2006-04-04, 11:33 | Link #61 |
Shikachu
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
I seriously doubt Oda has ever sat down and watched any foreign country's release of the anime, it's beyond his world. You realize that a lot of other countries have dubbed and edited One Piece before the US got it. Although nobody else did quite as bad of a job. :P
|
2006-04-04, 11:45 | Link #62 | |
Waiting for more taiyuki!
Join Date: Jan 2004
|
Quote:
FUNimation successfully completed their 1000 Paper Crane Project to ask for a second season of Fruits Basket. If you combine it with legal physical evidence (like a copy of the Region 2 DVD and Region 1 DVD containing the same episode for comparison ) and a reasonable petition taking into account cultural variations in how to go about this type of thing, it may be taken seriously by mainstream.
__________________
|
|
2006-04-04, 12:22 | Link #63 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
It could be that neither Toei or Oda know just how severe the editing is... Toei just doesn't care, and Oda could just be saying "ah it can't be THAT bad"... Sure it's been dubbed and edited before, but what 4kids has done is just plain insulting and disrespectful... a lot of artists would be pissed off |
|
2006-04-04, 13:32 | Link #65 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Hence why i used the term "could be"...
Like wingdarkness said, the jury is still out on Oda It's uncertain whether or not he cares about what happens outside of Japan... and it could be that he only really cares about the manga, as in "as long as they don't butcher the manga, then i don't care". Though if he doesn't care about such butchering, i have to say that, personally, my respect for him would weaken slightly... allowing his work to be insulted in such a way, it's just seems to show a lack of care... One of reasons why i give so much respect to Miyazaki is because i know that he thoughly cares about his work, no matter what country its in I wouldn't expect Oda to do something about it cause he doesn't have that kind of authority over the anime, but i would hope to hear that he was atleast ticked off by it... If it were my work, i would find it very hard to keep quite about such butchery to my work |
2006-04-04, 17:12 | Link #67 | |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
Quote:
--->"Way to go for an anime fan, about time you took off the blinkers...." I have no clue what this means could the baka who wrote this please explain? If you wanna get me, I should understand what i'm reading... As for Oda at this point it seems impossible to me that he doesn't know anything...There's a Japanese Cartoon Network that shows programs like Powerpuff girls and Justice League (which are fairly popular shows)...One Piece has almost if not 100 + episodes dubbed and i know if it was me I'd sneek a peek at one or two of them if I had any kind of caring for my product...This is a situation where his apparent lack of caring is glaring...Unless Toei is silencing him I see no other reasoning than he really doesn't give a damn...Because if he caught just 1 or 2 eps he'd see enuff to atleast make some miniscule press release or answer some rouge reporters question as to his feelings on it...One Piece dubbed has been on the air for nearly 2 years, in 2006 it seems unbelieveable to me you can't find one comment positive or negative from the creator of the show...You'd think something would have leaked out...Before the hack there was a thread talking about how he was involved in the 4kids takeover...Perhaps he got duped, but if he did something would have leaked, cause in these situations something always does, unless "said" person doesn't really care at all...I'm sure there are One Piece fans even more diligent than us that are writing letters directly to Oda or folding paper airplanes throwing them in his direction...telling him about how bad his work has been butchered...To think Oda knows nothing is a huge stretch IMO...
__________________
|
|
2006-04-04, 19:44 | Link #68 |
Shikachu
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
I never said Oda knows nothing...but I don't think it's really a stretch to think he hasn't seen the English dub. Sure they show Japanese dubs of American shows in Japan, but they don't show English dubs of anime when they have the original airing right there. I don't see what the logic of bringing that up is. The only way Oda would be able to see those English episodes is if someone is sending him DVDs. The guy is awfully busy as it is writing and illustrating a manga, handling business, and living a married life, I don't know if he's got the time to sit and watch the English, Spanish, German, French, Italian, Indonesian, Singaporian and every other dub out there. He most likely leaves most of the business decisions of the anime to Toei and Shueisha...that's their purpose for existing, after all.
