Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

Wolley (posted) 8,6/10 looking good
(used ) the second picture make the total signature42 pixels too high
Dragonar Fan 8,1/10 not much to say

[JRendell]

MetalCookie: Interesting gradient maps. 8/10
Halad: Nice use of the red lighting there. 9/10
Emerald: Not sure if the green works very well, but Yui looks cute as a chibi reindeer. 7/10

[Marlan35]

JRendell: 9/9 ^.~

*sighs* be easy on mee, all of my good haruhi signatures are XXX x 200+

[Suomi]

9/10 JR, very nice use of transparency and adorable!
10/10 ganbaru, gorgeous color and composition.

(btw, my sig is supposed to have a border but I think imageshack somehow got rid iof it...)

[Marlan35]

bleh, i just quickly made this... some minor modifications what do you think?

[Mr. Wang]

@JRendell Good, I like signatures that have some transparency and go beyond the norm of the rectangular signatures. Even the links on the right side of it kinda makes it have an organized, complete look. I'm also noticing the addition of a santa hat I plan on doing that to my own signature soon... 9.1/10

@Marlan35 Good concept, and I like it, though it needs quite a bit of anti-aliasing, and smoothing out in general. 8/10

@Illusore I personally see a border, though it looks very thin, unless you look for it. The sheet music, and the faded rose add a very serene, peaceful looking effect. 8.7/10

[Marlan35]

Originally Posted by Mr. Wang

@JRendell Good, I like signatures that have some transparency and go beyond the norm of the rectangular signatures. Even the links on the right side of it kinda makes it have an organized, complete look. I'm also noticing the addition of a santa hat I plan on doing that to my own signature soon... 9.1/10

@Marlan35 Good concept, and I like it, though it needs quite a bit of anti-aliasing, and smoothing out in general. 8/10

@Illusore I personally see a border, though it looks very thin, unless you look for it. The sheet music, and the faded rose add a very serene, peaceful looking effect. 8.7/10

umm, did you rate the black and white siggy i had or the black and red one i have now??

[Drake]

Mr. Wang Nice use of transparency =] its becoming a rarity these days 8/10

[Mr. Wang]

Originally Posted by Marlan35

umm, did you rate the black and white siggy i had or the black and red one i have now??

I rated the black and white one, you must have posted your new one before I was done finishing my rating

Anyway, I see quite a bit of that Haruhi image, and for what has been done here, the colors and theme is good, though I wonder how much of it is edited or kept from its original source image. It's good, and I can tell the borders are custom, though perhaps I think the fact the signature's shown twice is a tad unnecessary. 8.5/10

[ganbaru]

JRendell 8,7/10 nice Chrismass version
Illusore 8,8/10 good looking
Marlan35 8,6/10 you could use just one of the two picture
Drake 8,9/10 nice one

[Marlan35]

Originally Posted by Mr. Wang

I rated the black and white one, you must have posted your new one before I was done finishing my rating

Anyway, I see quite a bit of that Haruhi image, and for what has been done here, the colors and theme is good, though I wonder how much of it is edited or kept from its original source image. It's good, and I can tell the borders are custom, though perhaps I think the fact the signature's shown twice is a tad unnecessary. 8.5/10

i made a slight error when trying to find my damn image adress, i had to search trough over 120 adresses in notepad... oh well i love your signature

[CMSensei]

Ganbaru 9/10 pretty, vivid, warm colors.

[Haladflire65]

Mr. Wang: Great transparency. 8.7/10
JR: Lovely and great transparency, 8.9/10
ganbaru: Nice colours. 8.9/10
CM: Good one. 8.9/10

[OgodItsKanon]

@Marlan35: I like the effect on the right(: 9.1/10
@CMHerrera: Nice! 9/10

[Marlan35]

Originally Posted by OgodItsKanon

@Marlan35: I like the effect on the right(: 9.1/10
@CMHerrera: Nice! 9/10

You do? Wow, i never tought it would be THAT good, i was just experimenting
And your signature gets 9.9/10 I just love the facial expresion

[Dist]

^7/10 It's okay but the right side being black 'n white is distracting, has bad quality and for some reason is 160px while the left side is 159px.

Additionally, the forum rules state maximum of 500px width which you've just broke, and since the right side is 160px, you can't have any text underneath either. Also what did you mean with the post of all your haruhi images being XXX + 200 ? If that's supposed to mean in file size, you may just request a resize in the signature thread. It's easy to do, without loss of quality.

[Marlan35]

Originally Posted by Dist

^7/10 It's okay but the right side being black 'n white is distracting, has bad quality and for some reason is 160px while the left side is 159px.

Additionally, the forum rules state maximum of 500px width which you've just broke, and since the right side is 160px, you can't have any text underneath either. Also what did you mean with the post of all your haruhi images being XXX + 200 ? If that's supposed to mean in file size, you may just request a resize in the signature thread. It's easy to do, without loss of quality.

the bad quality whas intentional, i was just experementing and liked the style and ill start working on the size isue right away

[Haladflire65]

Dist: Lovely one by Patchy. I feel the left is a bit empty though. 8.8/10

[Marlan35]

Haladflire65: 9/10, great effects, really well made

[The Chaos]

Illusore..pretty..8.8/10