Rate that Avatar

[sarcasteak]

Originally Posted by PK

You guys are all wrong about my outer border!! In fact, your mistakes are so humongous that I'll even make an explanatory image for now and for the future


Sarc, now it's not so strange that you like it that way ^^

Fine then...I shall dock points! XD

Originally Posted by PK

This one!

Ohhhh, Chikage...nah, that one is too elegant for me. Don't you think so?

I'll let it "hung" for a while until it stops swinging. What, you say it'll never stop swinging? Nonsense! Go retake your physics course!


...


Avaj - Well done. My only minor minor gripe is that white stroke outside the green on the bottom right is a bit too much compared to all the other whites; otherwise, perfect. 9.9/10

[X-1000]

sarcasteak I know where your avatar came from. It's from Galaxy Angels right. Anyway, your avatar is cool at the same time funny. 8/10

[hobobaggins]

MidoriShinobi- i saw your new avatar and hurried over, but alas you had already changed it.

your last avatar= 10/10 for doing that to "your" face

this avatar is nice, pleasant, but... not quite you. she needs to have SOME green SOMEwhere.

9/10

[Meatwad]

sarcasteak: 6/10

[Don Roberto]

Could you rate this one:

sarcasteak: ...Interesting... that's about all I can say besides a smooth loop. uh 8.5/10

[sarcasteak]

Don Roberto - Nice looking guy...presumeably Cloud? The transparency doesn't hurt nor help, but I'd like to see the background... 8.7/10

[Ambience Blue]

Hobobaggins: Hooray for the half-border! An 8.99/10 for you!

Avaj: I love the colors. The border around the ears is very well done also. 9.1/10

Hobbsy: Not a bad av, but there's some weird dude in the upper right corner... confused... 7.5/10

MidoriShinobi: Cute. Looks like a chibi Morrigan 8/10

Shay: Very nice shadow. Perhaps the border could be a lighter pink. 8.5/10

Necrodeath: Whoa. Trippy background and Monopoly-esque dude = plus points. It's very original. 8.8/10

Aahhsin: LOL! X-men! It's a good image and for some reason, I like it. 9/10

7thMethuselah: Very very cute. You do those animated ones pretty well 9.5/10

Sarcasteak: Ummm.... No idea what to think... (Obviously I haven't seen that show) 7.9/10

Oneesama: Very nice image with appropriate border. 8/10

Thany: I liked your old caption (answer to Aahhsin). Oh well, it's cute, and the border is great as usual. 9.6/10

PriestessKikyo: Ooh. A stamp effect. It works well, though it would be cooler if the transparency were more detailed. 9.85, still.

Don_Roberto: The Cloud avy is very well done. 9.2/10

[sarcasteak]

Meatwad - Appropriate captioning but nothing spectacular. 7/10

Ambience Blue - A pretty picture of Nayuki! I commend your use of gradient white border here; a very peaceful, glowy feel that matches the subject well... 9.5/10

Originally Posted by Ambience Blue

Hobbsy: Not a bad av, but there's some weird dude in the upper right corner... confused... 7.5/10

I also agree that he should be removed, but perhaps hobbsy wants the boy in because of his involvement in the depicted scene...

Spoiler for Elfen Lied spoiler!:

Young Lucy befriends a puppy. Some boys beat it to death. Lucy finds out. Lucy turns the boys into a bloody mess.

[MidoriShinobi]

@DonRoberto - Midori likes Shino very much!! I like the loop on the GIF, as well. 9/10

[X-1000]

Midorishinobi I like your new avatar seems to me that the girl in it was prettier than the other one. Anyway... 8/10

[JOJOS'STAR]

Don Roberto

8.8/10 for that one. Realy good. I don't like gifs avatar so..

MidoriShinobi
You did a nice job. Good croping ^^ 9/10

X-1000 Must.. change.. this one...

[whatever123]

first time rating, first time making an avatar

JOJOS'STAR nice quality 8/10

MidoriShinobi nice quality but there is something about the girl that anoyes me 6.5/10

X-1000 scary 6/10

sarcasteak nice 6/10

edit:uploaded the wrong avatar

[Sakura-chan]

Ambience Blue - shiny... ._. 9/10

[hobobaggins]

Originally Posted by whatever123

first time rating, first time making an avatar

good for you! however there are some things that need work.

1) border: way too thick
2) color: too dark, cant see your source very well
3) dual border: ??? both are too thick.

once you clean that up you should be in the 8-9 range. but for now, 5/10

[xargon]

JOJOS'STAR: I really like the simplicity within that avtar, its really nice. 9.35/10

[hobobaggins]

Ambience Blue- oh my god. no border???

its like a dream come true. that and the swirlyness (err... she is spinning)

10/10



xargon - i think yours is overly simple, with a lack of sharpness/quality. looks like a screencap. 8/10, because the major rocks. and stones for that matter.

your sig however has the proper sharpness ^^

[MikoKikyo]

I hate to be the one to break this up to you Hobo, but Ambience Blue's av actually does have a border it's white and very thin, but it's there.

Ambience Blue the border is hardly visible! Lol! But image is really beautiful 9.3/10

xargon good animation, I like how it zooms in on her face when she closes her eyes. 8.4/10

Sakura-chan heh? a strange, animated, cartoonish figure and.. gir? o_O 7.5/10

whatever123 hey not bad for a first timer... border may really be a bit too thick, and a tad too dark. 8/10

[Tzurial]

sakura chan- evil gir !! *heart* and ohh transparency! He seems a little pixally on the edges, but who am I kidding if I say my ratings arent biased 10/10!!

whatever123- 6/10 If that's Ratio, I can barely see him ;__; lighten it up a bit and dont let the color get so saturated

[Don Roberto]

Originally Posted by sarcasteak

Don Roberto - Nice looking guy...presumeably Cloud? The transparency doesn't hurt nor help, but I'd like to see the background... 8.7/10

Are you sure you want to see the backgound, its just solid white.

Sakura-chan: 8.7/10

[AKS74u]

just threw this together, needed something for these forums... its pretty simple