[Umineko] Fan Fic EPX-4

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

I request Gohda's investigation log.

No.

Get it in a game and you can request it.

And no, I won't make a game now.

[Hekate]

Originally Posted by Marion

Hehehehe

Kahahhahahahaa!!~~

My perfect trapping!

Do you see now? I killed Hideyoshi. You have just accepted that truth with those words! Ahahahaha!

Incorrect, unless you can say this in red: Neither Genji nor Nanjo killed Hideyoshi

The note Gohda wrote told Genji to lie about Kinzo

[Marion]

Aww but if I do that your soul will be crushed~ I feel kinda bad too, because of the mistake you are making.

-Neither Genji nor Nanjo killed Hideyoshi
-A human killed Hideyoshi

Incorrect.

-The note Gohda wrote just informed the reader that Kinzo was killed by Beatrice

[Kets]

Therefore, Nanjo did not survive the 1st Twilight.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

Therefore, Nanjo did not survive the 1st Twilight.

Wrong due to reasoning.

At least one survived. But if two survived then only one killed and the other didn't. Understand?

Also, it's not in blue : (~

[Hekate]

Repeat in red:
-All of the "Insert person here" did not kill statements and all "Insert person here" did not kill Hideyoshi statements in red are absolutely true for the duration of the game
-There is no "Hinamizawa syndrome" that causes Hideyoshi to kill himself lol

Also, Kanon did not kill Hideyoshi because he was being watched by Krauss + being carried by Gohda.

If Kanon did not kill Hideyoshi, then it follows that Kyrie survived the 1st twilight and Kyrie killed Hideyoshi. This is because all other people did not kill Hideyoshi.

Hopefully I'm right, and it should be proof that if red is used properly, it can only help the human side.

[Marion]

-There is no Hinamizawa syndrome. That's so 4 years ago 9_9

All of the "Insert person here" did not kill statements and all "Insert person here" did not kill Hideyoshi statements in red are absolutely true for the duration of the game.
So not repeating this. That's like killing my entire game board in one swift move :U

-Kanon did not kill Hideyoshi

Hmph...

-Rudolph did not kill
-Eva did not kill
-Nanjo did not kill Hideyoshi
-Kinzo did not kill
-Kumasawa did not kill Hideyoshi
-Genji did not kill Hideyoshi









.....ahahahaha. Tell me, how long were you stuck in that pit? Was it fun trying to climb out? You must be so grateful I helped you if the least bit by extending the rope of blue.

-Kyrie survived the 1st twilight and killed Hideyoshi.

Now let's see you solve this game in a week.

[Kets]

Please define killed and dead.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

Please define killed and dead.

Killed: Attacked and rendered incapable of moving or doing anything
Dead: I already defined this.

:U

Therefore, when people are killed they sometimes die (-shot-)

[Hekate]

Sadly I don't think we'll solve it in 1 week T.T tbh it was boring, I simply had to recheck everything and cross out impossibilities one by one....

Would refusing to repeat that sentence mean that Even if it says Kinzo did not kill in red, we must consider the possibility of Kinzo killing to be true?

Possibly Kyrie saw Hideyoshi awake even though he was drugged and that is the reason Kyrie killed Hideyoshi. Kyrie suspected Hideyoshi had planned to kill.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Certain Miracle

Sadly I don't think we'll solve it in 1 week T.T tbh it was boring, I simply had to recheck everything and cross out impossibilities one by one....

Would refusing to repeat that sentence mean that Even if it says Kinzo did not kill in red, we must consider the possibility of Kinzo killing to be true?

Possibly Kyrie saw Hideyoshi awake even though he was drugged and that is the reason Kyrie killed Hideyoshi. Kyrie suspected Hideyoshi had planned to kill.

It actually gets more interesting in later parts, but you guys mostly focused on the boring parts of it sadly </3 Besides, that's what mostly Umineko is: just eliminating possibilities. The game makes it look funner because Battler is a loser who can't even make correct recitals or think through things half the time

No.

-Kinzo did not kill anyone was already stated. So he surely did not kill anyone.

And that's wrong

[Kets]

Kyrie killed Hideyoshi in revenge for Rudolf's death.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

Kyrie killed Hideyoshi in revenge for Rudolf's death.

Incorrect.

[Hekate]

Then Kyrie killed Hideyoshi because she wanted his gun. Everyone wants a gun right? Except George...

So far we have 5 people who can still kill for the 1st twilight, which are Gohda (he can kill more), Krauss, Kanon, Nanjo, and Kumasawa (I swear it was stated she didn't kill somewhere, but it's not on the red list ) We also have a possibility of either Natsuhi, Hideyoshi, and Rosa waking up and killing, then falling asleep.

I still suspect that Krauss killed Rudolph. After all, Krauss got a knife, Rudolph might be an unnecessary witness... Can you confirm or deny this theory in red?

[Marion]

I didn't state 'Kumasawa didn't kill'. If I did it would be on the list after my giant update. I'll look again tomorrow but I promise you I didn't make such a recital. And if I did, then my bad. If you can find it tell me the page and I'll add it right away.

-Kyrie did not kill for Hideyoshi's gun

How about I give you a light hint-

-The person who woke up saw a murder committed but cannot recall it.

As for your theory about Krauss killing Rudolph: it's wrong.

I need to get going soon.

[Kets]

Kyrie killed Hideyoshi because she became mentally ill.

[Marion]

Originally Posted by Kets

Kyrie killed Hideyoshi because she became mentally ill.

Incorrect.

[Hekate]

Mmm well I'm not exactly sure if Kumasawa did not kill was stated in red... it's just that when working on Hideyoshi's murderer I kept thinking "Kumasawa didn't kill anyone was stated in red" even though it wasn't on the list not sure if I just assumed she didn't kill or something.

Repeat in red:
The person who woke up saw a murder committed but cannot recall it ever, not even the slightest.

Because if that's not true, then it's just major evidence that Rosa woke up and what she recalls slightly (aka gut feeling) forms the basis of her suspicion against Krauss (I'm very sure "Krauss and Rosa suspected each other for more than just sibling rivalry" was stated in red or was a correct theory; it forms my belief in suspecting Rosa woke up after all)

Also, because of the symptoms of roofies, although the person woke up, they were unable to move.

[Kets]

Kyrie killed Hideyoshi to see if fluff would come out. :awesome:

Kyrie killed Hideyoshi because Hideyoshi attacked her 1st.

[Marion]

The person who woke up saw a murder committed but cannot recall it ever, not even the slightest.
I refuse to repeat this.

-The person who woke up eventually remembered the murder they saw.
-The person who woke up could not move around very much

@Kets:

Wrong