Location: The Netherlands Age: 37	~Tsukuyomi Bit cluttered for my taste due to the bg full with ls characters. And not to found of the line myself. Other than that. Looks ok. 7.5/10 Pendevous: I like it. I just don't see the point of the height, since it's empty anyway But i like the overall looks. And nice change from the usual anime signatures i see here. 8/10 CXC: Not to found of the black stroke myself. Other than that it looks ok. 7.5/10 Runa: Bg is nice. Render looks good to. Just the border which i'm not to found of, but that is just meh. 8/10 Azami: Very bright and soothing as usual But as runa mentioned the brightness went a bit overkill on this one. 8.5/10 And i think it would be better if you save it as a jpeg with a white bg instead of the PNG-8. I can see some quality lose. Unless those miniscule white dots are on purpose and part of the render/sig, than ignore the pgn blabla of me. matradley: Cute but the font is a bit plain. 7.5/10 __________________ Currently watching: Aria the Origination & Dennou Coil Sephi: Anime Icons \| Signatures & Avatars \| Renders

2007-08-30, 14:22	Link #3825
Mystearika Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2007	azamii> so pretty i really like the ligt colours and its so sweet 10/10 by the way my sig is my first so that is why it is not so great i have drawn the drawing myself, becouse i didnt wantet to usew fanart ^^: __________________

2007-08-30, 14:54	Link #3826
Rhyel Senior Member Graphic Designer Join Date: May 2007 Location: Solar System Age: 48	@ Sephi 10/10 Kawaii Aria signature @ Azami 9/10 Great, but a dark pink color font make it better. @ Mystearika 8/10 I like it. Humm I change my signature, based on episode 22 of Claymore. No much work on it. __________________ Thanks KiNA for this lovely signature.

2007-08-30, 17:49	Link #3828
konstargirl Reisen FTW! Graphic Designer Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Chicago,IL, USA!!!! Age: 31	@Rhyelys: Ooo. Looks so halloween like love the black thats fits in your siggy. 9/10 @Mystearika: I agree with matradley it looks a little plan but simle 7/10 @Azami: So pretty but its alot bright don't you think maybe it can be a little darker. 8.5/10 @~Tsukuyomi: Lucky star. Thats a really cute siggy. 9/10 New siggy. I'm not going to use it for here but I'm going to use it on other forums: __________________ My graphics thread. come and check it out.

2007-08-30, 08:44	Link #3822
~Tsukuyomi [- Caramelldansen Spam -] Join Date: Aug 2006	@Pendevous 1st: Random placement of paintbrushes, with horrid erasing job on the main focus... Render job is around the head is quite noticeable and the strong redish color over the right side is too strong... 5/10 2nd: Basic background work with just basic brushing... Don't know what wrongs with the pattern going under Haruhi's boobs... 3/10 3rd: Another basic paintbrush work... Placement makes thing look a tad bit attractive, there's nothing "SPECIAL" about it... 6/10 Final Thought: Go study more on the basics of depth, colors, and lighting... Learning just those 3 all together can actually improve your sigs you have on now by maybe 10-20%... Also, learn a bit more on effect building, because seriously, paintbrushes are SOOOO boring...

2007-08-30, 12:52	Link #3824
Wandy Starlight StarBright~ Fansubber Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Canada	Sephi - 8.5/10 love what you've done with the sig XD..I was going to make that into a siggy because I have the render..but first I need to watch the anime and yes there is a big loss of image quality when I downsized it >_> if I save it on jpeg the round border will become all white :x

2007-08-30, 17:14	Link #3827
TakutoKun Mew Member IT Support Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Ontario, Canada Age: 39	@Azami: Kawaii!! Though I cannot really read the text. @.@ 9/10 @CXC: That's pretty cool! A bit of a rough cut though. 8.5/10 @Pendevous: Shiny... @.@ I want one! 8.5/10 @Mystearika: She's cute but the signature is a bit empty - 9/10