|
2006-04-04, 20:45 | Link #69 | |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
Quote:
As for the rest of your post your just going overboard...Yeah he draws manga day and night, but he still has time for some sembelance of a life (Last time I checked being married doesn't mean you can't watch or comment on a 30 minute program you created)....Atleast enuff of a life to at some point have some type of knowledge about 4kids (especially if the rumors are true that he also signed off on the 4kids takeover)...I'm not talking about watching a 30 episode marathon then writing a thesis report on the horrible editing, I'm just saying "Knowing about it"...Saying ONE WORD about it...Having some type of opinion leaked....I'm sure someone at sometime at some place has mentioned something about this to him...He isn't too busy to make a 10 second comment is he? I think you give him too much of a pass on not knowing jack...You act like drawing the manga and married life takes up every single nano-millasecond of everything he's all about...Surely he has time for one comment or one reflection...I'd bet my life on the fact that he's seen the show, furthermore isn't the manga in America changing names of stuff like Zolo and other elements of the manga..Your argument is always he's SOOOO Busy with the manga he doesn't have a clock tick to think about anything else...Surely he knows about the manga changes in America right? If he knows absolutley nothing about nothing about nothing then he's a rare breed indeed, because you hear opinions from other show//manga creators on how their product is being reproduced all the time [and I'm not talking about HUGE reports, just something, anything]...
__________________
|
|
2006-04-04, 22:19 | Link #70 |
Shikachu
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
Jeez, talk about going overboard. XD
Let me quote myself: "I never said Oda knows nothing" Which you keep assuming I said. All I said is that I doubt he's watched the English dub. Also know that Oda doesn't speak English, so watching the dub wouldn't enlighten him on the horrible dialogue. He would have to happen to watch some of the really badly edited scenes, like Arlong pointing at Bellamere, Luffy being turned upside-down, etc.. He may have heard some feedback from fans. But to what extent, or whether he really cares, nobody knows. |
2006-04-04, 22:24 | Link #71 |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
I'm just saying your going overboard in your defense of his ignorance and virtual lack of time in his life to consider any of this...But yeah I went overboard aswell because I just think the guy deserves a little more credit than he's oblivious because he's married and works on the manga alot...
__________________
|
2006-04-15, 19:58 | Link #72 |
I'll keep walking.
Artist
|
Hah, not a big fan of one piece, yet found this quite funny after reading the topic and seeing the hole movement against 4kids (Of which, though not because One Piece, I'm a strong suppoter).
http://www.vgcats.com/comics/?strip_id=145 :P
__________________
|
2006-04-15, 20:08 | Link #74 |
Shikachu
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
Yeah, that's a pretty old strip.
And this is an old Flash posted many times but always worth another view. http://www.deviantart.com/deviation/11707485/ |
2006-04-16, 10:55 | Link #76 | |
Master of The Sword
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
This monstrosity of a dub should not be allowed to continue, it has tarnished the image of OP, anywhere their version of the dub is shown. It will only kill the popularity then build it. Last edited by MihawkXGP; 2006-04-16 at 14:40. |
|
2006-04-16, 22:25 | Link #77 |
Senior Member
|
I see nothing wrong with what 4kids is doing. just complaing, honestly everyone here should know the original versions are always better then the dubs. i'm fairly content with whatever anime 4kids puts out. I guess im runnign the 4 kids high, becuase they produce all the animes i watch on regular tv. (not fortunate enough to have cable or satallite) no CN for me. But thats my opnion.
__________________
|
2006-04-17, 01:56 | Link #79 | |
Shikachu
Join Date: Nov 2004
|
Quote:
I actually LIKE lots of anime dubs just as much or better than the original. It's not a matter of taste. The 4Kids dub is so horribly butchered it's not even the same show. One Piece is probably one of the worst dubs EVER in the history of anime and it's a crying shame to be on TV. |
|
|
|