Rate That Signature!

[ReaperxKingx]

Ganbaru: 8.7/10 really catches the essence of Halloween for some reason, I like it.
Krytonis: 8.9/10 excellent color and placement of image.

[Kotohono]

Krytonis: 9.3/10 simply but very well themed with the color and general look of it I like it.
ReaperxKingx: 8.7/10 the text font/color and border both suit the image and effects nicely.
ganbaru: 8/10 has a solid dark feel to it with the faded look which seems fitting for the context.

[ganbaru]

Konakaga 8,1/10 not a bad photo

[Kirito]

ReaperxKingx 8.6/10 - The design and the colors look truly pretty. Impressive!
Konakaga 8.9/10 - Quite the Emiri Kato selection you have. Nicely done and great tastes in characters, as usual.

[ganbaru]

Kirito 8,3/10 could use a border

[Krytonis]

ganbaru: 8.5/10 good focus on the image and good quote

[mystogan]

ganbaru-8.5, nice lines there goes good with the image
Krytonis-9, i love the asuna sig, it is detailed and nice quality image and has your lighting string effect as well,
Kirito-8, nice goth character in it for the halloween, but there could be more work on the art and background

[Kaihan]

mystogan: Great effect on the sig and image of Erza. 8.8/10
Krytonis: Maybe need some work on the text but it's a nice looking sig. 8.6/10
ganbaru: Interesting sig. 8.8/10
Kirito: It's not time yet. Lovely sig. 8.7/10

[mystogan]

Kaihan- 9.7, totally awsome sig, great art, coloring and it's shading is just so good and the slightly changing frames in it makes it perfect

[Kotohono]

Kaihan: I don't see how it could possible better, I agree with mystogan pretty on the points of it 10/10
mystogan: the border feels a bit too large to me, especially on the left and right edges, but nice art and text fits it nicely, 8.5/10

[Krytonis]

Konakaga: 8.5/10 I recognize some of the characters

[Tsundere Louise]

Konakaga - cute signature. 8/10.
S-So how do you like mine for this month? I'm trying to find a decent one for Xmas, but so far no luck.

[ganbaru]

Tsundere Louise 8,2/10 a bit too simple, it worked better for the previous one.

[Krytonis]

Tsundere Louise: 8.2/10 you can try zooming in on the character more since the whiteness of the signature makes it really empty

[Tsundere Louise]

Y-Yeah, but then you wouldn't notice the candy and the witch's hat too much... G-Geez, I-I'll think of something better for the next Halloween.

[Midnight2352]

Tsundere Louise: 8.7/10 - I honestly love you signature but i have to say that the name by itself in the signature makes it look lonely there. If there was colour in the background, it would look better.

ganbaru: 7/10 - I don't quite get the signature since the poem you put does not exactly fit the picture you have. I don't know...i may just be me.

I have changed my signature but did my own twist in it. It looks different now as i have taken your opinions and place the words in the picture itself. How have i done now?

[ganbaru]

Midnight2352 8,3/10 the border is a bit too thick. For the text, a wider signature would allow to put it on less but longer line.

Originally Posted by Midnight2352

ganbaru: 7/10 - I don't quite get the signature since the poem you put does not exactly fit the picture you have. I don't know...i may just be me.

The poem is in fact a small part of one bigger, like my current signature is part of a serie. Sometime the quote on a individual sig isn't fitting that much, usualy because I think of it also as a part of a serie and not simply as a individual signature.

[Midnight2352]

Thanks ganbaru. I'll reduce the thickness. The text, however, was intended to be like that since it is somewhat like a short poem.

I understand where you are coming from with your signature.

[Tsundere Louise]

G-Geez... I-I will try harder on the Xmas one, okay? B-But there aren't any images that are good enough...

[NoemiChan]

Midnight2352 - 7.3/ 10 personalized???? Like it.. Hope you made it wider though..

Tsundere Louise - 7.5 /10... nice pic