2007-08-30, 19:32	Link #3829
xxmimixx ♥Sebastian's new wife♥ Artist Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: USA Age: 31	Nuriko: like I said in your thread, wow! Just wow (at the new signature)!! 100/10 because the squares look so creative lol. Azami : Seems bright but it is pretty. 10/10 Rhyelys: Simple but I don't like the dark theme though. 8/10 Everyone else: between 8 and 9 out of 10 =). __________________ Deviantart

2007-08-30, 23:22	Link #3830
Wandy Starlight StarBright~ Fansubber Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Canada	Nuriko - 7/10 if you cut them up into small to medium puzzles pieces rather than big sized pieces they look better

2007-08-31, 06:22	Link #3831
konstargirl Reisen FTW! Graphic Designer Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Chicago,IL, USA!!!! Age: 31	@Azami: This was my first time doing it though. I'll get better though. :P @Pendevous: 9/10 for all of your siggys you post in. They are just too cool to me. @Mr.Incest: 8/10 for all of your siggy. One they look simple. Two you couldn't work on t a little more. And three it looks like you were being cheap on yourself in the third especially __________________ My graphics thread. come and check it out.

2007-08-31, 14:35	Link #3832
TakutoKun Mew Member IT Support Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Ontario, Canada Age: 39	@nuriko_konstar_2006: I like it. Very nicely done! 9/10 Though, it appears to be of lower quality. Is that an effect?

2007-08-31, 22:05	Link #3834
Jechtsphere The Black Swordsman Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Antioch, California Age: 39	@ Cyz: Liking the soft blue colors in the background along with the cute girl although you can tell she was cut out of something else or maybe it's intentional what do I know lol, like it very much reguardless. 8.5/10

2007-09-01, 02:10	Link #3835
Thingle Banned Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Imperial Manila, Philippines	@Cyz 8. Nice model but simple BG.

2007-09-01, 06:57	Link #3836
konstargirl Reisen FTW! Graphic Designer Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Chicago,IL, USA!!!! Age: 31	@Jechtsphere: Love the background but the man looks scary 8/10 @Mr.Incest:9/10 love the border. @Matradley: i just brighten it up a little. Also I use a tutorial for the siggy and it said save it on Gif or PNG. So I save it on both PNG and Gif __________________ My graphics thread. come and check it out.

2007-09-01, 21:07	Link #3837
Wandy Starlight StarBright~ Fansubber Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Canada	Jecht 6/10 it's missing lighting, would love to see it have gradient maps, photo filters and gaussian blur...what's that butt naked angel there? o_o is that just some random thing you put in ? Last edited by Wandy; 2007-09-01 at 21:20.

2007-09-01, 21:26	Link #3838
TakutoKun Mew Member IT Support Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Ontario, Canada Age: 39	@Jechtsphere: Though it is a bit rough, I like the work. However, I must agree with Azami, what is the angel for? 7.5/10 @Mr.Incest: I still love it! 10/10 @Azami: I know the intent is not Christmas, but I get a Christmas-feeling by looking at your signature. 9/10

2007-09-02, 01:31	Link #3839
Runa Fallen Angel Graphic Designer Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: why ask ?? Age: 38	Azami = 7/10... it's quite good image for a crop sigs... but shouldn't you change the size ? max 160 px for the height i believe... also to make it alive you could put some text on it^^ and the last things is... where is your usual rounded edge go^^ ? __________________

2007-09-02, 03:13	Link #3840
strung_out Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Ontario, Canada	Azami: Really nice! It has a "magic" feel to it, a border would be nice but that's just me 8.5/10 Matradley:Cute! Seems just a bit gritty though. Nice font and colour, it goes well with the background 8/10 Runa: Wow, really nice sig! The black goes with the pink very well, the picture is sharp and clear and the border is awesome!!! 10/10 And about Jechtsphere's "Angel"... it's a fairy named Puck. He follows Guts (the man in Jecht's sig) around everywhere he goes.