2009-10-09, 02:43 | Link #21344 |
Senior Member
Author
|
I see that someone loves Signum.
In many ways, I don't disagree with this attributes breakdown approach - I agree with your take on Hayate as a pure hardcore mage type, for example - but Signum is almost broken here, while I wonder why you think that Fate's defense is complete crap. I'd take Signum's Agility and/or Defense down a little bit, while upping Fate's Defense a fair bit. Those two should be very close to one another, as they struck me as very evenly matched fighters in Nanoha A's. Other than that, nice job! Good pics too.
__________________
|
2009-10-09, 02:57 | Link #21345 | |
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
Quote:
I do agree with taking down Signum's agility a peg or two. She's a hard hitter, sacrificing grace for power. My personal iffy about the graph is that Hayate outclasses all of them in terms of mana and attack, yet the graph is unable to display this. |
|
2009-10-09, 03:09 | Link #21346 | |
Senior Member
Author
|
No, Fate's defense is not crap. You don't become a great melee fighter with sucky defense, Keroko.
Fate's defensive spells are fine. She successfully shielded herself, with a magic shield, from one of Nanoha's best blast attacks in their final battle in the original Nanoha anime. I don't see any evidence at all that Fate has "low defensive spells". Just because Fate dodges a lot doesn't mean she has "low defensive spells". That's like saying that since Superman dodges attacks sometimes, he can't withstand them. No, it's just that he instinctively dodges, or he doesn't want to risk the attacks hurting him if he doesn't know how potent they are. Also, in Fate's case, why waste magic energy making shields when she's so good at dodging? Finally, a defense value should count for more than just "defensive spells". It should count for physical defense as well. Fate uses Bardiche very well as a defensive weapon at times. Quote:
I really see no good reason for Fate's defense to be significantly lower than Nanoha's.
__________________
|
|
2009-10-09, 03:24 | Link #21347 |
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
I had a nice post typed up... but then I realized we're dragging the thread off-topic, so I ported the post to the generic thread.
|
2009-10-09, 03:33 | Link #21349 |
Sword Wielding Penguin
|
If you're going to match them up...
It matches up as thus in canon. Fate Favors speedblitzing over tanking and precision over power. She starts out towards the balanced end of the spectrum, but favors rotating her stats to a speed and firepower edge as she 'powers up'. Emphasising her desire to hit first, hit hard, and be gone before the return fire. Her specialty would be strike. Signum, as a classic full warrior case, favors an ideal balance. If anything, Signum is the Mario of the group. Her speed is balanced with her defense, armor, skills and power. She excels in nothing, but can handle everything equally well. She'd be an ideal escort. Nanoha is a tank. She favors blasting her opponents until they give up, maneuvering a little, simply shrugging off what she does get hit with and keeps on trucking. Her firepower is strong and balances with her defenses. Prolonged assault is right up her ally. Hayate said it herself. She's absurd in close combat. She's a glass cannon. She's a cute artillery piece that suffers from a severe issue if you get inside her attack sphere. She's field artillery. |
2009-10-09, 07:34 | Link #21353 |
The Hawk
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Berlin, Fatherland
|
I agree that Signum is broken there, but I put it that way because I honestly see no weaknesses of her. It's not like she's "no weaknesses, no strength". She excels everywhere. She's a prime example of a Lightning Bruiser. And as far as I know, she won most of the matches against Fate (In the Sound Stages?) and still was as strong as Nanoha after StrikerS, despite the Wolkenritter never actually getting stronger. In fact, their power is fading away in the process of becoming more human, I think.
Take her first fight with Fate, for example. She blocks her lightning attack with her Panzergeist magic. Without even flinching. Then she goes ultra-speed and disappears from Fate's vision only to go from below and crush her shield and Bardiche in one blow. And Fate's defense is weak. What's with the "Are you crazy, if you take one blow like that, you're down" coming from every opponent, including Signum. She said so herself, if she takes a hard hit in Sonic Form, she's done for. I should however mention, and this is important, that those attributes are no exact values. It's only how their strengths are distributed. For example, just because Nanoha and Hayate both have maximum strength does not mean both are equal in terms of power. It means that they both have power as their best attribute. At least I think so. I realize that it's not the best system, maybe I'll remake it. The thing is, I have no idea how to compare them in terms of power and speed, when one relies on strong physical attacks and the other one on beams. Suggestions are appreciated, of course. Spoiler for Oh, and here's the picture:
__________________
|
2009-10-09, 20:54 | Link #21359 |
I'm Back
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Land of Lincoln
|
Here it is:
Focuses on Ginga and Cinque in a French maid outfit. http://rapidshare.com/files/29093705...on-h__C75_.zip
__________________
|
Tags |
images, nanoha, nsfw |
|
|