[Umineko] Fan Fic EPX-4

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

Eva fell off the mansion.

lol

Eva: MY SON HATESS ME AND IS MARRYING FURNITURE BAAAAAWWWWW -dies-

:awesome: Nope

[Kets]

You know there's no awesome smiley, right?

Eva was stabbed and passed out in the mansion. When her killer was carrying her body out, he hit her head on something, permanently killing her.

[Hekate]

Bah, more wordplays >.< Ideally the story is written from someone's perspective... and IMO you really shouldn't make dead = not dead... after all it was stated in red so it should be entirely believable and the "absolute truth"

Regardless it is still true that neither Eva nor Kumasawa, who now were both outside did not kill and thus cannot be either killer or culprit. IMO it only complicates things when determining the exact order of events.

Eva was knocked unconscious, Revived and then Attempted to either go to the guest house or to the chapel

On Hideyoshi, it would still require great strength to pierce the skull, something Kumasawa is unable to do.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

You know there's no awesome smiley, right?

Eva was stabbed and passed out in the mansion. When her killer was carrying her body out, he hit her head on something, permanently killing her.

Should be : (

Nope.

@Certain_Miracle: True, but you have to remember at least one person survived the 1st twilight. At that point dead does not equal dead already. Not to say that she didn't eventually die permanently. As far as perspective goes you don't see the 1st twilight happen. And what I say is the truth - but then again, truth itself needs to be elaborated on~

Eva passed out, revived outside at one point and then attempted to get to the chapel.

And yes:

-Kumasawa did not kill Hideyoshi for that reasoning. Although the blunt object increases strength she is still too weak regardless to kill him.

[Kets]

Therefore, Nanjo killed Hideyoshi?

Eva failed to get into the chapel.

[Kets]

Oh yeah, please define dead.

[Marion]

Mmmm nope

-Eva never reached the chapel

[Hekate]

>.> Not even Beatrice's truth needs to be elaborated upon

Therefore, we can say that Either Nanjo or Genji killed Hideyoshi.

And along the way to the chapel, Eva recieved her killing blow which was the wound that made guts slightly visible. So far the axe seems pretty lame too, although it seems unprepared, which would mean it is...pretty good?

State in red:
-No one mutilated Hideyoshi
-Genji did not change his uniform due to blood until he carried Shannon

[Kets]

Wait...Since the 1st Twilight survivor killed Hideyoshi, and neither Kumasawa nor Nanjo killed Kumasawa, someone other than Kumasawa or Nanjo survived?

[Marion]

@Kets:
Your Nanjo killed Hideyoshi theory is wrong because you have failed to tell me why Nanjo survived. You don't even know how he died for starters.

@Certain_Miracle: Well Beatrice hates Battler and I love you guys~~~

Wrong.

And wrong.

-No one mutilated Hideyoshi

Genji did not change his uniform due to blood until he carried Shannon
I refuse to repeat.

And my axe is lame, huhh? Don't worry, this axing was well-prepared. I'm sure you won't get it for a while.

[Kets]

And I love you too. <3

Can we do another minigame?

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

And I love you too. <3

Can we do another minigame?

No.

One game a day~

[Kets]

Fine...I'll ask in three hours and six minutes.

Please recreate the scene right after Kinzo is killed.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

Fine...I'll ask in three hours and six minutes.

Please recreate the scene right after Kinzo is killed.

After Kinzo died Gohda wrote a note on the desk and then moved Kinzo out of the room.

[Hekate]

Since the contrapositive was wrong, would Neither Genji nor Nanjo killed Hideyoshi?

I claim that if we can prove only Nanjo/"insert someone supposedly dead" could have killed someone, we proved that they lived and shouldn't be denied for that reason >.< lol

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Certain Miracle

Since the contrapositive was wrong, would Neither Genji nor Nanjo killed Hideyoshi?

I claim that if we can prove only Nanjo/"insert someone supposedly dead" could have killed someone, we proved that they lived and shouldn't be denied for that reason >.< lol

At this point you only three people that could have killed Hideyoshi.

-Nanjo, who you have not proven died fully
-Genji
or the third choice
1st Twilight Survivor Y

I stated that at least one survived. Yet have you thought that maybe another survived. What if they all survived??

[Hekate]

It cannot be another survivor, since Kinzo, Kyrie, Rudolph did not kill and Kumasawa cannot kill (although she may aid)

[Kets]

I request to see Gohda's note.

[Marion]

Hehehehe

Kahahhahahahaa!!~~

My perfect trapping!

Do you see now? I killed Hideyoshi. You have just accepted that truth with those words! Ahahahaha!

@Kets:

Gohda's note? Get his investigation log and you can have it.

Otherwise, no

[Kets]

I request Gohda's investigation log.