Rate That Signature!

[KiNA]

@ Pelli.. if you drop in my thread you'll know the eason why I used the repeating Ayako

@ KK .. Love the grungy effect ..

[Wandy]

kaito-kid - 9/10 very interesting way of making your sig
nice text & lighting


weeeee Fate Fate Fate ~ >_>

v1

Spoiler:

v2

Spoiler:

Note:the sparks aren't sharpened >_>
they are from the effects I used so that's why they look "sharpened" >_>

[~Tsukuyomi]

Originally Posted by kaito-kid

@~Tsukuyomi

I like these two the most but I think you should have played a little more with the color balance, levels and brightness.

anyway, I like your work so far, but I think you should try out a new style.
and don't forget, the most important thing is to keep your work unique and original.

good luck!

Yeah, I'm still figuring out what is my style... Since I refuse to look at any tutorial, my learning curve for effects is a bit longer, though my understanding for art is a lot better than most people...

Well, on to my rating:

@Kaito Kid
Nice use of patterns, liquify/distort filters, color and text... Scanline is good, but its somewhat killing the depth of your work a little... Lighten it in various areas a little bit more to fit the lighting around the image... 8/10

@Azami
lol at same Fate image... Needs depth and more natural effect (sparks are a bit too sharpened)... 5/10

[Aoie_Emesai]

Originally Posted by Riker

@Pellissier: Yay, animated! Smooth and cute. Bias rating 9.5/10,

Exactly what I thought. ^_^ 9.5/10

[Tatsumiko]

Wow best Code geass sig ive ever seen...awesome 10/10

[Islaya]

I like it, don't know who she is but it's nice. 9/10

[Cyz]

@ Aoie_Emesai: 8/10

@ Aihiru77: Zero/Lelouch's posing is cool. Good one...although the dimensions are waay big for Animesuki. You might want to resize it. 8/10

@ Islaya: Set-chan! I like the pic. Hmm, I think shrinking the width a little might do since it's making it a little empty with all those big spaces. 8/10

[KaWaitress]

~Tsukuyomi + Nice effects and overall feel 8/10 ^_^
Aoie_Emesai + I'd love to have that Doujin xD 9/10
Tatsumiko + Kind of a holiday feel, very cheery! ^_^ 8/10
Islaya + Short and to the point, nothing like some Yuri to brighten up a sig ^_^; 8/10
Cyz + Same as always, animated in static = 9/10 ^_^

[Cyz]

@ KaWaitress: A little crowded but it was a good Haruhi pic. 8/10

[typhoon]

Cyz..i would say 9/10

nice changes of colour from left to right.

well balanced in all areas with the left side image and although the right side images are considerably smaller the animation pulls it off very well.

all in all.....an extremely well balanced perspective that is not over powered on any level (thumbs up)

typhoon

[Islaya]

Kinda hard to see the font. Good BG and blending though 8/10

[Wandy]

typhoon - 7/10 everything is good
the text needs to be repositioned because it is hard to see, and the
right side seems to be in "disarray"; did you use photo filter? because
seshoumaru's skin colour doesn't look very good :x

KaWaitress - 6.7/10 Text needs to be repositioned, too large :x
the background seems to be conflicting with each other from the
other images


C.C Fan Art! <3

[guiltygearxt]

grrr 2 many sigs 2 rate so i will just rate the 1 above me lol

Azami:
ava: nice coloring, 8/10
sig: 7/10 (good sig but dont like the color)

[Cyz]

@ guiltygearxt: A little dark but it was a good Dark Saber sig. 8/10

Mine: Well, I'm bored so I played around the Photoshop/Image Ready and....yeah. It's just a simple thing though nothing waay too special like the pofessionals in here. Hmm, I really need to learn how to handle PS

[Islaya]

It looks good to me. 8/10

[Wandy]

Cyz - 7/10 simplicity! simplicity! it makes me feel very nostalgic looking at that Cyz
lol no need to be pro XD when i first started i don't even know how to change my brushes or change opacity for my eraser lool XD


oh by the way..there are some renders here for sigs

Click me -->

Spoiler:

www.animerender.com

[guiltygearxt]

Azami rated

Cyz
ava: 9/10 (1 of my fav char in CG)
sig: 8/10 (simple but excellent pic and theme)

Islaya
ava: 7/10
sig: 8/10 (i like yuri couples)

[Cyz]

@ Islaya: The BG color doesn't seem to match but hey, Set-chan and Konoka together is 7/10

@ Azami: The BG and the C.C pic really goes hand in hand Good work! 8/10

[#ASprek8#]

@Cyz: sometimes a good image is enough to make a good sig, and yours is a nice one. 8/10

[Shadow Angel]

#ASprek8#: 8/10